• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Why Were Some Forms Of Nationalism More Successful Than Others In Achieving Concessions From The British Government In The Period 1800-1900?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Why Were Some Forms Of Nationalism More Successful Than Others In Achieving Concessions From The British Government In The Period 1800-1900? Constitutional Nationalism, which although prevailed over revolutionary and Cultural Nationalism throughout the period of 1800-1900, combined to spearhead a driving and determined nationalist force campaigning against the diverse British Governments of the period for Emancipation, Repeal of the Union, Home Rule amongst other concessions. Constitutional Nationalism, embodied by O'Connell, was known for legislatively campaigning for concessions; Cultural Nationalism was an evolutionary process while Revolutionary Nationalism was essentially revolutionary known for its commitment to violence and its predominant legacies which were left behind by numerous martyrs of the cause. Daniel O'Connell, himself, was the protagonist of the emancipation story, who was followed by Charles Stuart Parnell in the late 1870s in the Home Rule and Land War sagas of the closing stages of the nineteenth century. Constitutional Nationalism sought greater autonomy for Ireland within the British Empire through gradual, peaceful change. This was personified in O'Connell's clear dismissive attitude of violence in his Emancipation and Repeal movements, which ultimately contributed to his downfall in 1843 at Clontarf. The second unquestioned leader of Irish politics in the nineteenth century, Parnell, was more open to an alliance with the revolutionaries, shown by the 'New Departure', his alliance with the Fenians. ...read more.

Middle

Charles Gavan Duffy, one of the founders of The Nation was himself a well known Irish poet. However, in a year of revolutions throughout the continent, such as in Italy, Germany, Austria and France, The Battle of Widow McCormack's Cabbage Patch is Ireland's sole contribution to the Year of Revolutions, where Smith O'Brien's uprising ended in nothing more than a skirmish with local police in a cabbage patch. In the aftermath of the severity of the Famine, the "Repeal Rent" dried up, and O'Connell died in May 1847. His death marked the end of a period in Irish politics. The Famine, which has been referred to as "passive genocide" due to England's ineffectualness in dealing with it, had a profound influence on later political developments. It left a feeling of resentment against the whole system of government in Ireland and created a legacy distinctly similar to that of some of the martyrs of Revolutionary Nationalism, as it left, ingrained in the mind, a resentment of the British occupation of Ireland. Importantly, two of the Young Ireland members involved, James Stephens and John O'Mahony escaped punishment and both fled to Paris. O'Mahony went to America in 1853 to try to gain support for another uprising from those who had left Ireland during the Famine and Stephens returned to Ireland in 1856 to found the Irish Republican Brotherhood, with the sole aim of independence on its agenda. ...read more.

Conclusion

Yet, the incident was turned to his advantage as the obvious sincerity of his reaction made a good impression in Britain. By the end of 1882, Parnell's position in Ireland was stronger than it had ever been before which led to Gladstone's conversion to Home Rule and his first Home Rule Bill was only defeated by 343 to 313. Yet, for the next 20 years, the governments were dominated by the Conservatives. Cultural Nationalism was more specifically concerned with reminding Irishmen of their heritage and was closely linked to the Young Ireland movement especially. The GAA was merely preoccupied with the advancement of Gaelic sports and the Gaelic League was concerned with the preservation of the language itself. Revolutionary Nationalism was for the most part ineffective as such examples as Emmet's 1803 rising, the Young Ireland 1848 insurrection and the Fenian rising of 1867 serve to illustrate. It was only when Revolutionary Nationalism was combined with Constitutional did both reach the potential of achieving concessions from the British Government. O'Connell, to an extent, managed this with his military rhetoric and brinkmanship in the Emancipation struggle, but it was mastered by Parnell in the Land War, where his movement incorporated the Fenians of Ireland and America. Constitutional Nationalism dominated this century in terms of ability to achieve concessions and it was only in a surprise uprising, in the next century, did Revolutionary Nationalism display its full potential. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Other Historical Periods section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Other Historical Periods essays

  1. How effective were National Government of 1931-1939 in dealing with the problem of unemployment? 20 ...

    The Government realised that certain parts of the country were suffering far more than others from the Depression. It decided to give additional help to these 'special' or 'depressed' areas. The Special Areas Act appointed two commissioners with a budget of two million pounds to try to attract some of the new industries to the old industrial areas.

  2. Why Did The Wartime Alliance Break Down?

    The London Poles, who were Catholic landowners and were members of the government in exile, opposed Stalin, they were against Communism. Quite the opposite was the Lublin Poles, set up with the help of the USSR in July 1944 and therefore supported Communism.

  1. South African Heritage - Where we come from?

    One example is Nazism; Hitler blamed the Jews for Germany's shortcomings and therefore distorted the image of the Jews to make it look like they were the reason for Germany's poor economic state. Communism is another example as in both Russia and China books and other written documents were destroyed

  2. Who was more important in bringing about the end of Apartheid and minority rule ...

    De Klerk took the decision to release Mandela and other opposition leaders because of the pressure put on him by Mandela's supporters. He also won a Whites only referendum to get support for participation in the CODESA talks in 1991.

  1. A direct comparison of the role of central power and control during the late ...

    role as the 'little father,' the Soviet era of fear and repression paired with a cult of personality was far more effective. Stalin was determined to eliminate such 'harmful superstitions,'22 as religion and religious belief. Communist control of the church came mainly through groups such as the League of Militant

  2. The First English Civil War

    from the King's headquarters at Edgecote, on 22 October. Battle of Edgehill Rupert promptly reported the enemy's presence, and his confidence dominated the irresolution of the King, and the caution of the Earl of Lindsey, the nominal Commander-in-Chief. Both sides had marched, widely dispersed in order to live, and the

  1. How far would agree that the strength of the British government was the main ...

    The middle-class Catholics, whose support was vital to O'Connell in the emancipation movement were in no hurry to plunge into Repeal. They felt that their energies would have been better spent in pressing for reforms in local government, tithes and law enforcement, which was also the attitude shared by most of the Catholic bishops.

  2. Louis XIV's fondness of war resulted his downfall

    However, Louis made some huge mistakes and it was these that almost certainly provoked his enemies into war against France. The following miss-interpretations seemed to show Louis as someone that did enjoy conflict, as well as someone that threw his weight around, always thinking he could get what he desired.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work