• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Statutory Interpretation

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Statutory Interpretation The process by whereby judges attribute meanings to words in a statute in order to apply the relevant statute to a case to reach a decision. There are two approaches: Literal and Purposive. The literal approach is where the words are given their plain, ordinary and grammatical meanings. The purposive approach is when the judge looks at the intentions of parliament. Aids available: There are two types of aids available for statutory interpretation, they are Internal aids, which are included within the act, or External aids that are not included within the act. INTERNAL AIDS These are most likely to be used when the literal or golden rules are being applied, but might also be useful in finding the purpose of the act. These parts of the act can be used so long as they do not conflict with the clear enacting words of a statute: * Preamble (often found in old statutes, setting out what acts must do; private acts must have them) * Long Title (sets out the aim of the Act) * Short Title * Definitions section (helps with the literal approach, as words are given their meaning) Punctuation is disregarded, as it was not originally used. EXTERNAL AIDS These are mostly used by judges trying to find the purpose of the act. The following have been traditionally used: * Historical setting * Other statutes * Textbooks * Previous practice in the field covered by the statute * Treaties and international obligations * Subordinate legislation * Dictionaries (used for the golden and literal rules) ...read more.

Middle

* Town Causes Act 1847 * Two police officers were sent to 'stake out' the toilet the offender, after they had been receiving complaints about the behaviour of a man in a public toilet. * They saw Cheeseman indecently expose himself to them. * The extended meaning of the word street included the public toilet. * However the defendant was found not guilty, because the policemen did not fit into the definition of a passenger as they were not 'a passer by or through; a traveller (usually on foot); a wayfarer' ABSURD RESULT Golden rule Lord Wensleydale defined the golden rule in Greg v Pearson (1857) as a sensible view of matters. The golden rule is used to prevent an injustice or absurd result, or when the court has to choose one of two words. Advantages Avoids absurd results Disadvantages That it is not as broad as the mischief rule. CASES Re: Sigsworth (1935) * Son murders his mother * It is discovered that the mother has left no will * Normally it would go to the next of kin, which in this case would be the son * Court was not going to let a murderer inherit the estate of the person they have killed * Court effectively wrote that the 'issue' would not be entitled to inherit where they had killed the deceased R v Allen (1872) ...read more.

Conclusion

was done by nurses without doctor's supervision * H/L said it was lawful because of the mischief rule Elliot v Grey 1960 * Road traffic act 1930 meant it was illegal for an 'uninsured car to be used on the road' * Fact was that there was a jacked up car with no battery on the road * Found guilty because the intention of parliament was for people to use insured cars Rules of language Ejusdem Generis - general words which follow specific words are taken to include only things of the same kind. Powell v Kempton Park Racecourse (1899) Expressio unius exclusio alterius - the express mention of one thing, excludes others. Eg, No dogs allowed on the train, could mean that donkeys are allowed Noscitur a sociis - a word is known by the company it keeps Presumptions 1. Mens rea - no one can be convicted unless they have a blameworthy state of mind 2. Statutes don't change common law 3. Crown is not bound by any statute 4. Legislation does not apply retrospectively 5. It applies generally through the UK 6. International obligations wont be breached 7. Laws creating crimes should be interpreted in the favour of the citizen 8. Nothing is removed from the courts jurisdiction 9. Existing rights are not interfered with 10. If property rights are interfered with, the victim will be compensated European Legislation The purposive rule is more applicable in Europe because European Legislation is drafted more on purpose. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Sources of Law section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Sources of Law essays

  1. Statutory Interpretation

    Lastly - the mischief rule; if the words of a piece of legislation are uncertain or ambiguous the court will adopt the meaning most likely to give effect tot the intention of Parliament. This rule should only be applied if a literal interpretation does not produce a result.

  2. Statutory Interpretation

    decision as they had blindly interpreted the Act of Parliament without any consideration. The Parliament had to immediately amend the Act before any further miscarriage of justice occurred, and that clearly illustrated the limitation and consequence of using the literal approach.

  1. Statutory interpretation

    The court of appeal ruled that duress could not be used as a defence based on the precedent set out in the House of Lords in (R v Howe, 1987). Another extrinsic aid judges may use to aid them in making their decision is Hansard.

  2. What are the advantages & disadvantages of secondary legislation.

    In looking previously at the different types of secondary legislation it could be seen that the bodies making the legislation are at least in part undemocratic. Statutory instruments are regulations made by government ministers but the decisions can be passed onto civil servants and lower government bodies.

  1. Statutory interpretation

    These are known as intrinsic aids. The court may consider titles, preambles, headings and marginal notes. However, as these are only helpful comments put in by the printer they may not be as helpful in discovering the parliaments intention as compared to extrinsic aids.

  2. Statutory Interpretation

    To interpreting this Judge might adopt Literal rule. Under this rule if the words in statute is clear and natural and so far they do not produce an absurd or totally obnoxious result then, it must be applied(R v Judge of the City of London Court [1892]).

  1. blood wedding plot Garcia Lorca

    They also start talking about the bride and groom and are joined by the wife and Leonardo. They stop when the bride and bridegroom enter. Then they talk about the wedding itself. The rest of the cast leave and we are left with the maid and bridegroom, the maid asks

  2. Indigenous peoples, almost without exception, have been dispossessed and disregarded by those who 'discovered' ...

    Any treaty that purportedly derogates from such a principle is void21. It may be claimed that the 2001 fisheries treaty is void to some extent but, as discussed in part (a), enforcement by an individual is best approached through article 27, because of the contortion of economic self-determination into an individual right.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work