• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Using examples, discuss the advantages/disadvantages of proportional representation systems compared to the ‘first past the post’ system as used in parliamentary elections in the UK.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Using examples, discuss the advantages/disadvantages of proportional representation systems compared to the 'first past the post' system as used in parliamentary elections in the UK. The United Kingdom, along with a few British influenced states including Canada, maintains the 'first past the post' or 'plurality' system of translating votes into seats in Parliament (Hague 1998). Growing controversy about electoral systems has centred on the rules for translating votes into seats and many have argued that the UK should join the rest of Europe in converting to a system of proportional representation (PR). PR systems attempt to distribute seats in direct proportion to votes. In the plurality system elections are won by the party/individual who gets the most votes. It's the simplest of the electoral systems and is easily understood and employed. Other countries employ a wide range of alternatives, most incorporating some form of PR. Though there are many variations the main PR systems are the party list system, the single transferable vote (STV) and the additional member system (AMS), as used in Germany. Whether or not plurality is the best system has long been debated. ...read more.

Middle

Although the Israeli system results in higher ratio of 'effective' votes than even STV and is highly proportional, the country votes as a single constituency and this means an end to local MPs and constituencies (Hain 1986). This reduces the extent to which MPs represent the community and creating a more remote relationship between MPs and the community they represent. The system, although sounding simple, in practise can prove very complicated. In Norway the list system has caused urban voters to be underrepresented due to constituency size and how they are arranged (Hain 1986). It can also lead to lots of small parties in parliament and coalition governments. All PR systems can increase the likelihood of this and it may not necessarily be a bad thing. It means that more people's views can be represented, and "coalition and minority governments have not been noticeably 'weaker' than governments in a two-party situation" (Finer 1975). It is also worth noting that the plurality system has occasionally resulted in coalition governments and "a coalition...can pass its legislation just as easily as a single-party government" (Finer 1975). ...read more.

Conclusion

AV shares the criticism of AMS that two classes of MPs would result, however, all MPs at Westminster should stay equal in status. On reflection, all the electoral systems mentioned have their own problems and advantages it is, perhaps understandable that the government have opted for a referendum on this contentious issue. It seems that the controversy over is ongoing and those advocating change will not succumb to traditionalists' arguments as feelings run high, centring on the pursuit of democratic government. A referendum, promised by the government will be taken before a decision is made and it is unlikely that a new system will be implemented any time soon. It is vital that governments do not rush through a change of system. Once an electoral system is adopted it unlikely to be changed as once a party has been elected through a particular system they do not wish to change it. However, improvement in the fairness of the system must not be forfeited for fear of change. Each excels under different circumstances and what succeeds for one country may not for another. Deciding and agreeing which system is best for the UK is clearly problematic, if indeed any one system is best. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Information Systems and Communication section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Information Systems and Communication essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Database Coursework on a Vehicle Rental System: Analysis

    5 star(s)

    Due to the messiness and illegibility of the handwriting on the customer's record, the employee that was trying to contact the customer read one of the digits wrongly on the telephone number, and thus it turned out was dialling the wrong telephone number the whole time!

  2. Compare and contrast first past the post system and majority systems, and consider the ...

    However there are also arguments against the first past the post system and they are that in each constituency as many as 70% of the votes are wasted as votes that are cast for the losing party are wasted in the sense that they are ignored during seat allocation and

  1. The Advantages and Disadvantages of the First Past the Post Voting System

    This is one of the disadvantages of the First Past the Post System. With two parties usually gaining large proportions of the seats we end up with a Government and an opposition with no need for coalitions, some people see this as an advantage of the First Past the Post System others see this as a disadvantage of the system.

  2. Energy Conversion (EC) Systems

    Three independently variable properties are required to define its state. Here the emphasis is not on magnetic effects, electric properties of substances, or with surface tension. Only the work mode due to compressibility will be considered; the state of such a simple compressible substance can be defined for a non-reacting system in terms of only two independently variable properties.

  1. What form of electoral system would you recommend for Parliamentary elections in the United ...

    Another election was called 8 months later in October where Labour managed to gain a majority of seats in the commons. By looking at the above figures, we see an example of the main argument for reform of Britain's electoral system.

  2. The Federal Republic of Germany.

    Right in the heart of Germany are the Harz Mountains. Toward the east are the Rhon Mountains, the Bavarian Forest, the Upper Palatinate Forest, the Fichtel Hills, the Franconian Forest, the Thuringian Forest and the Ore Mountains. The terrace landscape of the Central Uplands in the southwest embraces the upper

  1. Outline a case for and against electoral reform in the UK.

    In a system that is proportional or with additional members the importance loaded on these areas will be weakened. The fact that the votes in constituencies are close but result in just one representative asks the question of why we don't have additional members or `MP top ups.'

  2. Data Processing Task. Mr Peters, the man who runs this particular Samsung store ...

    The product price was correctly calculated. 5 Look-up in Product Order Subform Does information from the product table appear in the subform when the ProductID is entered? When I enter the ProductID, the relevant information for the product should appear.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work