• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing Coverage in 'The Independent’ with ‘The Mirror’

Extracts from this document...


Media Study English Coursework This analysis contrasts and compares a broadsheet and a tabloid newspaper. I chose to compare 'The Independent' with 'The Mirror'. The analysis involves a general comparison, and also a more detailed evaluation of one news item that appears in both papers. If we examine the front cover of each paper to begin with, we notice that there are differences. The title of 'The Mirror' is around 1/10th of the page, whilst 'The Independent' title is approximately 1/16th. The font used for 'The Mirror' is relatively modern in appearance, using sentence case with black outline and white fill. In comparison, the font for 'The Independent' is more traditional, using black bold capital letters. The title also contains the logo on the left hand side. The price for 'The Mirror' is 32p and this is presented in bold text at the bottom right hand corner of the title. The price for 'The Independent' is also found in this location, however the text used is extremely small and the cost for this paper is 50p. The difference in price could suggest that each paper is aimed at a specific audience. This suggests that a paper like 'The Independent' maybe targeting a more professional consumer, in a higher pay band. ...read more.


A whole range of entertainment features can be found in 'The Mirror'. These include cartoons, quizzes and word search. Additionally, the paper has adverts on almost every page, and there are many photographs including glamorous and fun photographs. A whole page is dedicated to horoscopes and the paper offers 9 sports pages. The paper provides very few articles on serious current events, and concentrates more on gossip type news. The content of 'The Independent' is very different. The paper comprises news and discussion of world events, along with a range of articles that focus on such things as 'education', 'the environment', 'politics' and 'economics'. There is a lot of business information such as 'stocks and shares', 'exchange rates' and 'interest rates'. In contrast to 'The Mirror', there are only 5 sports pages, and there is only one crossword, found in one of the supplements rather than the main paper. The target audience for 'The Mirror' is working class, and people who are not interested in 'intellectual' debate. This contrasts with 'The Independent' as this broadsheet paper clearly aims to attract readers from a higher social class including people from the business and academic world. Apart from the content as previously discussed, there are several other points, which clearly show that the papers are aiming to attract different types of readers. ...read more.


Another difference can be seen in the descriptive language used by the papers. 'The Mirror' describes the take off using an analogy associated with thrill rides 'Take off is like something on an Alton Towers ride'. 'The Independent' uses much more creative style 'it is just so aesthetically pleasing, such direction and poise'. 'The Mirror' also describes New York in terms that aim to shock, and uses emotive language to do this ' anthrax-ravaged, terrorist torn New York', whereas 'The Independent' focus's more on such emotions as 'patriotism'. Another example of the more down to earth colloquial terms used by 'The Mirror' is where the writer discusses safety, and this is presented as 'I was frisked more thoroughly than I have ever been frisked before', the message being driven home by using the word 'frisked' twice. 'The Independent' talks more in terms of 'safety checks' and 'the grim reality of terrorism', rather than using the more tactile description used in 'The Mirror'. In conclusion, the two papers contrast significantly. Whilst to some extent they cover the same main stories, the presentation, the language, the descriptions and the way in which the stories are told use totally contrasting techniques and styles. This aims to suit the audiences for which the papers are written. Richard Hiom 01/05/07 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Newspapers & Magazines section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Newspapers & Magazines essays

  1. Two media pieces - 1) The Factsheet from the NCDL 2) The article from ...

    cages on their own and that the bitches are either killed or thrown out when they become infertile. She writes in this forceful way, to make the reader feel more hatred towards the farmers because she herself does not like the fact that puppies and bitches are being treated in this way.

  2. An analysis comparing the front pages of the Sun and the Mirror, considering the ...

    of Jonny Wilkinson from a slightly different angle and then the headline: "your troops did not die in vain". This headline is also underlined which connotes a sense of importance. The masthead of the Sun is rather plain, containing only the basic facts of price, name, website and date.

  1. Magazine Evaluation

    If I had to redo the advert I would add more colour to it to make it stand out as well as to look more attractive. Also I would add different cars manufacturers models in the advert to not give the advert a connotation of being only for VW cars.

  2. Compare and contrast the treatment of the killings at DunblanePrimary school by The Sun ...

    The papers reasonably take advantage of this knowledge in order to sell more papers, however I do not think they exploit the situation. Nevertheless the western culture has the taste of reading and watching terrible things happen because it is their way of life, things like soap operas encourage this through their high popularity.

  1. Compare the article in the Independent with the article in the Daily Mail, addressing ...

    No colour is used but the picture is large and the text surrounds it on four sides, but it is still very effective. The main headline is long but not very bold it is very level headed. It is larger than the main article but does not stand out a

  2. Taking the image of people jumping from the Twin Towers as your starting point, ...

    Bullet points are used as a way of representing factual evidence and information and added to 'Thousands die' and 'Bush vows to defend freedom from cowards' 'The Times' would have subsequently managed to render the scale of the matter to its readers.

  1. Compare an article in the Independent with the article in the Daily Mail, addressing ...

    The sub-headings, the by-line and what inside page to turn to for the main story are all in bolder larger fonts than the actual stories text. This is because most readers read the headings and sub-headings before actually buying the newspaper to see if the article is interesting therefore they are also main selling points of the newspaper.

  2. Analyse The Scoreand Drugs the Factslooking at how genres have been used and subverted ...

    This may be so that the demographic group of eleven to fourteen year olds feel they can relate to it, and continue to read it assuming they will be entertained. The front cover could persuasively prevent them from taking drugs by subconsciously reminding them of prisons, using images that resemble

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work