• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare the persuasive techniques used in the two charity fundraising advertisements. Which advertisement do you think is more effective and why?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Assignment. Friday, 05th,November,2004 Compare the persuasive techniques used in the two charity fundraising advertisements. Which advertisement do you think is more effective and why? The hardest thing for any charity is to raise money. There is only one way to do this, that is to persuade people to part with their money and donate it to a good cause. The " Bhopal Medical Appeal" and "Save The Children" advertisements are two examples of this. Both of these advertisements come from " The Observer" a broadsheet newspaper. Consequently it is assumed that the target audience is those of a higher education and people who more likely to actually read the advertisement. In both of the advertisements they use very different persuasive techniques. It is easy to see how the two advertisements, both need and want the same thing: the readers' help. However, in many various ways, it is clear that the "Save The Children" advertisement and the "Bhopal Medical Appeal" advertisement have distinct ways of reaching out for the readers attention and support. First of all " Just 10p a day" is used throughout the 'Save The Children' advertisement. This sticks in the reader's mind and makes them remember the words "Just 10p a day", then makes the reader think what their "10p a day" could do to help save children's lives. ...read more.

Middle

A remarkable persuasive media technique is the use of the pronoun "you". It immediately makes the reader feel involved, as it seems as if the advertisement was directed at them, therefore, making it appear to be much more personal. Both advertisements use this; in the "Save The Children" advertisement it asks "Will you give 10p a day?" and in the "Bhopal" advertisement it states: "We don't ask 'you' to help 'us' to help 'them'. 'We' is all of us together" The "Save The Children" advertisement uses this technique much more successfully as it is short and gets straight to the point. Related to this technique is the use of the present tense. "will you give just 10p a day. Now?" The use of the word "now" in the present tense, urges the reader to do something that instant. Making them think that people need their help right now. In the "Save The Children" advertisement the present tense is also used; "please will you help us save more children form poverty by completing the direct debit form attached to this letter today?". Therefore "today" and "now" show the use of the present tense. It is also used in the "Bhopal medical appeal" advertisement, "free phone 0800 316 557 now." Again "now" is the use of the present tense. ...read more.

Conclusion

In conclusion, both advertisements used some similar techniques of persuasive media and some completely different techniques of persuasion. They are both appealing for your sympathy and help. However, the 'Save The Children' advertisement is much more effective in comparison to the 'Bhopal Medical Appeal'advertisement, because it uses a number of various techniques, such as: rhetorical questions, use of the pronoun 'you' to involve the reader, and finally strong emotive words. Another point could be that the 'Bhopal Medical Appeal' advertisement had a long story; the problem with this is although you want to make your point, people are less likely to read a story that may be touching, only to find that the advertisement wants their money. On the other hand the 'Save The Children' advertisement does have some long written text in parts. The advertisement, however, is straight to the point, it immediately informs the reader of what they would like, letting the reader know what to expect, therefore the reader knows that if they continue to read their help will be needed. The 'Save The Children' advertisement uses media features much more successfully than 'Bhopal Medical Appeal.' Emotive images are used showing numerous close ups of children's faces. 'Save The Children' itself suggests that the children are in danger and that your contribution can help. Therefore, the 'Save The Children' advertisement is more effective. Kirsty Nichol - 10A ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Advertisements section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Advertisements essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Discuss techniques used in charity advertising with specific reference to particular examples and case ...

    4 star(s)

    rain and wind which is the way the young girl is feeling. In this advert, they have also used a rubbish motif to symbolise the rubbish in her life. As print-based advertisements are, moving image advertisements are also emotive, persuasive and controversial.

  2. Analyze and compare two print advertisements for similar products. Examine their methods of persuasion ...

    However, the language used in the text is dramatic and the messages are oblique, but once understood, the reader would be convinced that the mobile has these three factors: Fashion, boldness and highest technology. We are persuaded that if you have this particular mobile phone then you will become as glamorous as this phone.

  1. Compare and Contrast the Oxfam 'Cut Conflict' Advertisement and the CCF Advertisement.

    writing since the reader is once again asked to focus their attention on the image of the girl. However we can not look this girl in the eye because of the injury caused to it, this type of writing is called a pun, it has a double meaning.

  2. The first part is to compare and evaluate two competitor organisations strategies of their ...

    16 sheet billboard This advertising shows 96 and 48 sheet posters Poster Printers DIGITAL and SCREEN PRINTED LARGE FORMAT POSTERS For local, regional and national advertising campaigns sited on billboards and hoardings outdoors. Any size of poster Up to 12 x 3 metres.

  1. Analysis of the Guinness TV Advertisement Tipping Point

    curiously looking out his window as if it was an everyday occurrence. For this shot the music dies down but quick builds up again as we move to the next shot increasing the tension. We are now shown shots of people excitedly running through the streets, showing us the excitement

  2. Analysing TV Advertising - The Guinness surfers advertisement and the Levis Odyssey Advertisement, directed ...

    clothing will have the same effect on you, even though this is often not the case. This age group of people, usually at school or university, will have a lot of responsibilities and restrictions, such as exams and school, and will not yet be old enough to have utter expressive freedom, a matter which can frustrate a lot them.

  1. Marketing Media and Audience Feedback

    All managers must make decisions using the data of market analysis and understand how it was derived, but not all managers are asked to conduct this. However, an understanding of the tools most used for analysing markets and making sales forecasts is needed by all managers due to the fact

  2. Exploring Printed Media Texts I have selected two advertisements printed on paper to compare ...

    of the reader; the way the information is presented makes compelling reading appealing to readers with a social conscience. The layout and organisation of the one page advertisement is visually complex, and deliberately so, because the intention of the presentation technique is attention grabbing.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work