• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

World War One Sources Question

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

History GCSE Coursework Question 1 Study sources A, B and c. Use your knowledge of the First World War to explain which two posters were published before 1916,and which one was published after 1916.You must give reasons for your answer. The sources A and B were produced before 1916 and C was produced afterwards. Source C is an American poster and these wouldn�t have been needed before 1916, as America did not join the war until 1917. Joining the army before 1917 when conscription had not yet been introduced was voluntary so posters like A and B which encourage men to join off their own backs by playing on emotions and make them think why they should join the army would have been needed. Posters A and B are very similar, they both use the family in encouraging recruits and patriotism-making the men feel that the war is something they should be part of. Whereas source C is portraying the enemy as a beast using propaganda to give the men enthusiasm to fight the Germans. Question 2 Study sources A B and C. In what ways are these posters similar, and in what ways do they differ? Posters A and B are very similar in using family values yo encourage young men to join the army .Source C is also similar to A and B in the sense that they all have something to do with patriotism of the war. Although A and B are similar in the way that they are both concerned with family and patriotism as does source C. Source C uses a different tactic of trying to recruit men; it portrays the enemy as a mad raging beast who must be stopped. It is also an American poster whereas sources A and B are both British. The posters A and B would not have been needed after conscription was introduced. ...read more.

Middle

Sources F and G were both produced for the same reasons to keep the British public proud of the soldiers and in high sprits that they would win the war. In these two sources the soldiers appear to be so relaxed that the people would think that they had a lot of confidence in winning without much effort. Source H is produced for a completely different purpose-to reveal what the battle was actually like behind the propaganda front that the public was bombarded with during the war. Question 6 Study sources I and J. Suggest possible reasons why these two sources give different impressions of conditions in the trenches. Explain your answer. Source I and J differ because they have been made for different reasons and by different people-one who has experienced trench warfare and the other people - have produced an advertisement to sell cigarettes. Source I has been produced for the purpose of selling cigarettes to the public therefore they are going to use the 'nice� relaxed image of soldiers have time to smoke one. The makers of this poster probably never actually saw the war in reality and even if they did go to war this could have been produced early on when conditions weren�t so bad. Source J is written by Siegfried Sasoon who had experienced war trench conditions and he creatively and cleverly uses his language to portray the trenches and the feelings of the other men. Sasoon describes some fingers of a dead man sticking out of the air as 'an appeal to God in defiance of those who made the war�. This very much emphasises one particular incident and he twists it-so it has a meaning In source I we are told about all the gruesome details such as the 'mangled bodies of the dead� everywhere in the trenches but Source J gives a nice clean and un-battle like impression of the trenches. ...read more.

Conclusion

Which was nothing like the government led the public to believe during the war. Question 10 Would a historian writing about the trenches in 1918 have been likely to produce a different account of what conditions were like from a historian writing much later? Use the Sources and your knowledge from this period to help you explain your answer. The Historian writing in 1918 about the trench conditions would have most definitely had a different account than one writing later. This is because the real information at the time was concealed from the public. Only writings that didn�t describe the trenches as bad were allowed to be published. Although there was conscription in 1918 there still would have been a lot of propaganda around to make the public feel proud of their soldiers. The Historian writing later would have been able to look at a variety of sources and information not just that what the government let people see. By using a range of information the Historian would later would have a better idea of what trench life was really like from different view points. The sources E,F G and I are all examples of the kind of things produced in the war. E -a postcard censoring the soldiers writing back home so they wouldn�t let anything slip about conditions. F and G which appeared together in British newspapers shows the men confident and brave while entering the battle this was later critised by BA steward who was present then. A historian later can look at both sides of the perception of the trenches but the historian writing at the time wouldn�t have much of an insight. The historian writing earlier would probably have given a much nicer impression of the trenches than the historian writing later as the bad details were kept quiet from the public. Source I is another example of the nice clean laid back impression the public were fed during the war. The historian writing later would also have a different account because they are 'reflecting� history rather than writing an account at the present time. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    World War One Sources Question

    3 star(s)

    Count Von Schlieffen, who wrote the Schlieffen Plan, thought that it would be best to tae the capital, Paris. They would achieve this by sweeping six parallel armies through northern France, taking the Channel ports to stop any overseas help i.e. British help, getting through and surround Paris (see diagram).

  2. Vietnam Coursework Sources Questions

    Photos were also another type of media that resulted in a changing the attitudes of the public. Source J is an example of the kind of photographs that were taken. They showed the cruel treatment of the Vietnamese and the public was shocked by what they saw as they showed scenes like My Lai.

  1. Evaluation of key sources to address the question of increased tension

    Upon Khrushchev's return to the Soviet Union he made a speech in Moscow, An extract of this is shown in source A5. In this primary source Khrushchev addresses the nation and explains that America has been caught 'Red Handed' flying over Soviet airspace.

  2. American History.

    The one thing Adams' detachment did help him with was the whole France crisis that erupted b/c of Jay's Treaty [which France didn't like too much]. - So b/c of Jay's Treaty, the French started seizing American ships carrying British goods.

  1. The Prelude to the 1975 War and the Cairo Agreement.

    It began with an incident September 29 at the Rashidiyya refugee camp on the outskirts of Tyre in which Palestinians allegedly fired on an Amal patrol. Amal immediately surrounded the camp, demanding the surrender of all arms inside it. The demand was refused.

  2. Using the information in the sources and your own knowledge, were contemporaries correct in ...

    this is another example of the soldiers bravery during world war 1, how ever there bravery led to there death at the hands of the German machine guns. The soldiers didn't give up to; through out the whole battle of the Somme, soldiers were sent over the top, however as

  1. Vietnam Assignment – History Sources Question

    When the US forces were all in the village exits were covered and men murdered, this was a major advantage as in doing this hardly any Vietcong troops were killed where as to kill this number of Americans in open combat would surely see many Vietcong troops dead.

  2. History Question C

    Russia had made peace with Germany; the armies that were previously fighting on the Eastern Front could now join the armies on the Western Front A number of small infantry groups crossed No Man's Land during ongoing shelling. Storm troops were now equipped with light weight machine guns that allowed them to move fast when crossing No Man's Land.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work