• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Broadsheet and Tabloid artical comparison.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

English Media Coursework By Josephine Opoku The incident that all three papers are discussing is a cable car accident in Italy in which 20 people died. This tragedy occurred on 3rd February 1998 as a low American fighter jet severed the wire on which the car hung. This caused the cable car to crash down 300ft leaving another cable car in suspension. This event happened nearby Mount Cermis, Northern Italy. The Mirror takes it account from all spectrums but focuses on British tourists in the area. The Times do not mention their eyewitnesses but focus on the American and Italian view on the subject. The Newsweek discuss mainly with American officials but they do feature any eyewitnesses. The major differences is that the Mirror is a daily tabloid, the Times a daily broadsheet and the Newsweek is a fortnightly American publication. The Mirror and The Times reported on the incident the next day, whilst Newsweek reported on it thirteen days after. The Newsweek will obviously be bias as its country is involved in the accident and the other two papers should share the same views as they are not involved. Due to the Times being a broadsheet it should have a more sophisticated language and its attitude should follow this. The Mirror has a lot of factual information on the accident. It states the number of deaths (20 skiers). ...read more.

Middle

The Mirror included these British tourists to give the report a personal aspect, this may gain interest from readers who would be attracted to the article as it brings the incident to the British shores that there own were involved. They also discussed the incident with a police chief Andrea Russo who described the scene saying 'all four wall of the car opened up like a cardboard box ' and tells of the severed bodies and the bloodstained snow. This shows what the scene looked like after the incident. They talked to a fire services spokesman to confirm the number of deaths and the US Defence Secretary William Cohen who gives the official American statement and view on the disaster. They also get an official statement from the Italian Regional President Carlo Andreotti who condemns the Americans. He was interviewed to give an impression of the Italians view on the accident. Cristina Antoniazzi a hotel owner nearby, she discusses what she heard at the time of the accident. This gives a view of a normal resident in the area and their view on the deaths, free from all the spin and censorship a government statement may have. The Times does not offer any statements from British officials or those on the scene. They do not care for their opinion as they are not involved and do not need their view on the matter. ...read more.

Conclusion

Also the picture of the plane is helps the reader envision the power it holds and with the force it may of hit the wire. The Times also gives more information on the area including a past accident and some history about the area. The Mirror uses its sensationalism to exaggerate the event by highlighting the word 'under' in bold this is used to blame the Americans for deliberately flying low and by using the word 'innocent' to describe the tourists who took the consequences for the careless Americans. The Times is also bias but it is not as blatant as in The Mirror, it says the plane had been flying 'very, very low' and that it was attempting to pull itself up when it hit the cable. This shows that thy are slightly bias as they seem to be defending the Americans in a very subtle way. An eyewitness also says and it also mentions that a US pilot said it had a 'bad jolt'. The Newsweek has a cynical view on the event and there involvement. This is two weeks after the event which shows that they do not care about the accident they attempt to put the blame on the Italians as they did not defend the Dolomites the week of the accident. They also try to say that both the U.S and the Italians have been 'hot-dogging' through the cables. Due to it being an American paper they were more concerned with the safety of the pilots then those dead or injured. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Newspapers & Magazines section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Newspapers & Magazines essays

  1. Broadsheet and tabloid comparison.

    This article in The Express is the only article on the page, with the exception of two advertisements. This ensures the reader is not distracted by another story. In The Times, there are several other articles and advertisements to take the reader´s attention away from the main headline.

  2. Comparing Broadsheet and Tabloid Reports.

    an instruction: "FIND MAN WHO TOOK SARAH" The use of capitals in a headline is common and the missing 'THE' between 'FIND' and 'MAN' makes the headline seem like an order to do something. In contrast to the layout of 'The Sun', 'The Times' puts this story on page three

  1. Analysis of Tabloid and Broadsheet newspapers in the British marketplace.

    personality or position in society Politician's comments often included, with a commentary by the journalist Geoffrey Boycott: Kevin O'Brien was a hero for Ireland, but England's bowling was awful How the mighty have fallen so quickly. England were national heroes after winning the Ashes - national chumps after this embarrassing defeat by Ireland.

  2. 'Disaster in the Alps' - comparing and analysing how the Times, Mirror and American ...

    There is also surplus information given in the Times, which we don't see elsewhere, the information on "Stradivarius Violins", which is hardly necessary and really superfluous. The final article Newsweek seeks to uphold American notions on the incident, and is fairly sparse with giving facts about the plane or those

  1. Write about a tragic incident that had happened in Docklands, on 9th February 1996, ...

    "Fighting for life" means struggling for life and struggling gives a sense of depression. "Lost limbs" is horrifying because living with out limbs limits your life; therefore there are nothing to live for. The Sun describes their feeling towards the IRA as "horrific" and "Terror chief".

  2. Broad sheet and Tabloid - On 3 February 1998 in the Italian Alps, a ...

    Other than that it has a few extra details such as classing the jet as a Prowler and emphasising that the incident happened at 3.25pm. It also has information about what the plane is used for and what special attributes it has, 'The Prowler is used to jam enemy signals electronically'.

  1. Comparing News Reports - On the day of 3rd February 1998, a Marine Corps ...

    at, and that if it were to happen in the morning, that the car would have been packed with around 40 people, as it would have been peek time: "If it had happened in the morning, the car would had been packed and the death toll would have been even higher."

  2. To compare the way three news publications, The Times, The Mirror and Newsweek, an ...

    The Mirror talks about the "huge metal hook weighing several tons", which smashed down through the roof of the car. Newsweek devotes very little of its article to the reporting of the accident itself. There may be two reasons for this.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work