• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11

Can the Islamic approach to Human Rights be compatible withthe current International Human Rights Doctrine?

Extracts from this document...


Can the Islamic approach to Human Rights be compatible with the current International Human Rights Doctrine? 1. Introduction This essay outlines one of the biggest and burning issues insofar toward the universal human rights: can the Islamic approach to human rights be compatible with the current international human rights doctrine? As an entitled notion with the religion of Islam, which has the second biggest in number of the followers worldwide, its approach to human rights is definitely crucial. Islamic human rights copes such a large area of thought, but this essay much more likely to focus the discussion on the idea of the Islamic women's rights. The main argument is that pure Islamic approach to human rights, especially to women's rights, can not be compatible with the current international human rights doctrine. However, its approach to human rights, include women rights, might much more sustainable internally of the Moslem society. Fairly, my position is not pretending to provide any problem resolving or to justify anything, but to tease out some of the possibly conflicting notions that are tie up with human discussing on this issue. In order to do that, we will begin by making such an overview on the context of international human rights doctrine, and then go through along the existence of human rights in Islamic perspective, and finally come up with the examining of the compatibility of both side to conclude. 2. International Human Rights Doctrine Jack Donnelly, as paraphrased by Freeman, declares such a conceptual idea about human rights by saying as follows: "Human rights are the rights one has simply because one is human being. Consequently, they are held universally by all human beings. They are the highest moral rights, and 'in ordinary circumstances' they take priority over the moral, legal, and political claims. Human rights are universal also in the sense that they are almost universally accepted, at least in the word or as ideal standards" (Freeman, 2004: pp 380). ...read more.


This is the only one covenant of human rights which is based on religion that has been completed worldwide. Al-Hewar Center - The Center for Arab Culture and Dialogue, describes that the declaration comprises the rights which are written here in detail, as: right to life, right to freedom, right to equality, right to justice, right to fair trial, right to protection against abuse of power, right to protection against torture, right to protection of honour and reputation, right to asylum, right of minorities, right and obligation to participate in the conduct and management of public affairs, right to freedom of belief, thought and speech, right to freedom of religion, right to free association, right to involving in economic area, right to protection of property, right to status and dignity of workers, right to social security, right to found a family, right of married women, right to education, right of privacy, and right to freedom of movement and residence (A-Hewar Center, 1999). According to this, arguably, it seems that Universal Islamic Declaration of Human Rights is much more detail and comprehensive than the International Human Rights; for instance it proposes the right of minorities that is not clearly stated in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. In terms of women's rights, although there is no particular convention on the protection of Islamic women's rights, Moslem fellows attractively argue that Islam is a well known religion which completely recognises women's rights. They are usually over-confident when they show that Islamic women's rights are incomparable with whatsoever religion or cultural thought on this earth, even with secularism notions, as they believe that Shari'a as the basis of all Islamic rules, in which the women's rights are entitled, is derived from words of God and the impossible-false of the Prophet's acts and traditions. In this sense, Shari'a is looked at as a blessing rule that is respectable to human kind as the higher creation of God. ...read more.


Nonetheless, it seems rather unfair since all forms of human rights need Islamic legitimacy, whereas all instruments of legitimating in Islam are totally against the outsider, non-Moslem. The implication of the attitude of subordination has been impacted to the implementation of human rights in all forms of the Islamic society. Unfair and inequality between men and women becomes a serious barrier to realise the principle of universal human rights for all human beings. Yet, the obligation of being a believer in Islam also makes a clear confession that it is quite worthless to promote Islamic human rights for all human beings. In addition, Ida Glaser and Napoleon John, by quoting Engineer's words, writes that it is undoubtedly that there is a common thrust towards equality of the male and female in the Qur'an. Unlike in other religions, there is definitely no differentiation between men and women in religious matters. (Glaser and John, 1998). However, this statement seems inapplicable when that equability comes into implementation in the global context, as it is clearly stated the term of undivided men and women in 'religious matters'. 5. Conclusion To summarise this essay, there are many similarities between the concept of universal human rights that has been adopted by United Nations and the Islamic Human Rights. They both include freedoms, equalities, and rights. To some extent, Islamic Human Rights notions is likely more detail and comprehensive. However, the problem in the Islamic human rights emerges at the stage of the implementation, in which it tends to require all as the Moslems. The implication of this fait accompli is that it seems too vague to rely upon only an Islamic approach to human rights universally. Yet, as it has proved that there are subordinating teachings implied in Islamic thoughts, it clearly makes the achievement of human rights effort face several barriers. Thus, I conclude that the Islamic approach to human rights can not be compatible with the current international human rights doctrine, but it may work well in the faithful Islamic societies. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Sources of Law section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Sources of Law essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    How satisfactory is the current law of murder?

    3 star(s)

    it has been stated that a person is not a human being until the moment of birth. To establish the AR of Murder it is a necessity to find Causation. Firstly 'Factual Causation' must be established in which the 'But For Test' must be applied.

  2. Jury Essay

    forthcoming, the judge may recall the jury and instruct them that they are prepared to consider a majority verdict. This means that a verdict of either 10-2 or 11-1 will be accepted. As jurors have no legal training, and have no obligation to supply reasons for their verdict, they are

  1. Free essay

    How effective are domestic and international legal measures in dealing with human trafficking?

    Of that $110, $50 was deducted from the debt and the remainder of the proceeds went to the establishment. The women were given the option of working on their free day and retaining the $50 per client, but only upon that day.

  2. "In form, the Human Rights Act (HRA) is compatible with parliamentary sovereignty. In practice, ...

    legislation, and a declaration of incompatibility "does not affect the validity, continuing operation or enforcement of the provision". If it so wishes, Parliament may amend the offending legislation under section 10 of Schedule 2, which, in a sense, achieves an equilibrium between having regard for the ECHR and maintaining Parliament's legislative supremacy.

  1. How has the European Court of Human Rights contributed to the protection of children's ...

    to overcome it28, was actually influenced by need to prevent indirect state interference by Court with parents' privacy, if child's freedom was allowed against the mother. The Court importantly argued that a child of 12 was not ready to take decisions himself, so it was normal for his mother to

  2. Evaluate the extent to which the Human Right Act 1998 is consistent with the ...

    See R v Greater Manchester Police, ex parte R 20 There are however cases where the House of Lords have interpreted cases to be compatible with the Act. In R v A,21 a 'rape shield' for victims of rape introduced by the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 199 was

  1. Outcome (3): Analyse the provisions relating to the police powers of arrest, search, seizure, ...

    believing that material is on a premise that could be of significant usefulness to an investigation and could also be used as evidence. A search warrant is only necessary in a case where such entry onto a premise will not be granted without a warrant (see Hope v Evered 1886)

  2. Law case study

    This only applies to children born after the date of commencement of the Act which was the 4th of May 2006. As both parents were not married, law dictates Inheritance Rights of Spouses and Civil Partners. In this case, as Johanna is deceased, Richard has the right to inherit the

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work