• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In relation to murder (including voluntary manslaughter), consider the suggestion that the current law is unsatisfactory.

Extracts from this document...


In relation to murder (including voluntary manslaughter), consider the suggestion that the current law is unsatisfactory. In the proposals published in December 2005, the Law Commission says that the law governing homicide in England and Wales is a 'rickety structure set upon shaky foundations' and propose that for the first time, the general law of homicide be rationalized through legislation. The AR of murder being the unlawful killing of a human being can be unclear as there is no definition of death, nor a ruling as to exactly when it takes place, modern life support technology (life support machine) can make death a gray area whereas in the past they would have died. This was the case in Malchrek and Steele where the court decided obiter that death meant brain dead. This is not considered a problem as the rule of causation can be used to establish liability. CLR agreed that it's better not to have a strict definition of death. ...read more.


The LC said a person acts intentionally with respect to a result when, it is his purpose to cause it or although it is not his purpose to cause it, he knows that it would occur in the ordinary course of events if he was to succeed in his purpose of causing some other result. This can lead to confusion in a jury and lead to inconsistent verdicts. The LC proposes the D should have intention where s/he knows that the result would occur in the ordinary course of events. Murder carries a mandatory life sentence, which is where the judge has no choice but to impose this sentence. This means aggravating and mitigating factors can't be taken into account. The judge can't discriminate between different types of murder e.g. Cocker- who acted out of mercy. The HA 1957 had to create a partial defence to murder to give the judge some sentencing discretion in some situations. ...read more.


In Duffy it was said that the loss of temper must be sudden and temporary. This defence is seen as one that favors men as women in cases like Ahluwalia and Thornton act out of fear but don't have the defence of provocation. A sudden reform would be to remove the need for a sudden and temporary loss of control and simply return to a loss of control taking all the relevant factors into consideration. A new defence may be created called 'self preservation' that would take into account the way women react. In Holley the PC ruled that the jury should expect the level of control of an ordinary person of D's age and sex. Personal characteristics are only taken into account in deciding the gravity of the provocation. The LC proposes that the objective test should be based on a person of D's age and temperament. This supports the PC decision in Holley. If all the LC reforms were implemented, the criticisms would be addressed and the law on homicide will be improved. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Criminal Law section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Criminal Law essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Critical evaluation of murder for A2 law unit 4

    3 star(s)

    They should pay for all the pain they have caused to the family of the victim, and the fact that they denied someone the previalage to live the rest of their lives - they gave up the right to be a normal human being and be able to enjoy their

  2. Marked by a teacher

    Reform of the law on murder.The law commission say it is rickety structure set ...

    3 star(s)

    There is currently a new proposal for reform Coroners and Justice Act 2009. Some of these proposals include reforming the partial defences to replace Homicide Act s.2 and s.3. This would mean provocation would change to loss of control. At the moment there is a gender issue where women can't

  1. The law relating to the defence of insanity is out dated and unsatisfactory. Reform ...

    Another obvious criticism is that these rules which define insanity are a strictly legal term - there is no link what so ever between medical insanity and legal insanity, so the statement is accurate in suggesting reform in the interest of common sense.

  2. Law A2 unit 4 murder problem answer plan

    Also, the chain of causation can be broken by the actions of the victim, so the fact that Derek jumped in to the river could mean a break in causation as Charles may not have anticipated the fact that the chase may have lead to the river, and because Derek

  1. The justifiable use of force in self-defence depends entirely upon the circumstances in which ...

    This allows those to rely on the defence when they acted in the spare of the moment, and that at the time they generally believed it to be necessary. Lord Lane CJ in Whyte said that "the jury should be reminded that [the defendant's] state of mind, that his view

  2. Murder and Voluntary manslaughter - analysis of cases and the plea of involuntary manslaughter.

    is 'No'. She would have died anyway. Judicial Principle: Therefore the defendant was acquitted of murder because he did not cause his mother death as there was no factual cause of the death because the actual cause was natural and not affected by the defendants act The principle can also be seen in an unusual way.

  1. Liability in criminal law requires the prosecution to establish that the accused has caused ...

    Another way in which the chain of causation can be broken is through the actions of the victim. In the case of Roberts (1971) the victim jumped out of a moving car to escape the sexual advances coming from the defendant.

  2. Property Offences, Corporate Manslaughter and Police Powers of Search and Entry.

    If a violent incident has happened in a business such as someone stealing an item from the business then the police can stop and search a person as the police will know that they will find the item. If the police stop to search a person, they have to provide

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work