• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What are the advantages & disadvantages of secondary legislation.

Extracts from this document...


"What are the advantages & disadvantages of secondary legislation" When looking at the question of the advantages and disadvantages of Secondary Legislation it is first important to establish its advantages and disadvantages as compared to what. That is, what are the other types of legislation that command over what goes on in a society? Once this has been established it is then important to look at these different and see how they differ. Deciphering what makes a particular type of legislation that type can do this. Who makes the type of legislation? How is it implemented and to what degree of the law can it be executed. When this has been done it will be quite clear as to how one type of legislation can be more of an advantage to society than another. When this has been completed it will then be necessary to look at the role of Parliament in the implementation of Secondary Legislation. It will have to be established whether secondary legislation takes away from the law making power of Parliament. Once this has been done an analysis into how widely Secondary Legislation is used will answer the question of whether Parliament is abdicating from its power. ...read more.


Therefore the decision on procedure is being made with the help of people who have a thorough knowledge of the subject. Statutory Instruments are also subject to a Parliamentary Committee that comprises of members of both Houses. They scrutinise any Instruments that draw the attention of Parliament. The grounds of Ultra Vires also give anybody who may be affected by Secondary Legislation the authority to challenge. This is done by Judicial Review were a person can take the body making the decision to the High Court to challenge the decision. Unlike an Act of Parliament, which is supreme and cannot be challenged, Secondary Legislation can be declared void if it does not follow correct procedure or if it is outside the powers granted. Secondary Legislation is more flexible than a act of Parliament. It can be passed quickly and is easily amended or revoked, so the law can be brought up to date. Through primacy of statute it is impossible for the courts to refuse to apply primary Legislation on the grounds that it is invalid or outdated, a later Parliament or ultimately the European Court of Justice can only do this. There are a number of disadvantages associated with the implementation of secondary legislation mainly due to the fact of the sheer numbers of them that are passed every year. ...read more.


Judges, although allowed to offer their own sometimes interpretation, may never act outside the law laid down by parliament. Parliament is an effective lawmaker because it is democratically elected and this means that the laws passed by parliament will reflect the values and demands of the community. Because parliament is representative and responsible, members of Parliament can be voted out of power if laws are passed which the community does not like or is not prepared to accept. On the other hand the courts are not democratically elected and therefore judges do not have the same responsibility to represent the community. This reduces the effectiveness of the courts as a lawmaker as they may make decisions that are old fashioned or that fail to acknowledge changing technology or values. However, because the courts can act independently of public pressure they are able to make controversial decisions that Parliament may not be prepared to make but are actually for the good of the community, or sections of the community. Having both Parliament and the courts making decisions is beneficial for the community and both can monitor the performance of the other in shaping society and it is harder for one to get away with hidden agendas. For example, Parliament passing an Act, that is not very beneficial to society, coming up to an election just to keep their seat. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Sources of Law section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Sources of Law essays


    Sheer Metalcraft Ltd. 1954, it was held that a statutory instrument was valid despite incomplete (cf. above) compliance with the publication requirements. Judicial Control Statutory instruments can be held substantively (if the statutory instrument exceeds the powers or area expressly or implicitly statutorily authorised)

  2. "The main aims of the Land Registration Acts were to give certainty to title ...

    27 Barclays Bank v. Taylor (1974) 1 CH. 28 Mortgage corporation v. Nationwide credit corporation (1993) 4 ALL ER. 29 The so called 'void-ness' rule. 30 S.20 & S.59(6) Land Registration Act 1925. 31 Strand Securities v. Caswell (1965) 2 WLR 958.

  1. Free essay

    heirachy of civil courts

    Theses methods are arbitration, conciliation and mediation. As seen in the diagram below Resolving Civil Disputes Traditional methods Civil administrative Courts tribunals ADR Arbitration, conciliation and mediation Administrative Tribunals Under the tribunals and inquiries acts of 1958, 1971 and 1992, many disputes at the present day are adjudicated upon, legal

  2. Is the UK Parliament still supreme with regards to enacting Acts of Parliament? Discuss.

    In Committee the clauses of the bill are examined individually and detailed amendments are considered. The bill's opponents, seeking to emasculate or destroy it, propose some amendments but many are technical improvements and clarifications proposed by the government itself. When the Committee Stage is complete the bill moves into the

  1. Customer Protection Legislation.

    The resulting organisation is now larger than all its rivals and thus more likely to increase its profitability. However, such large businesses can be contrary to the interests of customers, depriving them of choice and providing a lower standard of service.

  2. Statutory Interpretation

    the task was not illegal even though the Abortion Act 1967 provided that a pregnancy could only be "terminated by a registered medical practitioner", i.e. by a doctor. In Corkery v Carpenter (1951) the court was required to interpret the word "carriage" in s.12 of Licensing Act 1872, and to

  1. Statutory interpretation

    Using the mischief rule and the source I believe the relevant term a judge would have to interpret would be 'for the purpose of prostitution'. Harriet is 'soliciting' the attention of her friend, who is in the 'street' and so using the source would likely be convicted under these two points alone.

  2. The most conventional meaning of the 'legislative supremacy of Parliament' was adopted by Dicey

    It clear that ultimately there are even limits on the supremacy of Parliament which it is the courts in alienable responsibility to identify and uphold. They are limits of the most modest dimensions which I believe any democrat would accept.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work