• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Constitutional & administrative law.

Extracts from this document...


Constitutional & Administrative Law 2001/2002 'Desirable as it is, the full entrenchment of the Human Rights Act 1998 remains impossible due to Parliamentary Sovereignty'. Analyse and critically assess the above statement. I am of the opinion that full enforcement of the Human Rights Act can not be possible due to the long standing constitutional doctrine of Parliamentary Sovereignty. In this essay it will be discussed the origins of Parliamentary Supremacy and the effect of the incorporation of the Human Rights Act 1998 will have on this. The theory of Parliamentary Sovereignty, its meaning and how allowing individuals all the rights and freedoms as laid out in the named Act would undermine this, therefore I believe that fully incorporating and abiding by the Human Rights Act will be impossible due to the theory of the supremacy of Parliament. Parliament is the legislative assembly of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Over the centuries it has become more than a legislative body; it is the sovereign power of Great Britain, whereas the monarch remains sovereign in name only. It has the power to: create new laws (eg Transport Act 1981), amend existing Acts (eg the Transport Act 1981 amended the Transport Act 1972), pass a Consolidation Act which brings together other Acts which cover similar areas of Law (eg Sale ...read more.


Due to the British constitution being largely unwritten, an Act was passed: The European Communities Act 1972. the Act seemed to provide the courts with instruction to obey Community law, but was not clear on what to do if this conflicted with an Act of Parliament. They were advised to interpret in ways so as not to create discrepancy between them. There was no direct clash between EC law and British law until the Factortame cases in 1990 and 1991. these concerned an apparent clash between EC law forbidding discrimination on grounds of nationality and the Merchant Shipping Act 1988 which imposed discriminatory rules on fishing boats. They challenged the application to them of the 1988 Act and asked for an interim injunction suspending the Act, pending a reference to the European Court of Justice. English law would not have permitted such suspension as it would undermine the doctrine of Parliamentary supremacy, the European Court of Justice said that EC law could require it. The House of Lords chose to obey the 1972 European Communities Act and awarded the injunction. The basic rule of European Union Law is that The European Communities Act of 1972 provides for the incorporation of European Community law into UK law. ...read more.


Most importantly, the duty of disclosure under Article 6 of the Convention is not dependent upon disclosure of the defence case. In light of current events, like in the case of Lincolnshire Police as advertised in The Times on 5/2/2, stating that the private client-lawyer conversations were bugged and this is where the murder charge was 'confessed to'. Part of the prosecutions case was obtained as result of overhearing what the accused had discussed confidentially with his solicitor. This case saw the conviction quashed due to the infringement of basic rights which the convention guarantees: Article 6.3 the right to a fair trial and Article 8 the right to privacy. This is an example of where the rights of the individual have come before the aims of Parliament in securing a conviction of someone guilty of a serious offence. It is my opinion that to fully respect and take individuals rights as paramount would mean taking the rights and prerogative of the state as second. This in itself shows that desirable as it may be, to fully establish human rights as a central part of the system it will not be entirely possible due to the long standing doctrine of Parliamentary Sovereignty. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Sources of Law section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Sources of Law essays

  1. The Human Rights Act 1998 has a significant impact on administrative law in the ...

    The key issue for discussion is that although, citizens of the UK are able to challenge public bodies for infringements of their human rights stringent limitations are imposed on the public's power to exercise their rights in judicial review proceedings.5 Limitations include for example, time restrictions by which claims must

  2. The Land Registration Act 2002 heralds major changes to the law and procedures regarding ...

    However, where the sale takes place after 12 October 2006, the squatter's title will not be an overriding interest unless he is in actual occupation, and even then will not be protected if his occupation would not have been obvious to the purchaser or if, when asked, the squatter did not disclose it.

  1. Parliamentary supremacy

    The powers that are delegated through devolution are limited and remain under the overall control of Westminster Parliament. Perhaps the most influential development in a loss of national sovereignty and a fragmentation of Parliamentary supremacy has been the UK's Membership in 1973 to the European Union.

  2. Outline many of the basic elements of law that relate to business and marketing.

    Conduct research (via the Internet or by contacting the Workers Compensation Authority in your state) and prepare a brief outline of the legislation, regulations and specific Codes of Practice that cover occupational health and safety in your industry. Australian Occupational Health, Safety and Welfare consists of five sections of both mandatory legislation and voluntary guidance material.

  1. Discuss whether incorporation of the European Convention on Human Rights into the domestic legislation ...

    assembly and association, Article 12; right to marry and Article 14; prohibition of discrimination. Now that the ECHR has been incorporated into English domestic law through the HRA it has an impact on UK law as before this it had no legally binding force.

  2. "In form, the Human Rights Act (HRA) is compatible with parliamentary sovereignty. In practice, ...

    There was overwhelming emphasis during Parliamentary proceedings that the Act is designed to be compatible with, if not to strengthen, Parliamentary sovereignty, while also giving effective protection to Convention rights (Rights Brought Home: The Human Rights Bill, 1997). "It is clear", said Lord Steyn in R v DPP, ex parte

  1. How has the European Court of Human Rights contributed to the protection of children's ...

    8 rights are too often not respected70. It is regretful that this empowerment does not apply to administrative/disciplinary procedures - ward/secure accommodation order, expulsion from school - whereas Dutch legislation provides this71. Elsewhere, the Court has achieved remarkable results, like proclamation in Marckx v.

  2. Critically evaluate the partial defence of Provocation.

    In R v Davies (1975), it was the acts of the lover of Davies's wife could be taken into account as provoking Davies to kill his wife. The fact that the provocation was induced by the defendant in the first place does not necessarily prevent the defence being made out.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work