• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10

I will look at different black theologies and different theories of justice, and attempt to compare them, concluding with which system of justice makes for an ordered flourishing community. Communitarian Theories of Justice

Extracts from this document...


To what extent does black theology have a coherent understanding of justice? Introduction Essentially, the word "justice" is derived from the Latin word "ius," meaning right or law, and the Greek word "???????" meaning righteous or moral. Individualist theories assert that the good of the individual comes first, and the good of the community, second; communitarian theories assume the reverse. A compromise between these positions is usually sought. For Aristotle, justice is the intellectual virtue of prudence: the balancing of one's own interest with the rights of others. This provides us with the capacity to balance the rights of the individual with the responsibilities of the community. Indeed, Aristotle finds that all virtuous behaviour leads to one being ?????????and justice will follow on from such behaviour. One maintains society as one maintains oneself; for society to flourish, individuals must also flourish. This is clear when Aristotle expresses it in a proverb: "in justice is summed up the whole of virtue,"1 It is difficult to offer a qualitative assessment of the extent of how coherent an understanding North American black theology has of justice. Instead, it may be better to qualify the extent of justice comparatively. Alternatively, as both justice and black theology are ambiguous and can be defined differently, I will look at different black theologies and different theories of justice, and attempt to compare them, concluding with which system of justice makes for an ordered flourishing community. Communitarian Theories of Justice Communitarian theories assume that society is rather more than merely the sum of its parts. Its starting point is the view that being an individual is only possible if the society initially recognises the concept of individuality. This arguably began with Plato's Republic and Laws where the good of the whole of the city-state is placed above the good of any single individual and is continued by Aristotle in Ethics and Politics to a certain extent. ...read more.


Having looked at society, he tries to unpack it in a theoretical way. This means that it is descriptive not prescriptive. Nozick defines justice in terms of "entitlement". Everyone is entitled to what they have, earn or acquire as long as it does in the way in which my society or community defines as legal. Indeed, there are three main principles at work in a just society, and these principles apply to the just distribution of all "holdings": firstly just acquisition; secondly just transfer; thirdly rectification (the resort to law if the acquisition or transfer of goods or holdings has been illegal). If all of the principles are adhered to then everyone is legally entitled to what they have got. In this way, rich weapons dealers or cigarette manufacturers are allowed, as long as the goods or holdings in which they deal are transferred and acquired legally, then the society is a just one. This is what constitutes justice. We have no moral obligations to anyone except ourselves, and provided we live by the rules of society then we are morally safe. There are many different attitudes towards black theology, but essentially it was developed not for an intellectual ruling elite but instead for tens of millions of working class blacks in the United States. It emerges from their experiences of hundreds of years of white racism and economic exploitation, two forms of discrimination that are inseparable and which still exist in our time. In the mid 20th Century blacks rebelled against racism and their imposed poverty during the Civil Rights movements, with radicals rallying around the slogan: Black Power! Black theology allied itself with this black power movement that was clearly calling for a new economic order. James Foreman's Black Manifesto saw clearly that liberation would not work within a capitalist system: any black man or Negro who is advocating a perpetuation of capitalism inside the United States is in fact seeking not only his ultimate destruction and death but is contributing to the continuous exploitation of black people all around the world. ...read more.


For in Cone's black view, justice is human willed, but God demonstrates justice through human agency, i.e. God siding with the poor, where there clearly is a justice of inequality. In the beginnings of black theology, while it was just emerging, the first and most evident source of oppression of blacks was white racism. So racism became its primary target, while black theology's support for socialism remained under the surface. However as black theology developed, writers like Cone and West recognized the value of a Marxist critique of the capitalist system, and integrated that into black theology and now call for a total liberation of black people from both racism, capitalism, and imperialism. This is a huge step towards justice. Conclusion There are many different black theologies with different outlooks. Indeed, many self-titled black theologians criticise other self-titled theologians for not actually having a black theology. James Cone thought that Martin Luther King did not have a theology. The fact that many "black theologians" have thought that King did not actually have an academic theology meant that I felt it acceptable not to include him in this essay. Instead, I have tried to show how different black theologies have understandings of different theories of justice. Therefore I think that there is a significant understanding of justice and the ramifications of it in black theologies. Obviously by defining justice in different ways, the significance of justice in black theology can be augmented or reduced. However, I have tried to compare some of the most widely acclaimed theories of justice with well-known black theologies and my conclusion thus far has been that there is definitely a coherent sense of justice apparent in most black theologies. Katie Cannon sums up this point succinctly:12 "Black religion and black church served as a sustaining force, assuring boundless justice." Black theology emerges from black religion and the black church, and so it too tries to assure boundless justice, and does so coherently in my opinion. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Machinery of Justice section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Machinery of Justice essays

  1. Critically analyse the relationship between law and justice.

    The rule of law is one of the cornerstones of democratic state and in those with written constitutions (which we do not have) it is guaranteed. Hence government excesses could be found not only illegal but unconstitutional as the constitution is treated as a higher form of law by which the actions of the government and other are measured.

  2. Free essay

    Law and Justice

    Bureau cannot give specific legal advice and even though 'Accident Helplines' provide help on a 'no win no fee' basis, a successful claim could see 25% of the damages awarded going to the lawyer. More recently, there has been the introduction of the controversial Criminal Justice Act 2003, which John

  1. Law and Morality. Within the justice system there is a genuine relationship between law ...

    For instance, in R v Brown, D's stuck pins in each other for pleasure and was charged with assaults. The CoA quashed their appeals and held that individuals were not allowed to consent to violence that may harm themselves, this case clearly illustrates that moral views are not always taken into account.

  2. Discuss the meaning of 'justice'. Consider the extent to which justice is achieved in ...

    But in civil law, the law can often favour the wealthier party, as they are able to drag out proceedings for a long time. When considering the rules of natural justice and the rules of evidence, it must be ensured that trials are entirely fair, and that both parties have

  1. Free essay

    Examine the relationship between law and morals. Consider the extent to which the law ...

    it continued 'It is not in our view the function of the law to intervene in the private life of citizens, or to seek to enforce any pattern of behaviour, further than is necessary to carry out the purpose that we have outlined.'

  2. What Impact will Formalising Plea Bargaining have on Justice and Equality in the English ...

    restated that "plea bargaining, in the sense of seeking to extract from a judge an indication of the sentence which he will give if a particular defendant pleads guilty, forms no part of English criminal jurisprudence".10 Today in American courts unlike the English legal system, a system of open-court bargaining replaces trials in most criminal cases.

  1. "If the Constitution is the source of governmental power, and the judiciary interprets the ...

    Furman v Georgia Thurgood Marshall attacked the penalty more directly stating, "it is excessive, unnecessary, and offensive to contemporary values." This is an interesting incite into the 'moral reading' of the constitution that is so often denied by those in the legal profession and brings us onto one of the other limits of Supreme Court power.

  2. To what extent is it still true to say that legal justice in England ...

    policing and questioning processes seem to be controversial to the due process guidelines. On the other side, in Japan, there is a 99.9% conviction rate from using a crime control method, although these statistics are impressive, one can only imagine the number of injustices caused.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work