• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

308 CMC Popular Music

Extracts from this document...


Richard Adams Take Away Examination March 2005 308 CMC Popular Music Question 3) A process of commercial 'recuperation' always leads to the turning of subcultural signs into mass-produced goods. This process of comodification creates a 'diffusion of the subculture's subversive power' (Hebdige 1979) Discuss this statement with reference to specific examples. Essentially what Hebdige is saying with his statement is that eventually a subcultures generic trademarks will cross over into the mainstream. This will in tern render the original intentions of subversion diluted pastiches of there former representations. The validity of this statement is interesting in two ways. Firstly are subcultures subversive qualities diluted through popularisation? And secondly and perhaps more importantly in terms of more contemporary subcultural representations; how valid is the statement that what might be considered subcultures are actually subversive in terms of attempted displacement of a dominant ideology. It is these two areas with particular reference to the Punk movement of the nineteen seventies which I intend to discuss within this Essay/Exam. Looking at the work of Hebdige himself and other writers and theorists in comparison, and also contrasting areas. Punk is perhaps the most obvious musical form which has been linked to subculture. Even Hebdige himself is of the opinion that music and subcultures are part of the same "expressive circle" (Quoted in Middleton, 1990:165). ...read more.


Therefore it can be argued that what we think of as Punk was in fact not the subcultural movement created from the metaphorical hangover the country suffered after the late sixties and early seventies. But in fact an exploitation of that very state of affairs. If this is so then the commodification of Punk like other forms of music from the 1960's Tin Pan Alley Bands of the sixties to the current incarnation of 'Boy Bands' of the Nineties simply a commodity from the start. If one was to take away the record labels and the clothes labels would we still have 'punk' or just an angry youth? However, Hebdige does not agree that sub-culture are commodified forms mass communication from the moment of there conception. After all how can a subculture's 'subversive power' be 'defused' if it had none in the first place. He had though come to see "subcultural styles as less as expressing a groups material position in society than as intervening in existing processes of signification" (Middleton, 1990:164). Hebdige Also subscribed to the 'Structuralist' view of subcultures. Identifying historical structures to subcultures which in many ways outlines what Polhemus stated about in inevitability of Punk due to the historical circumstances which preceded it. Therefore we can now see exactly what Hebdige meant when he questioned the validity of subcultures subversive qualities after commodification-which Hebdige saw as inevitable. ...read more.


We can now see Skateboarding 'Goths' BMX riding 'Chavs'. The lines within post modernity are becoming increasingly blurred. And although Hebdige's statement is true a certain extent. It is what Foucault would call "A regime of truth" (Quoted in Hall, 1997:49) It can never be completely true as there are too many individual, self orientated discourses both hidden and on display within post modern western society. 'diffusion of subversion' via 'commodification' is also not necessarily answering the question as to why certain we do not consider acts to be as subversive as previous generations. Another reason for this stems from the point Storey made regarding the speeding up of 'fashion cycle' by the mass media been lost due to our post-modern individualism, our desire for consumption and gratification? Jameson has highlighted in his writing that "it must be stressed that it's (postmodernism's) own offensive features no longer scandalise anyone and are not only received with the greatest of complacency but have themselves become institutionalised" (Jameson, 1991:56). Jameson therefore seems to suggest that although subversion is still possible. To achieve it on such a large scale as say Punk did; as a movement against a social norm incorporating large numbers of distinct members is now impossible. This in tern renders Hebdige's comments relevant only in terms of history. More recent movements such as 'Girl Power' or Grunge where either to superficial or self referential respectively to be considered subcultures adequate enough for idealistic subversion. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Music section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Music essays

  1. Lady Gaga and Post-Modernism

    Post-Modernism in 'Alejandro' Lady Gaga imitates Madonna's 'Like a Prayer' Lady Gaga's 'Alejandro' video begins with soldiers sleeping in a cabaret with a close-up of a soldier passed out in fishnet stockings and heels as another lone soldier stares into the distance.

  2. The subject of this dissertation is how feminist beliefs have been expressed in alternative ...

    Their reviews influence record companies by alerting them to possible new signings and showing which bands to promote. In most music magazines, the female journalist is in a minority and is often given the more lightweight articles. This trend is particularly evident in the 'serious' monthly music press in the

  1. What I am going to find out-1. ~ Does age ...

    and divided it by how many there were (6) So, 23/6 = 3.83 (their average modernity). I then did this with each adult in groups according to the ages of their children, for calculations see Appendix 1. Modernity for all age groups: No children - 6.82 Aged 0-5 - 8.25 Aged 6-10 - 7.50 Aged 11-15 - 7.21 Aged

  2. Youth Sub-Cultures, Popular Music and Social Change

    in the early 1950s, especially with the release of Rock Around the Clock, a feature film resulted in unruly behaviour in cinemas all over US and Britain, and even more extreme reactions across Europe. Young audiences danced in the aisles and ripped out seats when the movie was screening.

  1. Intertextuality is a technique, when one text refers to another text or uses its ...

    The video starts with a young girl watching TV then an image of Pink appears as an angel at the young girl's right side flowing by a devil Pink on the left hand side of the girl. The devil says to the girl to watch TV channels which influence girls

  2. music production work

    It would have been better to add more detail to the inlay of the album as we only mentioned briefly who the artist wished to thank, who produced it and where it was recorded. The function of music videos is to promote music made by bands of all genres.

  1. How helpful the concept of counter-culture is in understanding the changes that took place ...

    Some changes did not come through opposition or confrontation. As the decade wore on material changes to peoples lives increased in many places, such as Italy, to bring greater comfort and the introduction in some areas of electricity and lavatories for the first time.

  2. An Analysis of the Influence of Music and it's Contrasting Message on the Youth ...

    Compared to Ms Dynamite's video, 50 Cent gives the audience a false impression because Ms Dynamite expresses the true reality of the gangster lifestyle through her opening scenes The core of both videos is where the biggest influences are established.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work