• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Should the UK reform the Electoral System used for General Elections?

Extracts from this document...


Should the UK reform the Electoral System used for General Elections? The United Kingdom has had competitive elections since the 18th century, with calls for electoral reform dating back the 19th century. The system was almost changed in the 1930's by the Labour Government but they were defeated in the next election. The UK has never seen major change to its electoral system, but since the success of New Labour in 1997 it has become increasingly likely. To ascertain whether or not the system should be reformed, it is necessary to examine the current system and the proposed alternatives, whether in use or not, and to analyse issues surrounding possible electoral reform. The current First Past the Post (FPTP) system is the most widely used democratic electoral system on account of its simplicity. It provides a clear choice for voters, usually between two main parties but allowing other representatives to stand. This gives a clear majority to the winning party, meaning the elected government have a clear mandate so coalition governments are rare and therefore reform is more likely. The FPTP system retains the link between representatives and their constituencies, giving rise to a Parliament of geographical representatives. The main criticism of the FPTP system is that it has "an inbuilt disproportionality" (Rose). Minor parties are excluded from fair representation as the number of votes won does not equate to the number of seats obtained in Parliament. ...read more.


Many Labour MPs, when asked for their opinion on the matter, refer to their signing of the Make Votes Count "Call for Democracy". Typically, Conservatives are against electoral reform as they have traditionally seen most success under the current system. In England at least, the FPTP system often over-represents Conservatives and for this reason many see no reason for change. In the Welsh Assembly, however, despite one in five Welsh people voting Conservative, the party did not win a single seat in the 1997 Election. Conservative MP for Canterbury Julian Brazier refers to the Labour founded Jenkins Commission (ICVS) to show his approval of the current scheme: "As you know, the Labour Party set down four criteria by which Jenkins was to judge an electoral system: broad proportionality, voter choice, stable government and maintenance of a link between MPs and geographical constituencies. The current British system fulfils all of these proposals. In fact, our current system fulfils the criteria better than the 'AV+' proposal." Liberal Democrats are poorly represented under the current system and consequently the party advocates electoral reform. As mentioned above, minor parties suffer the most with FPTP and have the most wasted votes as a result of being third in a dominant two party system. When asked, the majority of Liberal Democrat MPs "follow the party line, i.e. STV, with AV+ as a step in the right direction," (Sue Doughty, Liberal Democrat MP for Guildford). ...read more.


The system ensures the targeting of marginal seats is reduced and producing majority governments, thus eliminating the possibility of coalition governments if the voters so choose. Conversely, the possibility of tactical voting is still probable and the ballot papers can be considered too complicated for the masses. The proposed larger constituencies damage the link between MPs and their constituencies, but not to such an extent that it would be greatly noticed as between 550 and 600 constituencies would still be in use. The system used to vote members into the devolved Scottish Parliament is the Additional Member System. This is similar to the AV+ model in that voters have two votes, one for their choice of the 73 MSPs voted in using FPTP and one for the 56 MSPs using proportional representation (top-up members). This is a system also used in Germany, New Zealand (called Multi Member Proportional Representation) and Japan. Elections for the Welsh Assembly are also carried out using this system. In Northern Ireland local elections, the Single Transferable Vote (STV) has been used since 1973. This is related to the AV system as voters indicate preferences on the ballot paper, but the STV works in multi-member constituencies. Voters can choose from a list of candidates proposed by parties so there is much greater choice and there are no wasted votes, as votes can be transferred such as in the AV system. When all votes have been cast, the winning candidate must achieve over a certain quota. Any votes over this are transferred to those voters' second preferences. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Information Systems and Communication section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Information Systems and Communication essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Database Coursework on a Vehicle Rental System: Analysis

    5 star(s)

    Due to the heavy amounts of paperwork involved, the employees sometimes make typographical errors during the recording or editing of data, which can merely be something as innocuous as a mis-spelt name but can on occasion result in something a little more serious such as an incorrect telephone number or

  2. ict as level coursework

    Only a cream has to be ordered however all the combo boxes must have a catalogue number selected with the quantity of 0 as shown above. This is because the system is not advanced enough to ignore the fact that there is no catalogue number present.

  1. Using examples, discuss the advantages/disadvantages of proportional representation systems compared to the ‘first past ...

    However, the reason most countries have dispensed with the plurality system in favour of other electoral systems is because it lacks proportionality. With the plurality system the party achieving the most votes wins, although most of the electorate might have voted against them.

  2. Feasibility Report

    because I think it will be the most beneficial to the Perfect Pie Company. If the Perfect Pie Company, were going to take on the COTS approach, it would be very beneficial to them as the Perfect Pie Company can make use of an online order form, this will give

  1. The Impact of Mobile Phones on social Interaction

    Following further discussion of this issue in the focus group it was concluded that it was the "hassle" aspect combined with the distrust associated with this method of purchasing that was responsible in such a low usage. Similarly, many people in this age group did not feel that there were

  2. Implementing a new system for Mastercare.

    The laptop also has a CD rewriter which may be useful for backup of the system. The proposed system will be backed up once a week (as required by my client) onto a CD, making use of the CD Re-Writing capabilities of the laptop.

  1. The Federal Republic of Germany.

    centralized France, Germany was missing such a single focal point because of its highly fragmented political structure. As a consequence, Germany had a road system which connected many political states and was very important to trade movements across the continent.

  2. I have been asked to write a report on current working practice and I ...

    Since they guess how long a certain task will take, there are some chances of not producing the task at time. If they think they can't finish a project on time then they talk to client and ask for

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work