• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Why do a high proportion of suspects not receive legal advice at the police station?

Extracts from this document...


Why do a high proportion of suspects not receive legal advice at the police station? A considerable number of studies have been conducted at different police stations which has produced information identifying a range of factors which are involved in the result of suspects not receiving legal advice at the police station. Prior to the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984, access to legal advice was overseen by the Judges' Rules, these had no specific power of enforcement, thus allowing the police to employ them arbitrarily. The police did not have to make records of the requests for advice, so how do we know that prior to PACE the proportion of suspects receiving legal advice was low? We can gain an idea from studying the research data in this field.1 Softley's study of four police stations in 1980 shows there was not only a very low proportion of suspects seeking legal advice (9%) but the number receiving even it was even lower (7%). An earlier study by Zanders in 1972 produced different results finding that it was closer to half of all of suspects interviewed requesting access to a lawyer.2 At this time the police did not have to inform the suspects of their rights and it is held that this is the main reason ...read more.


to stop suspects exercising their rights at the police station, thus accounting for a large proportion of cases where detainees do not receive legal advice. There are, however, reason that explain the request rates for legal advice which do not rest entirely on the police's assistance or hindrance. Brown et al.'s study in 1992 suggests that suspects request neither to see nor speak to solicitor 'because they are not informed (wholly or partly) of their rights'.11 If a suspect is not informed of their rights it is acceptable to say most will be ignorant of their entitlement to legal advice. Even if suspects were partly informed the likelihood of the detainee questioning the police to reiterate their rights is low, as 'most will be frightened and apprehensive' being held involuntarily in unfamiliar surroundings.12 This leads on to another influencing factor; suspects being desperate to leave the police station. The thought of delaying their departure to wait for a solicitor to arrive, it seems, plays a major part in the number declining legal advice.13 Sanders et al. found numerous different responses from detainees when an officer asked if they wanted a solicitor, including, 'well it depends how long I'm here for..', which displays how unsure suspects can be feeling at the time of interviewing, they believe that ...read more.


them to intervene or to raise some objection', also their was cases of the solicitor acting almost as a third interviewer.21 Not only this but there are cases where confession is encouraged by solicitors over the phone and in the interview room. Also there are cases when junior members of the legal profession are employed to mete out advice even though their experience is unmatched to that of a police officer.22 These actions of the legal profession are likely to deter suspects from accepting legal advice when they weigh up the cost and benefits. Suspects should be encouraged to contact their own solicitor, should they have one, so they are dealing with a familiar person. In conclusion, it is evident that there are a broad range of reasons why suspects do not receive legal advice at police stations. These range from individual detainee's viewpoints to unlawful police practices. However, it is true that the number of suspects receiving advice has risen considerably since the introduction of PACE, as well as introducing further guidelines to prevent police from 'getting around' the rules, the question that should be posed is, 'Does every suspect actually need advice?'. As long as suspects are making informed decisions there are certainly plenty of cases where advice is not in their best interests. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Machinery of Justice section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Machinery of Justice essays

  1. Woolf Reforms

    are adding on costs right from the beginning to ensure that they don't lose out at a later stage. It is therefore debateable whether costs will ever be successfully reduced, no matter what the reform is. Professor Zander felt that the reforms were fundamentally flawed, rather than prone to temporary

  2. What Impact will Formalising Plea Bargaining have on Justice and Equality in the English ...

    the presumption of innocence, the privilege against self-incrimination, the right to be treated fairly without discrimination and the right to a fair and public hearing. It could be argued that plea bargaining is racially discordant and divisive. This is the argument that the academic Penny Derbyshire proposes.17 In the United

  1. Conditional Fee Arrangements and Legal Aid

    Through these reforms the Government hoped to improve the quality and accessibility of the legal services on offer, while keeping a tighter control on their budget. The Legal Aid Board was abolished and replaced by the Legal Services Commission. In order to develop the standard and accessibility of legal services

  2. Why do young people join gangs and other subcultures? How does a criminal sub ...

    Therefore, the study of subculture often consists of the study of the symbolism attached to clothing, music and other visible affectations by members of the subculture, and also the ways in which these same symbols are interpreted by members of the dominant culture.

  1. To what extent should principles and practices of criminal justice for young offenders be ...

    Taking these two points into consideration it may be best to deal with these offenders in a rehabilitative, rather than an incapacitative (which may have been more suitable if the offender were an adult) manner. If the majority of offenders are only going to ever commit one crime then the

  2. Identify and Critically Discuss Problems Associated With Police Interviews and The Success With Which ...

    This practice is called 'taking the scenic route'. The R.R.C.J. found that 30% of suspects report being questioned unofficially, before being correctly interviewed. However, even though these interviews are improper, evidence gained may still be admissible. Police not only interrogate the suspect out of the police station.

  1. Penal Studies for Professional Practice

    There has been a 173% increase in the number of women imprisoned between 1992 and 2002, compared to an average rise of 50% in the male prison population. In April 2005 it was reported that there were 4,541 women in prison, of which approximately 20% were Foreign Nationals (Home Office 2005).

  2. "Examine why sexual offenders attract so much attention these days. How has the Criminal ...

    A key example being the case of Sidney Cooke, a convicted paedophile who operated a huge paedophile ring, in which they kidnapped, raped and killed children. Sidney Cooke was a known serial sex offender, however he was repeatedly released from prison into the community and once free continued to commit further sexual offences (BBC News, 1999).

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work