• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"The Chamberlain Case highlighted many of the weaknesses in the Australian legal system

Extracts from this document...


"The Chamberlain Case highlighted many of the weaknesses in the Australian legal system." Do you agree with this assessment? Give examples to illustrate your answer. The case of Lindy Chamberlain was very significant in Australian legal history as it involved the conviction and imprisonment of an innocent person for infanticide. This is occurrence should never have taken place and demonstrated the weaknesses in the Australian legal system. A legal system is meant to be sturdy and never failing system that the public can put its trust ad faith in but this time it fell apart and wrongly convicted an innocent mother, wife and friend. Something needs to be done to ensure the unnecessary imprisonment of an innocent does not occur again. There were many issues in the legal system that let Lindy Chamberlain down. Firstly the expensive court system that disadvantages those who cannot afford the best. Secondly, the inadequacies of the police force. The third issue was the public bias and finally the contaminated jury. Cheap Lawyer "Justice only comes by the expenditure of large amounts of money and support of many friends".1 This statement is true. Not many people in the country can afford the best lawyer and it is true to say that if you have the money to pay for a brilliant lawyer than you will have a good chance at winning any case. ...read more.


Ward an investigator did a test in the same conditions and found threads were not pulled. The police, at a later and dryer time of year, did a similar experiment that was televised. The loops of the jumpsuit were pulled. The media got hold of this and people came up with conclusions.5 The public were given the wrong impressions and evidence by the police, a force that the public have faith in. Public Interference The incident occurred in the Northern Territory, an independent territory with its own government and a tight knit community. Indirectly policies of the rangers had been instrumental in unsettling wildlife to the extent that dingoes had begun attacking humans, a fact that no local wanted to face. The policies of the chief ranger Roff inadvertly helped cause a baby's death.6 The line of the dingo taking the baby involved human intervention7. This intervention was said (and later proven) to have occurred at a local family's, the Cawood's, home and involving many of the locals. The aboriginal black tracker Winmatti was asked by chief ranger Roff to track the dingo that took baby Azaria. Winmatti said the dingo headed west, the direction of the Cawood home and then stopped at the house.8The Cawood's already had history of treating this particular animal like a pet and John Cawood claimed to have already "taken care of it" when the same dingo had attacked another child. ...read more.


The jury is meant to only convict if guilt is beyond reasonable doubt, but in this case the jury still did convict despite Lindy's innocence. Jury bias is strongly demonstrated in this case. The jury system is not an adequate system if it is able to wrongly convict an upstanding citizen. There were many elements that contributed to the failing of the legal system for Lindy Chamberlain. The Australian Legal System is taken from the British system which was developed a long time ago and when scientists or journalists had much affect on the system. With huge advances in science, the average person would be unable to understand let alone to dispute and identify inconsistencies. It is too great a task to understand and evaluates a person's innocence. This system is outdated and needs to be updated as it does not allow for jury bias, diverse ethnicity, bias of expert witnesses and does not give much consideration to discrimination and small town bond. No system of human justice is perfect. Our system has its rules and guidelines yet these are mere words written on paper, in practise it is different and rules are broken or twisted. A person may suffer unfairly at the hands of fellow citizens in a jury box. Sometimes law can be a popularity contest especially in cases so widely publicised and widespread as the Chamberlain one. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Machinery of Justice section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Machinery of Justice essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    ‘Trial by jury is outdated, expensive and ineffective in ensuring justice’ Analyse arguments for ...

    4 star(s)

    The claims of Lord Devlin in the 1970's that juries were primarily made up of white, middle-aged men from middle-class backgrounds was absolutely justified, as at the time, the majority of people registered to vote were exactly that. Research believes that up to twenty percent of black and Asian people

  2. Microsoft Antitrust Case Microsoft is a large diversified computer software manufacturer. Microsoft produces ...

    Explorer Icon on the personal computer desktop, and arguing that the courts were ill equipped to evaluate the benefits of high-tech product design. During the week following the Court of appeals stay regarding the preliminary injunction that barred the bundling of Internet Explorer with Windows because of the alleged violation

  1. Conditional Fee Arrangements and Legal Aid

    They suggest that solicitors will only want to take on cases where there is a very high chance of winning. It was for this reason that medical negligence cases have been kept within the state-funded system. There is also the risk that where legal aid is refused, a subsequent trial

  2. What Impact will Formalising Plea Bargaining have on Justice and Equality in the English ...

    citizens' rights and privileges as it contravenes the European Convention on Human Rights. Firstly, it penalises those who exercise their right to trial (Article 6) and secondly it indirectly discriminates against Afro-Caribbean and Asian defendants which breaches Article 14. Under the European Convention on Human Rights these Articles provide for

  1. I will look at different black theologies and different theories of justice, and attempt ...

    time of anticommunism, viewed as atheist and a direct threat to Christianity, and seen as overly sectarian. In face of these negatives, Cone's interest in Marxism was renewed through contact with Latin American theology. From there he began to recognize the validity of the Marxist critique, agreeing that Christianity had

  2. To what extent does the South Australian legal system guarantee justice?

    ?It is stealing in this case, stealing on a grand scale and deterrence must therefore be a predominant factor in sentencing?.[1] Although mentioning doctrine of precedent in sentencing remarks isn?t required as mandatory in Magistrates, District or Supreme Courts, judges are required to take prior cases into consideration, and are

  1. Expert Testimony and Its Value In the Justice System

    clear that it would be advantageous if there was one unified test which experts must pass for their evidence to become admissible. Such a test could be either subjective or objective. If the test were to be objective then specific guidelines could be set out, the expert would then have

  2. The English Court System

    as of right, but leave of the court is needed for other reasons. And if leave refused, convicted person may appeal to the Home Secretary, who has the power to refer the case back to the Court of Appeal. The House of Lords is the second chamber of the UK Parliament.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work