• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11
  12. 12

Penal Studies for Professional Practice

Extracts from this document...


Penal Studies for Professional Practice "Women in prison face greater resettlement problems than men on release". Examine this statement and use research and academic writing and your own practice to find evidence to support or disprove this statement. The purpose of this essay is to support of disprove the statement "women in prison face greater resettlement problems than men on release". Research undertaken on the resettlement of female and male offenders has highlighted that little information currently exists. Therefore, I have widened my reading to include information on the characteristics of female and male offenders, their experiences of prison and the impact this has on their lives, as it is these which create and shape resettlement needs. To begin I will provide a brief description of the current rate and type of women being imprisoned. I will then go on to consider the aim of resettlement and what it encompasses. Following this I plan to investigate those issues deemed to be the cause of resettlement difficulties. I will focus on; housing, childcare, education and employment and substance misuse and will compare findings within these areas for both sexes. I appreciate that both long-term and short-term prisoners may both have resettlement needs, however, due to the limitations of this essay I will focus on those women in receipt of short custodial sentences as these form the vast majority of women prisoners today. I shall also look at other factors which may affect resettlement; including current release arrangements, the stigma attached to female offending and the fact that women form the minority of the total prison population. To conclude, I will argue that women do face greater resettlement problems than men. This is based upon findings that the majority receive short-term sentences meaning that they are not eligible for post-release supervision. Also there appears to be limited resources specifically for women, and their offending is less accepted in society. ...read more.


custody or their children, but also if the child is resistant or shows signs of resentment as this will make it difficult to re-establish the relationship (O'Dwyer, Wilson & Carlen, cited Carlen & Worrall 1992, p187). My research has also identified that some women experience resettlement problems related to lack of education and training. For example, a 2001 resettlement survey found that only 18% of women had employment or training courses arranged on release, compared with 30% of males (Home Office, 2003). Also, when interviewed five to nine months after discharge only 25% were in employment. This may be in part due to an "absence of an overall assessment of the educational and vocational needs of the [female] prison population" (HM Chief Inspector of Prisons 1997, p120) It appears that women do not have access to the same range of opportunities for work and education. This may be due to the fact that there is the expectation that the majority of women offenders are mums, therefore they wont be seeing work on release (House of Commons Home Affairs Committee 2004, p89). Furthermore programmes inside prison such as 'Enhanced Thinking Skills' and 'Cognitive Skills Booster' (House of Commons Home Affairs Committee, 2004 p88) Programme tend to focus on the rehabilitation of women offenders using Cognitive Behavioural techniques. However not only have these programmes been designed for men, but also it is known that interventions based on developing cognitive skills are of little use for women, who have little deficiencies in this area and who are more in touch with their feelings than their male counterparts (Carlen 2002). They also fail to accommodate the needs of women Foreign National offenders' who do not speak English and hence will neither understand nor benefit from such interventions (Singh, 2004). Lacking the relevant skills and experience and often having resumed childcare responsibilities many women face unemployment on release and hence consequently are forced to become reliant on benefits. ...read more.


Having undertaken research I have formed the opinion that women at present do face greater resettlement problems than men. This is primarily based on the premise that women are more likely to receive short custodial sentences deeming them ineligible for statutory probation supervision. Also due to the fact that they currently constitute such a small percentage of the overall prison population, their needs seem to have been forgotten or overlooked. Whilst it has been acknowledged that men and women have different needs which warrant a distinct response, at present they are still part of a system that was designed to cater for men. Furthermore having analysed the particular areas set out in the introduction of this paper, it would appear that they face particular strains related family responsibilities and childcare as many women offenders are single parents. In addition, on release many women find themselves homeless, unemployed and some even suffering from drug addictions, therefore one or a combination of these factors will render women vulnerable and insecure and more in need of resettlement help and advice. It has been accepted that the Government and Criminal Justice System as a whole are working to improve resettlement services for women. Not only by the introduction of NOMS, but also with new policies and legislative changes. However, these are still in their infancy and do not come without complications such as need for additional resources and co-operation and communication between the various agencies involved. Finally, it must be remembered that women offenders are not a homogenous group of individuals and hence some may encounter little difficulties resettling. Also individual choice and decision making are integral to avoid re-offending and allow effective re-integration. Furthermore, I am not of the opinion that men do not face resettlement problems, however I would argue that the Criminal Justice System currently exhorts and essentially male ethos and whilst efforts are being made to modify this, more resources need to be injected into putting some of these well documented policies into action. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Machinery of Justice section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Machinery of Justice essays

  1. Free essay

    Critically discuss whether the criminal courts of England and Wales require substantial reform. Firstly ...

    The Criminal Justice System is a living instrument. It must be relevant and kept relevant to the changing needs of the community it serves. That court was built long before the typewriter. There was no electric light, no telephone. All these, when introduced, were "modern technology".

  2. Critically evaluate the aims and consequences of sentencing and show how the laws regarding ...

    In Storey (1973) 57 Cr App R 840 the County Court Judge gave Storey a 3 year sentence for mugging. The judge stated that he was deterring other people from mugging, although it was found that there was no reduction over the next 5 years.

  1. Conditional Fee Arrangements and Legal Aid

    justice, even if lawyers were choosing the high-value winnable cases and leaving many low-value cases without remedy. b) To what extent have the recent reforms in legal aid been motivated by financial concerns rather than a desire to ensure access to justice for all?

  2. The Penal System - Discuss the aims of sentencing and consider other factors the ...

    It is an extension of the idea of punishment because the criminal has done something morally and socially wrong. Judges when pronouncing a sentence with the aim of denunciation are expressing the disproval and un-acceptance of society. In this way punishment and certain sentences are used by Judges to enforce and maintain the limits of tolerability in society.

  1. Explain the ranges of sentences available to the judge or magistrate.

    It is argued that every time a crime is committed the theory of deterrence is weakened. Moreover, reconviction highlights the failure of the previous sentence. Andrew Ashworth sates that where a "former prisoner is not reconvicted within two years, one cannot tell whether the explanation for that is the rehabilitative

  2. The Canadian Justice system towards aboriginal offenders

    As aboriginal authors Monture-Okanee and Turpel describe: The person with authority to resolve conflicts among aboriginal peoples in their community must be someone known to them who can look at all aspects of a problem, not an unknown person set apart from the community in an 'impartial' way.

  1. Juries Essay

    Now, with the exception of the armed services must do jury duty if called. The Central Summonsing Bureau selects enough jurors for a two week period. More than 12 people are chosen due to them not knowing who will be disqualified or will ask for discretionary excusal.

  2. Expert Testimony and Its Value In the Justice System

    no professional qualifications or has little experience would be allowed to stand as an expert. This was shown in the case of R v Robb[13] where it was deemed that ?the courts would not accept the evidence of an astrologer, a soothsayer, a witchdoctor or an amateur psychologist?[14].

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work