• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Which of these judgements best Reflects the State of Imperial Russia in 1914? By 1914 all the Signs were there that Imperial Russia was heading towards a Major Confrontation between intransient Tsarism and the Forces of Change or

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Which of these judgements best Reflects the State of Imperial Russia in 1914? "By 1914 all the Signs were there that Imperial Russia was heading towards a Major Confrontation between intransient Tsarism and the Forces of Change" or "The Prospects of Stable evolutionary Development in 1914 were good until Foreign Affairs Intervened" Hanoom 13Sh The 1905 revolution had tested the strength of Tsarism at its core. However, the survival of the regime was due to the fact that whilst in 1905 the Russian rebels were confidant enough to voice their discontent they were not on a mission to usurp tsarist authority. It can be argued that whilst there was an active petitioning for change in 1905 by 1914 many critics came to the realisation that real change under despotic and authoritarian Tsarism was a long way off. But whether or not this itself had set Russia on an irreversible path against the established system is debatable. The main argument against the intervention of foreign affairs being instrumental in stopping Russia's prospects of stable evolutionary development is that Nicholas did not keep to one of the key concessions of the October Manifesto by a granting constitutional monarchy. Nicholas had absolutely no intention of handing power to the people and the Duma was the creation of an urgent need to appease the 1905 rebels. ...read more.

Middle

But partly the innate conservatism of the Russian people meant that this lack of strong alternative leadership to Nicholas in 1914 was something that resulted in any critics of the regime being unsure of whom to support. The opposition was inherently disunited and the alliances of different social groups were hard to fathom in a society where traditional division had always stood between the upper and lower classes. Another explanation for the failure of groups like the Kadets and the Liberals to gain the active support of the public is that their concern for securing a constitution subordinated the social welfare of the people who did not feel that their cause was being fought for. By 1914 the opposing parties to the tsarist regime were much less powerful than in 1905. The liberals were no longer seen as revolutionary and Witte's liberal concessions had split the opposition. Therefore anyone who wanted change did not think it achievable through a weak, liberal Duma with little influence. Consequently supporting the Bolsheviks in 1917 was a powerful alternative as it empowered a group of extremists willing to make vigorous changes. During the years 1908-1914 Russia was moving quickly forward, trying to develop its stagnant and backward economy. ...read more.

Conclusion

This was exacerbated by a power struggle between the Duma and Rasputin who was seen as manipulating the tsarina and steering the country closer to catastrophe. The war was the force, which interrupted Russia's progression into a more Western and developed society with better standards of living and equality. On the home front the food shortages, starvation in the big cities, coal shortages in the merciless Russian winter and inflation ensured a demoralised and exasperated population. The hopeless situation in Russia would later spark what was to be the end of tsarist Russia as Nicholas survived as long as he maintained the loyalty of the army and the Cossacks. Had it not been for the war these key groups would have remained loyal to Nicholas, especially due to the progressive and westward looking path that Russia was on. It is likely that at the end of Nicholas' reign the Duma would have become a far more influential body and that his royal successors would have paid greater heed to the advice of the assembly. Obviously it cannot be denied that a stronger and more prudent ruler than Nicholas would have survived the war, at the cost of making small concessions and curbing his autocratic power. Whilst this may have weakened the monarchy significantly it would have more importantly ensured its survival well into the 20th century. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Other Historical Periods section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Other Historical Periods essays

  1. Revision Table - Tudor Rebellions

    * Government agreed to negotiate with rebels. * Aske and ringleaders rounded up, tried in London and then executed. * Rents fixed and subsidy stopped. * Some monasteries re-established. * Rebels hung in Carlisle and Cumberland. * Increases power of gentry families who remained loyal. * No rebellion for remaining 6 years of Henry's reign, but punishments lead to new plots - Wakefield in 1541.

  2. To what extent did WW1 cause the collapse of Tsarism?

    The Tsarist regime, already weakening, was failing at this stage and this fatal act illustrated the death of the Tsarist regime and the decreasing support of the lower and working classes. This was an inconsiderate act towards the people who were to trust the Tsarist regime and have trust in Nicholas himself.

  1. To what extent had the Russian economy been successfully modernised by 1914?

    rate to those the peasants received, which allowed the nobles easier access to land. This highlights the Tsars wish to maintain the traditional Russian hierarchy, which can be seen as something they valued over the development of the economy. The nobles were also able to decide which part of their

  2. The First English Civil War

    towns, and the Fairfaxes underwent a decisive defeat at Adwalton Battle of Adwalton (Atherton) Moor near Bradford on the 30 June. After this, by way of Lincolnshire, they escaped to Hull and reorganised the defence of that place. The West Riding perforce submitted.

  1. The structures of the Soviet State were created by Lenin and abused by Stalin. ...

    or even of Stalin's own plans, but a desperate response to the social disaster Stalin's regime created after 1929. In conclusion, there were certainly links between Leninism and Stalinism, but that doesn't mean to say Leninism caused Stalinism. Lenin's authoritarian side - the elite role of the party, strict discipline,

  2. How effectively did the design and decoration of the Parthenon suit its function?

    The iron clamps were then covered with lead so they would not rust. The Victorians found out that when trying to restore part of the Parthenon, when they did not seal the clamps with lead that they rusted their work by not doing this only caused greater ruin for the blocks that that thought had been repaired.

  1. Despite frequent changes in policy, Russian and Soviet governments were spectacularly unsuccessful in securing ...

    For example, between 1890 and 1899, Russia?s industrial growth stood at 8.0% whereas between 1900-06, it reduced to 1.4%[10]. His aims of modernizing came with a heavy cost and it was consumers who had to pay the price. Taxes were raised but only for the lower classes, indeed the wealthier

  2. To What Extent Was Russia Modernised During the Personal Reign of Peter the Great? ...

    To try and convince the Russian people to become more modernised he published books such as ?the honourable mirror of youth?. These books showed the Russian people how to act in a civilised way. There were two problems with this policy, one was that the Russian people did not believe

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work