• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

R v David Smith. - ABH, criminal law

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

R v David Smith a) The Prosecutors Submission: The Defendant is charged with two cases of assault occasioning Actual Bodily Harm, according to Section 47 of the Offences against the Person Act 1861, arising out of an incident that occurred in Theobald Road, Smallville on the 11th of August 2003. This is an aggravated assault, and the Prosecution must prove an unlawful assault which caused the victim to sustain an injury that is more than merely 'trifling' or 'superficial,' but as long as the injury is 'not so trivial as to be insignificant,' it shall suffice. The defendant has pleaded guilty to both of the charges. In a brief summary of the facts, David Smith was alone in his car on the early morning of the 11th of August 2003. Whilst driving along Lansdowne Road, he turned into Beda Road and upon seeing a marked police traffic patrol vehicle, stuck his fingers out of the window and made an obscene gesture at the Police officer operating the marked vehicle. David Smith then turned into Brunswick Street, driving in the middle of the road, causing a taxi to take evasive action. Mr Smith proceeded to make a number of left and right turns whilst travelling at speeds of up to sixty miles per hour in a thirty miles per hour residential area. Mr Smith got out of his vehicle at the end of Lansdowne Road and ran away from the police car in a Westerly direction. ...read more.

Middle

His previous Actual Bodily Harm Offence highlighted his violent side when he punched a neighbour in the face. In the eyes of the prosecution, this shows that as a repeat offender he must move up the sentencing hierarchy. . b) Mitigating Circumstances: I shall begin as before by looking at the circumstances, then the character and situation of the Defendant. Mr. Smith pleaded guilty to all offences levelled at him, but the punishment dealt seems to outweigh the actions. The struggle with the officers was unsavoury but by no means a pre-meditated attack on another person. As said in the interview, Mr. Smith was purely defending himself as he was pushed to the ground. Mr. Smith was not trying to injure the police officers, but merely escape to carry on the chase. Dr. Hood inspected the police officers an hour later and whilst recognising breaks in the skin, said the injuries were of a superficial nature and of mild force. No further treatment was necessary and this is reinforced by the fact that it took ten minutes to clear both Officers. Mr. Smith deserves an amount of credit for pleading guilty to the attacks and has said that even though he can't recall specifically what happened, he is sorry for the attack on them. He accepts what he did was wrong and knows he should not have raced with the police or initiate a chase on foot. He admits to losing control of himself and is prepared to see someone in order to gain some responsibility. ...read more.

Conclusion

was also given six months in prison for punching and butting an officer. One case which does support Mr. Smith is that of R v Aguilar (1985) where part of a six month sentence was suspended due to the defendant having a job and excellent background, with employers willing to take him back. This will aid Mr. Smith due to the fact he has just found a job after a long period out of work, and although not too similar to R v Aguilar (1985), the employment aspect of suspending a sentence may aid Mr. Smith. The cases above offer guidelines in terms of how Mr. Smith should be dealt with, and the last thing left to consider is his previous sentences and character. Although Mr. Smith has found a job and seems to recognise his problems with responsibility, the punishments of his previous crimes have never really deterred him from re-offending in one way or another, be it the same crime or a new one. His previous conviction for assault occasioning Actual Bodily Harm shows a violent streak and no end of compensations and fines to be paid out have resulted in a halt of such activities. It is obvious that the cases above have all imposed a custodial sentence in light of a section 47 assault on a police officer and Mr. Smith shall be no different. In respect of precedent and with the consideration of all aggravating, mitigating and case law factors, and the totality principle of Mr. Smith having two charges of assault occasioning Actual Bodily Harm, I believe it suitable that Mr. Smith receive a custodial sentence of 6-12 months Word Count: 1,986 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Machinery of Justice section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Machinery of Justice essays

  1. A rule as to precedent (which any court lays down for itself) is not ...

    In R v Smith, the HOL gave a positive answer to that question and held that Parliament had intended by s3 of the Homicide Act 1957 to give the jury full authority to decide whether the reaosnable person would have acted as the defendant did, and along with that the prerogative to decide what characteristics should attributable.

  2. The Death Penalty in Canada. There are many issues surrounding the rebirth of ...

    Mental illness is a touchy subject whilst dealing with the death penalty. However, mentally ill people have been given the death penalty and it is an unfair and unjust action which again deteriorates the value of human life. Some criminals may also not see it as a deterrent because they may have the option of pleading insanity.

  1. Microsoft Antitrust Case Microsoft is a large diversified computer software manufacturer. Microsoft produces ...

    Microsoft argued that competition in the software sector was intense and that a new competitor or entrant could replace its leadership position at any time. They also argued that they were a leader in software innovation and that they have enhanced rather than hobbled the innovation process.

  2. Why do young people join gangs and other subcultures? How does a criminal sub ...

    Subcultures are often defined via their opposition to the values of the larger culture to which they belong, although this definition is not universally agreed on by theorists. Wikipedia (2006) Members of a subculture will often signal their membership through a distinctive and symbolic use of style.

  1. How does Peter Medak gain the viewer's sympathy for Derek Bentley in the film ...

    We feel sorry for him that he is being forced to do something that he doesn't want to do. During the shootout Bentley attempts to help the police but they rudely refuse. At this point we think how he would know what to do in such a situation, the police

  2. Describe with the aid of examples, the authorities, representative bodies or persons that exercise ...

    have within four weeks before the winding up resolution is passed made a statutory declaration as to the company's solvency at a board meeting, and have in that declaration stated that, after having fully examined the company's situation, they agreed that the company will be able to pay its debts

  1. Explain the ranges of sentences available to the judge or magistrate.

    These ideas largely stem from religious influences on our culture. However, a deeper psychological explanation has been argued to exist, underlying the offender's need for expiration. Guilt is a state of tension which gives rise to a need for the removal of this tension.

  2. Describe the different aims of sentencing.

    Deterrence is one of the six aims considered when sentencing an offender. This simply mean to discourage an offender from re-offending or to discourage others from offending. Deterrence can be split into two main types; individual and general deterrence. Individual deterrence, such as custodial sentences are imposed to make the

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work