• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

world war one propaganda, sources question

Extracts from this document...


Question 2: Which source is more useful to an historian studying the use of propaganda in the First World War? Explain your answer using sources A and B and knowledge from your studies. Through prior knowledge, we understood that the British government had used manipulation through propaganda to form and change the attitudes and views of the general public, so that it was according to the government way of thinking. Historians suggest that three categories where designed to create this. Patriotism, moral superiority and hatred of the enemy. We learnt that, at times of difficulty, certain pressure points were used generate recruitment, at the early stages of the war, we find that patriotism was quite strong. Therefore, we understood that at different stages whether in loss or victory, different propaganda tools were used to influence the way the population, which was the real army, to act. Now that we have established this point, we have a better understanding, thus, bringing a clearer answer. Source A, is an extract from a novel: 'covenant with death', by John Harris, published in 1961. The author, a well known respected author has researched 40 years worth of sources and information. ...read more.


Despite its fantasizing of language, what the true message here, is the understanding how powerful the devices were to increase the morale of men, willing to sacrifice for their country. I will now study source B, so I can build a comparison, and decide whether one is more useful over the other. This source is a newspaper article during the war on 6th march 1915. The source shows five brothers and their brother in law who are all gone to war. It shows patriotically photographed portrayed as a family of bravery and respect. 'Who answered the call', they are referred to as those who answer the call. Showed to be family who has made their country proud, you should too. The audience is in Bath, the city has population of under a 100, 000 today, so therefore we are dealing with fairly small cities. It's appealing to encourage a more family recruitment. Judging the source in terms of facts or its ability to capture feeling or context, may be difficult, as this was under censorship. But it is beneficial as it helps understand the censorship and propaganda. The purpose of the source was to encourage and change attitude. ...read more.


Therefore, naturally this becomes useful evidence. To judge over the other, is difficult, because each source, inputs to our understanding regardless of its amount. Source A gives a more general view; the language allows historians to easily understand the manipulation. It is research that has been done for us. However, this is rather difficult with source B, its gives a concrete, real, evidence of propaganda, but requires historians to go further to get a wider conclusion. To make a conclusion, source B is true information, and really shows us propaganda people were exposed too, we can learn more, because we had proved earlier that the government used different propaganda at different times. There is a limitation, source B alone is not sufficient to achieve a wide impression, but using this with other sources is would give us potentially strong inference. However, as historians secondary sources are more reliable due to the depth of research, source A gives a powerful depiction of propaganda. I do believe that source B is better as fits the question, 'use of propaganda'. Clearly this is a censored article. As historians we can say that both sources aid our understanding. ?? ?? ?? ?? Name: Faisal Jiva Centre no: 13240 Candidate no: 3093 Coursework 2: propaganda in world war one, question 2 Page 1 of 2 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    World War One Sources Question

    3 star(s)

    This was because if the Schlieffen Plan had accomplished its objectives the Germans would have won the war and stalemate would not have developed. Also the when the Schlieffen Plan did fail the German army decided that they needed to surround the French and the British by sweeping round to

  2. Dtente, meaning and definition.

    However after crossing great hurdles SALT-II was finally signed in 1979,which was not ratified by the Congress. USSR took invasion in the Afghanistan in late 1979, which is great hurdle in the way of the d�tente and beginning of the new cold war.

  1. WW1 Sources Question: War Recruitment Propaganda.

    with the Kaiser's hat running away with a beautiful maiden (representing the innocent and good allies). Source C convinces men to sign up by persuading them that if they do not fight Germany will "rape" their beautiful country. Sources A, B and C are similar because they all use emotions to achieve their goal.

  2. Vietnam Question 2

    Unlike Source D, this is a real photograph taken by an American photographer. Presumably, the American public's response was not encouraging. The idea that children were being targeted by the American soldiers horrified the Americans and swung public opinion. In addition, behind the children, there are American soldiers aiming there guns at the distraught children, fleeing for their lives.

  1. Describe the ways that propaganda was used to mobilise theminds of the nation towards ...

    The British Department of Information produced a leaflet, which described a 'corpse-conversion factory' close behind German lines. It reported that this factory was used to turn dead bodies into fat, oils and fodder for pigs, and that there could be no doubt to the existence of this factory.

  2. Describe the ways that propaganda was used to mobilise the minds of the nation ...

    torpedoed the Lusitanian in 1915 to prepare the Americans' opinions for war. The most important audience was the people of Britain which was organised by the Ministry of the Interior. The people of Britain were told where to work, what to eat, and what to do in their free time and more importantly, what to think.

  1. Wartime Propaganda Sourcework

    as it is a primary source and is from a newspaper rather than a novel. It was also made in 1915 which was the high point of the war whereas Source A was from a novel, was written after the war and talks about the situation in 1914 which was at the very beginning of the war.

  2. Evaluation of key sources to address the question of increased tension

    Source A4 is a secondary source providing a caption from the book 'The Cold War' by S.K. Gibbons in 1986. The caption is a description of the events of the Paris summit. This source firstly explains that both the USA and the USSR had built 'immense stocks of missiles' which threatened each others existence.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work