• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11
  12. 12

"The dichotomy between employee and self-employed is being eroded in employment law, so much so that today it appears meaningless". Discuss.

Extracts from this document...


Question: - "The dichotomy between employee and self-employed is being eroded in employment law, so much so that today it appears meaningless". Discuss. Answer:- T his question requires to analyse the operation of laws governing the classification of employment relationships. Access to employment rights depends to a large extent on whether an individual is employed as an employee. The self-employed and a number of other groups (such as agency workers) tend to find themselves excluded from employment protection law. The answer will reflect how laws relating to the 'status' of employees and the self-employed work in practice, will identify the sources of uncertainty in the application of the legal tests of employment status and will evaluate to what extent the distinction has been eroded and the justification of maintaining the status quo. For a variety of reasons, which will be discussed below, it is important to determine whether a person is employed under a contract of employment. Before discussing the statutory definition of an employee and a self-employed, it will be appropriate to define the terms 'employee' and 'self-employed' generally. The term 'self-employed' means persons who provide services to another party under a contract for services, but are genuinely in business on their own account, in that they are partners in a business or the sole owner of their own business and may employ others1. On the other hand, an employee is an individual who is employed by another under a contract of employment and is not genuinely in business on his or her own account. By s.230 of the Employment Rights Act (hereinafter ERA) 1996: a 'contract of employment' means a contract of service or apprenticeship, whether express or implied, and (if it is implied) whether it is oral or in writing... 'Employee' means an individual who has entered into or works under ...a contract of employment'. This definition of an employee, although provided by statute, is not, however, helpful as it fails to define what is meant by a contract of service. ...read more.


The House of Lords reached a similar conclusion in Carmichael and Lesse v National Power plc18 , where it was decided that guides employed on a 'casual as acquired' basis were self-employed. Lack of mutuality of obligations has led to agency workers being classed as self-employed (Wickers v Champion Employment19), although McMeechan v Secretary of State for Employment20 and trawler men who entered separate crew agreements for each voyage were also deemed to be self-employed, despite the fact that they invariably returned to the same employer, again because of the lack of obligation to provide work or services. However, the position seems to have changed by the application of the recent case Motorola Ltd v Davidson21 where the court found that the requisite employment relationship existed given the practical degree of control exercised by Motorola Ltd over Davidson, and from the fact that Motorola Ltd had conducted disciplinary proceedings culminating in Davidson's dismissal without MC's (an employment agency) knowledge. T he question which must now be asked is: why is the distinction between employees and independent contractors important? A variety of rights and liabilities apply in respect of employees which do not apply to independent contractors. An employee pays insurance contributions which are a percentage of his earnings and the employer also makes a contribution. This gives the employee certain benefits in respect of unemployment, sickness and industrial injury as well as Sate pension rights. An independent contractor pays a flat rate insurance contribution, irrespective of earnings and has no rights to the benefits mentioned. Moreover, an employer must deduct tax at source for his employees and may be committing a criminal offence should he fail to do so (Jennings v Westwood Engineering22). The employer is under no such obligation in relation to independent contractors, although, in the building industry, the employer is required to deduct tax as if the workers are employees and the workers can then claim tax back if they are genuinely self-employed. ...read more.


However, there are arguments against the removal of the distinction. If non-employees have a broader range of statutory employment rights, employers might increase their demands on them or the degree of commitment they expect of them. This could reduce flexibility for these working people. Some atypical workers may enjoy a higher remuneration package than other workers because they do not have the same employment rights protection. Moreover, the elimination of the distinction would fundamentally change the nature of the relationship between certain work providers and working people28. Furthermore, it may reduce employers' willingness to offer atypical working arrangements and some rights, such as maternity rights and the right to unfair dismissal may increase administrative burdens on business. T o conclude, it is, therefore, possible to say that a high degree of uncertainty attaches to the legal criteria by which workers are classified. This means that the effectiveness of the law, in practice, may be called into question. However, it is important for both parties to know what the legal relationship is. On the part employer, he will then know the extent of his liability and on the part of the worker; he will know that rights he has, both in respect of his employer and in the wider context of welfare benefits and employment protection rights. It has also been made clear by above arguments that the existing classifications have become too rigid to deal effectively with the growth of non-standard forms of employment, that is to say, those forms of work which depart from the model of the 'permanent' or indeterminate employment relationship constructed around a full-time, continuous working week. The result is said to be the exclusion of certain groups of workers, whose status is unclear, from the protection of employment legislation29. However, my opinion is in support to maintain the status quo and consider the scope of new rights of the self-employed on a case-by-case basis because radical change of their status may require changing some key Acts of Parliament30 in order to redefine workers and it will impact adversely to the small-businesses and overall economy. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Sources of Law section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Sources of Law essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Critically discuss different possible meanings of justice and explore the relationship between law and ...

    3 star(s)

    This is because Marx rejected capitalism and felt that it was unjust to the society by having it implemented within the law. He feels that within a capitalist society all law is unjust. This is because it represents the means by which one class oppresses the class or classes below it.

  2. Explain the distinction between the law and morals and consider the importance of the ...

    The committee recommended the legalisation of prostitution and homosexuality. This gave rise to much debate on the issues and established the Hart-Devlin debate. Professor Hart agreed with the findings of the committee and argued strongly that there should be a clear separation of law and morality.

  1. Commercial law discussion - 'Transfer of Title by a Non-Owner'.

    The fifth exception is a Sale by a mercantile agent- the concept of a mercantile agent- the concept of a mercantile agent within the meaning of the Factors Act 1989 and the power of sale by such agents has been expressively preserved by s21(2).

  2. Examine the relationship between law and morals and consider whether the law should support ...

    Therefore we should disregard a law which is at odds with this natural code, unless doing so would lead to social unrest. The problem arises in establishing what this higher code is, although it would seem to be based on human rights.

  1. Unmarried fathers and their children - has the law got it right?

    On the basis of the status ...of the child's parents ..." Article .8 of The European Convention on Human Rights is concerned with protecting family life 17, and requires states to take positive steps to enable family life to develop normally.

  2. Legislations and regulations in sport

    Data is defined as information which is: - processed automatically or recorded with the intention to process automatically or - recorded as, or with the intention that it be, part of a manual "relevant filing system" which is further defined in the Act or - contained in a health, educational or social services record.

  1. Outcome (3): Analyse the provisions relating to the police powers of arrest, search, seizure, ...

    This section of the Criminal Justice and Public Order act also give a police constable the power to search the premises where the arrested person was at the time of arrest. A police constable may search the premises if he/she has reasonable grounds to believe that evidence for the arrest is on the premises.

  2. The Nature of Law in Society

    Injunctions, specific performance, rescission and rectification are other examples of civil cases. The state plays no role in civil cases, unless the government launches a lawsuit or is the party being sued. Parties retain a lawyer - or may choose to represent themselves - to gather evidence and present the case in court.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work