• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The London Ambulance Service: a critical study on the failure story

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Abstract: The London Ambulance Service, largest among the world, had attempted to introduce a computer-aided despatch system to overcome their operational difficulties and meet the performance requirements of Operational Research Consultancy (ORCON). The project, due to operational and strategic flaws at various levels, was a failure. The report identifies the flaws to produce a lessons learnt report with respect to failure of the London Ambulance Service computer-aided despatch system (LAS CAD). 1 Introduction: To specify the service, LAS covers an area over 600 sq miles, serves a resident population of 6.8 m people, receiving 2000-2500 phone calls a day, where, 1300 to 1600 are emergency '999' calls. Service has 2700 staff and over 750 ambulances. With a budget of �69.7 m, LAS is largest in world. Performance Requirements - Reasons for taking a CAD system: According to ORCON's standards, the instructions should be given to the ambulance station or crew within 3 min and an ambulance should arrive at the scene within 14 min. This is a critical requirement, which can not be practically met with the manual system of activating emergency services. Lack of information and poor quality of communication with the crews were key concerns along with handling problems arising with organization, over-manning and operational cost of LAS. Being aware of the complete manual system LAS attempted to introduce a computer-aided despatch system (CAD) ...read more.

Middle

The structure gives a clear picture of responsibilities once every team member was properly communicated with the structure set. CAD, being an innovative project being handled by LAS encountered ambiguities over managerial role of the contractor. Project also encountered a lack of middle level management which led to an addition of unexpected and extra responsibilities being fell on the Director of Support Services, who found him spending more of his time in low level coordination and progress chasing. The involvement of ambulance crews was considered to be very little in developing a SRS. The hard ware manufacturer, who took the role of prime contractor, was not prepared to set up to execute his role and rapidly withdrew from activities of this nature. The contractor and systems manager found them selves not qualified for IT procurement and need to be replaced. The responsibilities of activities should have been clearly stated before attempting to prepare an SRS (along with team responsible to produce SRS). The ambiguities in managerial role of the contractor which resulted in inefficient progress in him leading the project would have been avoided if the responsibilities are clearly stated before accepting the job by contractor. As this happens only if contractor in the managerial role is self sufficient in terms of his duties and expertise, proper definition of contractor's responsibilities would have solved a part of problems. ...read more.

Conclusion

Functional testing to ensure that CAD does what is expected of it and Load testing to test the ability of the system to perform under maximum load would have added the completeness and quality to the performance of the system as few problems can not be simulated and can be seen only in real time. Though CAD was not termed to be a technical failure, the flaws in system development caused the system failure. A systems development methodology would have helped avoid many flaws in the LAS CAD. A system development life cycle approach would be of better choice rather than a single inheritance model of developing, testing (inappropriate environment), implementing. An experience project manager would have added this sugar and thus, this is to the notice of top level management. 3. Conclusion: Identifying the flaws it encountered, LAS should under go an analysis phase to figure out operational and technical feasibility in undertaking CAD. With system errors being identified and aligning experienced and relevant human resource would add the proximity of system being a success. An understanding of re-engineering project would help the top level management identify the change-management required. With a better communication of these to the organizational personnel, any future trails to undertake an innovation would be the interest of employees at all levels too, rather than only of top management. ?? ?? ?? ?? 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Information Systems and Communication section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Information Systems and Communication essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Database Coursework on a Vehicle Rental System: Analysis

    5 star(s)

    If work practices have to be altered too drastically that the organization will not be able to comply, then we say that the project lacks operational feasibility and the project will not go any further. Obviously I don't expect my client to turn his business upside down and inside-out in order to accommodate my system.

  2. Marked by a teacher

    Ecommerce Case Study

    In order for Cuckoo Games to make the most of E-Commerce it is essential that they have a website that looks professional, easy to use and is eye catching and grabs your attention. Although having a professionally made website can be expensive to have produced but Cuckoo Games will greatly benefit from a professional website rather than a cheaper alternative.

  1. This report examines a detailed action research process, Soft Systems Methodology (SSM) and discusses ...

    * Resourcing and Carrying out new product development The resources of the problem-solving system include people, skills, finance, time and physical resources. A system can be said to use a set of resources, physical and, through human participants, abstract which are at the disposal of the decision-taking process.

  2. Feasibility Report

    o Order options like text messages and an online order form can cause problems; the servers can easily get problems that will take time to resolve which in turn will give the customers less options to choose from for placing their order.

  1. Free essay

    ICT organisation project

    Most photographs are supplied as digital files shot at a high resolution with a minimum of 300dpi on the cameras highest setting to ensure quality. Consistency The articles are divided into three consistent types. These are: News items which usually consist of half a page, Feature articles, which take up to two pages, often advertised on the front page.

  2. Database Analysis & Design

    Functional Model Iteration This section will have a description about Functional Model Iteration. Within this section there are different stages which need to be assessed and completed, these stages should all be completed before moving onto the next full stage, these are, * Agree plan The plan which has been

  1. Custom Load Trucking

    He also had been involved in systems analysis design and programming, as well as managing the work of the other three team members. He assisted in the schedule to keep his team on track. The quality of his team work was good and if not better than the other teams on the project.

  2. ICT revision notes - IT project management

    âThe analysts use the results of their findings to produce a set of deliverables for the new system which are agreed with the user and the client. Deliverables âA set of items promised under a contract such as; +System functionality list +User interface designs +Details of provision for existing data

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work