• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

has welfare state suceeded

Extracts from this document...


Has the welfare state succeeded? The term "welfare state" refers to the provisions made by a state intended to protect its citizens from social problems - principally ill health, unemployment, poor housing and lack of access to education. This essay will study the British experience of the welfare state and its initial aims and consider whether its modern form has succeeded in fulfilling them. Welfare provision is characterised, in Fulcher and Scott's view (1999/2003), by a varying amount of compromise between two polarised viewpoints: the market model, where citizens purchase healthcare, education and the like privately, against the welfare-state model, where the state fulfils welfare needs. Supporters of the market model believe that state welfare "is excessively bureaucratic and therefore inefficient" (Taylor et al, 1995/2005: 155). Pre-Industrial Britain had had no welfare state; provision was made on a local scale, typically at parish level, and was administered in the main by family with some assistance from religious bodies. The 1601 Poor Law Act was the first nationalised welfare legislation; people were tied to a particular parish to receive welfare. Despite the Act provision remained patchy and regionally variable (Taylor et al, 1995/2005). As the country's urban population grew in tandem with industrialisation, traditional rural support networks became "largely absent" (Fulcher and Scott, 1999/2003: 826). The deprivation suffered by the exploding urban working classes, coupled with fear of civil unrest, encouraged the ruling classes to formulate nation-wide strategies for welfare provision, expressed in the Poor Law Amendment Act of 1834. ...read more.


The Governments intervention in society throughout the First World War "prepared the way for a more state-managed form of capitalism." (Fulcher and Scott, 1999/2003: 832) The inter-war years saw long-term structural unemployment, economic depression and housing shortages. The Second World War meant a continuation of state intervention in welfare provision, while "civil defence brought social classes together" (Timmins, 1995: 34). It was into this climate of national unification against adversity that William Beveridge's ideas "provided the framework of the modern welfare state" (Taylor et al, 1995/2005: 155). His report, published in 1942, made recommendations for a national system of initiatives which would slay the "five giants" of social deprivation: want, disease, ignorance, squalor and idleness. The report was based on universal principles. Every citizen would be granted benefits simply by dint of their citizenship. The National Insurance Act of 1946 was "the core of the Beveridge report: state-run insurance, paid for by employers, employees and the general taxpayer, from cradle to grave" (Timmins, 1995: 135). Following Keynesian ideas of state intervention in labour markets to ensure full employment, Beveridge's initiatives "argued along the grain of current thinking" (Timmins, 1995: 38) and were massively popular. The report also contained radical proposals for extending healthcare, education and improved housing to the populace - including the creation of the NHS via the National Health Act of 1948. ...read more.


His program took its cue for welfare reform from the "third way" theories of Giddens (1994, cited in Fulcher 1999/2003). The central core of Giddens' "third way" is the idea that citizenship entails obligations as well as rights - chief amongst which is the obligation to undertake paid employment if at all possible and contribute to the state through taxes. Blair's vision of "third way" Britain also encompassed a mixed economy of welfare, in which the state, the market, the voluntary (ie charity) sector and the informal (ie family and friends) sector combined to lessen the impact of the social problems targeted in the Beveridge report. Yet practical reality has not been radically different from Thatcher's reign, with privatisation continuing, benefits being reduced and being linked to participation in employment and training, continued rhetorical insistence on the responsibilities of the individual and "more than a hint of authoritarianism" (Fulcher and Scott, 1999/2003: 850). In its undiluted form - seen until 1979 - the welfare state made huge strides towards achieving its aims. The price of these gains - excessive inflation and high unemployment by the mid-1970s - allowed the contraction of the welfare state and the reversal of much of the progress made at the hands of Conservative governments since 1979. The current Labour administration has continued dismantling the welfare state, whilst masking its actions as a "third way" between market liberal and welfare state principles. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Sources of Law section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Sources of Law essays

  1. Jury Essay

    In this case the jury refused to convict even if there was no defence. Cases like this help promote fairness and equality in the legal system. Most juries should be impartial, as they are not usually connected to other cases.

  2. How effective were the Liberal Reforms between 1906 and 1914?

    The fact that there were huge exclusions to Liberal legislation adds to the idea that Liberal rule was not very successful with dealing with poverty and need. In conclusion, there are two views on how successful the Liberals were in dealing with the problems of poverty and need.

  1. How successful were the Liberal Reforms of 1906-1914?

    The issue that created the greatest difficulties for the Liberals, was one of the oldest: Ireland. In April, 1912. Armed with new powers of the Parliament Act, Asquith introduced a new Home Bill Rule. Conservative opposition to it was reinforced on this occasion by a popular Protestant movement in Ulster;

  2. Critically evaluate the partial defence of Provocation.

    affect his power of self-control may be attributed to the reasonable man. However, it was concluded from DPP v Camplin, Smith that certain characteristics ought to always be excluded, e.g. bad temper and excitability, because they are contradictory to the concept of the 'reasonable man' (i.e.

  1. The Not-So-Secret Affair Between State and Church.

    Continuing his quest for tradition in his second term, President Bush hopes to pass a constitutional amendment to correlate with the Defence of Marriage Act of 1996, stating that marriage is between one man and one woman. A bill of the same wind passed in the House, the Marriage Protection

  2. Investigate The Employment Of People With Disabilities

    and immune function so that the patient becomes vulnerable to pneumonia, fungal infections, and other common ailments. [2] Explain How Discrimination Limits Employment Opportunities Denial Of Job Opportunities, Limited Access To Building And Equipment, Lack Of Understanding, Denial Of Job Opportunities Some employees are afraid to employ people with disabilities

  1. Care Values and Practice Module

    with regards to human rights infringements, there is the chance the ruling can be over turned by the European Court in Strasbourg. Question 2 In the case of Tisha it seems that most of her rights have been neglected, under the children's Act 2004.

  2. To what extent has the war on terror had an effect on the idea ...

    The state now had the power to enter and search homes, businesses, and other privately owned properties without warning or explanation. It also granted the law enforcers powers to tap phones, check e-mail messages and monitor internet websites people visited.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work