• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Several tests have been developed to identify and categorise different types of workers.

Extracts from this document...


Several tests have been developed to identify and categorise different types of workers. The basic division for our purposes is between those who are employed persons and those who are self employed, and the distinction between these categories is that the employed person works under a contract of service, while the self-employed person works under a contract for services1. An important criterion for determining whether the relationship between employer and employee exists is the extent to which a person is under the direction and control of the other party with regard to the manner in which the work is done.2 It would be improper to use this test, where professional are involved, as it is likely that the employee will be qualified in a particular field, thus making direct control of the employee difficult. For example does a football manager have the right to control how his players play on the pitch, as questioned in Walker v Crystal Palace Football Club (1909). Despite this difficulty, a refinement to this test, where the "right to control" has been used a determinant factor.3 It is clear from these cases the higher the degree of control exercisable by the employer, the more likely that ...read more.


This obligation was a determining factor. Therefore the EAT refused to alter the tribunals decision. This case may be contrasted with Carmichael v National Power plc, where there was no mutuality of obligations. A more problematic area of law for the courts to decide upon has been in the form of atypical workers, such as casual workers, agency workers and home workers. The groups often find it difficult to establish a contract of service and the rights, which accrue under this label. Some workers are employed under a casual basis, or on short-term periodic contracts.. As previously discussed, implied into the contract of employment is mutuality of obligations, therefore an obligation to provide and accept work, without which a contract of employment cannot exist. There have been attempts to pay national insurance and tax as an employee would for the actual periods worked so that they may be classed as employees, but to no avail.10 In particular, where the terms which casual work is offered/accepted expressly negate mutuality of obligations, there can be no implied obligation or overarching contract. An attempt to treat such workers under a 'global contract' has been put forward but with limited success. ...read more.


This lack of mutual obligation goes against Lisa. As described in O'Kelly v Trust House Forte plc, the lack of mutual obligation, and more importantly no promise to provide work by the employer. Karim or Jordan controls Lisa, and she is integral to the business. She cannot profit other than by wages. There mutuality of obligations is vital. One avenue could be that Lisa could try, is course of dealings. As stated, although the work was casual, she did indeed accept the work as it was offered. Therefore a mutual obligation could be implied, and therefore provide Lisa with a remedy.16 1 Stevenson, Jordan & Harrison [1952] 2 Yewens v Noakes 3 Gibb v United Steel Companies Ltd 4 Whittaker v MPNI 5 Beloff v Pressdram 6 MacFarlane v Glasgow City Council 7 Market Investigations Ltd v Minister of Social Security 8 Lane v Shire Roofing Co (Oxford) 9 Tyne and Clyde Warehouses Ltd v Hamerton 10 Stevedoring & Haulage Services Ltd v Fuller 11 Clark v Oxfordshire Health Authority 12 Hellyer Bros Ltd v McLeod 13 Motorola Ltd v Davidson 14 Hewlett Packard v O'Murphy 15 Glasgow v Independent Printing Co 16 Nethermere (St. Neot) Ltd v Taverna and Gardiner ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Law of Contract section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Law of Contract essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Contract Law - Offer And Acceptance

    3 star(s)

    Archital Luxfer Ltd 1993 T built industrial units and subcontracted the windows to L. The work was done and paid for. T then claimed damages from L because of defects in the windows. L argued that even though there had been letters, phone calls and meetings between the parties, there was no matching offer and acceptance and so no contract.

  2. Four ways in which a contract may be discharged.

    Jarvis v Swan Tours Ltd [1973] 1 All ER 71. The plaintiff had booked a two-week winter sports holiday, which was described as a 'house party' and promised, among other things, a welcome party, afternoon tea and a yodelling evening.

  1. Invitation To Treat

    Conclusion In this case, the agreement from John to migrate to Australia is a social agreement which is unenforceable. There is no consideration from John's sister even selling off her house in England as she and her husband got the money back.

  2. Legal advice for Equipment Hire Limited.

    Which means Sunil may have agreed to hire the ladder on the basis of its description alone and therefore never had the chance to inspect the ladder. Also, section 5(1) states 'This section applies where, under a contract for the transfer of goods, the transferor transfers or agrees to transfer the property in the goods by reference to a sample'.

  1. I have been asked to advise a client on considering contracting with a building ...

    (Taken from Common Law 1 BPP) The outcome of the case was that she was entitled to the debt with interest. No consideration had been given by the claimant for the waiver of any part of her rights against him.

  2. In advising Bennys position of the interest over the said property (the flat), it ...

    6 Section 5(1)(b) of CPO stated: "A declaration of trust respecting land or any interest therein shall be manifested and proved in writing and signed by the person who is able to declare such trust or by his will." 7 Presumption of a resulting trust is on the assumption that

  1. "It would be hard to over emphasise either the contribution made by implied terms ...

    licence, courts decided in express terms that he was required to hold a clean driving licence, even though it was not written in a statement. McIntosh did not win his case, as with all contract terms they have equal validity, and express terms will override implied terms.

  2. What is the importance of implied terms to the contract of employment

    I will evaluate the importance of implied terms by assessing the employment relationship in terms of the employee's obligations to the employer and the employer's obligations to the employee rather than providing a series of 'light weight' arguments. The employee's obligations to the employer include to the duty to obey

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work