• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Can it ever be justifiable to give a machine control over a risky activity? When? What happens when something goes wrong?

Extracts from this document...


Can it ever be justifiable to give a machine control over a risky activity? When? What happens when something goes wrong? In this essay I intend to discuss whether or not it is right to give a machine control over a risky activity. Incorrect decisions by a computer can cause death, but so could human control. Which is riskier? Nuclear Power One of the scariest things about nuclear power is when something goes wrong - an accident occurs. They utilize radioactive materials to make power but in the event of an accident, thousands of people can get hurt. If radiation is released into the environment people die. Two of the most famous nuclear accidents occurred at Three Mile Island, and at the Chernobyl plant. In both of these accidents, a meltdown occurred. This is where the molten fuel rods melt through the bottom of the reactor and then about 20 metres into the earth beneath the plant. The uranium reacts with groundwater forming explosions. The radioactive steam can then affect nearby areas. Chernobyl The Chernobyl accident took place on April 26, 1986. The accident happened because normal operations were suspended due to an experiment taking place. ...read more.


To help avoid accidents, humans should be provided with an on-the-spot diagnosis of the problem along with error tolerant corrective actions. Human operators should continuously monitor and try to detect failures of system components. Failures are very significant, as they can affect the accuracy of the control system algorithms. A good example of such a failure is the NORAD moon attack. A faulty sensor gave incorrect information to the system and missiles were nearly launched. One General decided that the sensor was faulty and stopped the missiles from firing. Starting unsafe operations should be difficult, while stopping such actions should be easy. For example, a missile should have to be armed before it can be fired. The fire button should not be touch sensitive and should require a complicated code to be entered. This would help to prevent an accidental firing. The interface should augment human abilities and not replace them. The operator's task should not be oversimplified. It should provide facilities for operators to experiment, and to update their mental models of the system. A method of providing alternative sources of critical information in case the display fails should be available to the operator. ...read more.


The shearer can cut 900mm of coal from the face on each pass. The maximum daily output (24hrs) has been 46,340 tonnes of coal. The shearer can mine such a large amount of coal due to the fact that the mine is operating 24 hours a day. Machines do not need a rest or break. A well designed machine can be very efficient. All of the processes in the mine are computerized. This includes cleaning the coal to remove its natural impurities, sorting it into size groups, and drying it to remove moisture. As these stages are computerized, it ensures that customers are getting coal of a consistently high quality. By computerizing the coal mining industry, the risk to human workers has been greatly reduced. This is an industry that has benefited greatly by computerization. Personal Views The issue over who should be responsible for the detection of an impending accident and initiate shutdown procedures should be considered. Is it better for a human or a machine to make the judgment? My opinion is that if a system is so risky that a machine must initiate the shutdown, perhaps the system should not be built at all. Machinery is replaceable, but human life is not. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Information Systems and Communication section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Information Systems and Communication essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Database Coursework on a Vehicle Rental System: Analysis

    5 star(s)

    The information held by the proposed system must be updated regularly, or risk breaching the Data Protection Act 1998, which would be very expensive for Fred's Car Rentals. System Requirements The following is a list of what will be required of the proposed system: 1.

  2. ict as level coursework

    then I keyed in : What does this mean? UserForm4.Hide To stop this user form from showing Load UserForm1 Allocates the relevant user form that has to be loaded (in this case the main menu) UserForm1.Show This user form will not display This is how it looks on the user form.

  1. System Analysis and Design Assignment

    will continue to overstretch the staff and manual records are at risk of becoming lost, damaged or destroyed by fire. 2. Improve the current system Advantages: * There will be minimal disruption to the working of the current system * A minimal amount of training will be required to adapt

  2. Database Analysis & Design

    Analysis The analysis section within the traditional life cycle is the starting point and is very important. This section shows both the requirements for the new system but firstly analyses the old system. The analysis of the old system will show what was wrong with it and what was good with it.

  1. The hospitality industry is in a unique position for the creation of an automated ...

    And hence what the JIT strategy is, is to eliminate all wastes and this can be done by refraining from small inventories in the system and at a later stage to aim to eliminate more, always comply with the customer's expectations for a better design and functioning of each product, be flexible at manufacturing, be a team player etc.

  2. Regenerative Braking

    The process of regeneration is entirely automatic and occurs when the demand speed is reduced. When the driver applies the brakes, the controller supplies a voltage to the motor to drive it, and, the motor is generating an EMF proportional to the speed of the vehicle.

  1. From the e-commerce strategy you gave me earlier I understand that by having a ...

    Which means you cannot sell, give out, lease or buy any information without the user's consent. So if you wanted to have a list of people who like diving you need to get the information from your own website rather than obtaining the data illegally.

  2. Website Design, Creation and Evaluation

    This allows lots of flexibility within a web page. Business websites favour JavaScript because of CSS Cascading Style Sheet (CSS) is a language which is used in the presentation of any markup language document. It is primarily used alongside HTML/XHTML to style web pages, and works by separating the document content written in HTML, from the document presentation (written in CSS).

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work