• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Haney, Banks and Zimbardo (prison simulation)

Extracts from this document...


Psychology Essay - Sampling Haney, Banks and Zimbardo (prison simulation) i) The method of selecting the sample for the prison simulation study was very extensive - it began very simply, with a newspaper advert offering $15 a day to take part in a psychological study on 'prison life', and progressed from there. 75 potential subjects responded to the ad, and of these, 22 were finally selected to take part in the study. They were made to complete an extensive questionnaire, designed to find out about their family background, physical and mental health history, and their experiences with and attitude towards psychopathological tendencies (including any criminal history). Every respondent was also interviewed by one of the experimenters. The final selection were chosen because they appeared to the experimenters to be the most mature and mentally and physically stable, and the least likely to become involved in antisocial behaviour. Therefore, they were chosen on the basis of their 'normality', to demonstrate the effects that prison life could have on apparently ordinary, non-criminal people. The subjects were described as 22 'normal, healthy male college students', all of who happened to be in the Stanford area during the summer the study was carried out. They were mostly of middle-class socio-economic status, and Caucasian (with the exception of one Oriental man), and prior to the study, they were all strangers. ...read more.


From the beginning, the newspaper ad asked for only male participants, proving it impossible for the sample to become truly representative. It was also only applicable to students in the Stanford area, which erases quite a large portion of the world. It then went on to narrow down the already-limited sample to people who were mature, non-violent, and mentally and physically stable - and in the end, produced an incredibly limited selection of people. iii) There are many problems with sampling in psychological studies, the most evident of which is the almost impossible task of getting a representative sample. No matter how close the sample is to being representative - it could include thousands of people, of all ages, genders, and races - there would undoubtedly be something about it that made it unacceptable as a representative sample. The only way to do it, really, would be to subject every person in the world to the same psychology study - which is essentially impossible, and definitely a waste of time. This problem is made evident in almost every study that we've investigated so far - for example, Loftus and Palmer's study on automobile destruction. In their second experiment, they used a wide range of subjects - a hundred and fifty - with a fairly equal variation of genders. ...read more.


It's possible that it would end up in a small-scale war between the guards and the prisoners, with each group firmly uniting against the other, and the abuse going beyond the level it did with males. Whereas men are more likely to deal with issues like that alone, women are far more likely to group together. It could also result in the guards ignoring the prisoners, and the prisoners socialising with each other. As women are generally more open and talkative than men, I find it much easier to believe that they'd spend their time in the cells talking amongst themselves and discussing their lives outside the study, rather than talking of little else other than the guards' treatment of them, as the men did. This would prove the original hypothesis completely wrong, confirming that it was the people inside the prison who make it a bad place to be, and not the general atmosphere. Finally, the change in sample could result in complete interaction between the prisoners and the guards, splitting off into separate social groups which did not concern the study. As women who are bored tend to start talking as quickly as possible (women at bus stops, or in queues, for example), it would be unsurprising to see that the roles made no difference whatsoever to who interacted with who. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Probability & Statistics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Probability & Statistics essays

  1. Differences in wealth and life expectancy of the countries of the world

    I put the countries and their given data in a graph. In some cases I had to randomly reselect a country as the previously selected country didn't have sufficient data for me to include it in my investigation. Also for Cyprus I had to add both the Greek Cypriot area

  2. Used Cars - What main factor that affects the price of a second hand ...

    0 11499 21 MEDIUM 1700 49260 5 6999 22 MEDIUM 1700 22070 2 5999 23 MEDIUM 1799 36534 5 6999 24 MEDIUM 1800 18620 2 9199 25 MEDIUM 1800 17200 3 9999 26 MEDIUM 1800 49589 4 5499 27 MEDIUM 1800 4940 1 17399 28 MEDIUM 1800 2920 0 14899

  1. A sociology study of male self image

    older sample because of limited time and the fact that delivery and collection had to be done by hand, because of a low response rate he then decided that he would double the amount of questionnaires given in the older sample so that he would retrieve the original amount that he wanted.

  2. "The lengths of lines are easier to guess than angles. Also, that year 11's ...

    5 0.4 8.70 45 12 36.36 5 0.4 8.70 45 12 36.36 5 0.4 8.70 45 12 36.36 3 -1.6 -34.78 40 7 21.21 5 0.4 8.70 46 13 39.39 5 0.4 8.70 30 -3 -9.09 4 -0.6 -13.04 30 -3 -9.09 3.5 -1.1 -23.91 40 7 21.21 4.5 -0.1

  1. Analyse a set of results and investigate the provided hypothesise.

    of line guesses, the anomaly would have a large weighted effect and would make the mean of the results insignificant and unreliable. Revised set of sample data line angle age gender 1 40 30 78 M 2 35 52 12 F 3 50 43 45 F 4 50 45 14

  2. To test if my secondary evidence is correct and therefor to find if adult ...

    HERE FOLLOWES MY GROUPED FREQUENCY DISTRABUTION TABLE FOR EACH SEX AND THE FREQUENCY OF BOTH SEXES ADDED: Pulse Rates Mid Interval Men Frequency Women Frequency Men & Women Frequency Mid-interval � Frequency of MEM Mid-interval � Frequency of WOMEN Mid-interval � Frequency of MEN & WOMEN X F F F

  1. Comparative Newspaper Project

    The way in which I selected each sentence was as follows: E.g. Ran# = 0 . 1 2 3 4 5 Disregarding any number generated that does not work. E.g. 0 . 9 4 3 1 2 page number too high 0 .

  2. find out if there is a connection between people's IQ and their average KS2 ...

    in one go. I found the average easily as all I had to do was highlight the columns I needed in Excel and type in a formula. =AVERAGE(M2:O2) This gave me an average for the first person in my sample, then I dragged the little box down which copied and pasted my formula

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work