• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing coverage in two different Newspapers

Extracts from this document...


Comparing coverage in two different Newspapers The incident covered in the two articles I have studied was a train fire in the Austrian ski resort of Kaprun on Saturday 11th November 2000. The first article I looked at was in the tabloid paper the Sunday Express. The second article I looked at was in the broadsheet paper the Observer. The two articles were very similar but had some differences. Both the articles emphasised that British people were among those that had died. The Sunday Express said "Britons among 170 victims" and The Observer said "Britons among 170 dead" The Observer also stated that children died "Children among victims" Although both articles covered the same subject and seemed to emphasise the greatness of the tragedy, they had different approaches, The Sunday Express' article was sensationalist and over emotive "... inferno as it tore through carriages" The Observers article was a calmer and more concise report "... and, within a few minutes, almost everyone on board was dead." The articles both contained similar factual information. In the Article in the Sunday Express, facts were intertwined with opinions and emotive language. "... engulfing tourists in temperatures of up to 1,000 degrees Centigrade." ...read more.


We can presume that everyone still on board the train is dead."" They were commenting on their feelings about the incident. Klaus Eisenkolb, a cable car technician who worked on the planning of the line was also interviewed and spoke of what he thought about the occurrence of this incident and what could have possibly caused it. One witness and one survivor were also quoted. The Observer had fewer people interviewed, but had interviews with relatives and witnesses. They also had a statement from the company who owned the train, Gletscherbahn Kaprun, who commented on their feelings about this incident. "In a statement, the company said: 'We and the whole town of Kaprun are in mourning.'" An unidentified man whose son had gone skiing that day, and a deacon were also interviewed. This gave the article a more personal feel, as the reader felt that they could relate to the people who's lives had been affected by this and so understand the tragedy better. The layout of these reports was very different. Article I had a large bold headline on the front cover saying "INFERNO" in capital letters, to draw people's attention. ...read more.


I think because the facts were not clouded with opinions, they were easier to understand. I thought that the double page spread was particularly effective. The pictures were clearer and attracted the reader's attention. The diagram on the double page was very clear and easy to understand. It showed exactly what happened in stages, with information about the mountain and the tunnel. I also thought that the headline "Inferno in the Alps" on the front page was really effective. It gave enough information for you to know what had happened but was short enough for the reader to read at a glance. I felt that The Sunday Express' article was more difficult to understand as there were fewer facts and the writing was very opinionated. Also because there were fewer interviews with people who were directly affected by the incident, such as survivors, and relatives of victims, it wasn't as easy to relate to that article. There was less text in general, as much of the space was taken up by large illustrations and headlines. Although the articles seemed to be similar they had differences which although may not be drastically apparent I felt they made a big difference to the effectiveness and success of the articles. Ingrid Bolton ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Newspapers & Magazines section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Newspapers & Magazines essays

  1. In this essay I will be comparing two articles taken from local newspapers in ...

    The people who put together the articles must make sure that everything they include in the interviews is relevant and that they are not too long. I think that the article that uses interviews and quotes better is probably Inches from tragedy, because all the information given is relevant to and informative about what happened.

  2. Comparing two articles from newspapers - Both the articles are about the same story ...

    When The Sun says '...made cop kick his own god to death' it uses 'made' to incriminate the trainers, it makes it sound like the policemen didn't have a choice and that the whole incident was the trainers fault. Whereas The Telegraph uses 'told', this is much more informative and

  1. Comparing two articles from different newspapers.

    It says; 'Police 'told to kick and punch dogs'', although it does uses words such as 'kick' and 'punch' it uses them in a way to inform what the police had been told to do and doesn't go into detail about what the trainer was like.

  2. Looking at and comparing how two different newspapers report the same story.

    Inside the paper there are also two very effective pictures aside the inside headline. On one side of the headline there is a cricket bat whereas on the other side there is a picture of him with a gun. These two pictures are designed to create a comparison between cricket

  1. Successful reading may be achieved by balancing approaches: bottom-up and top-down.

    Readers need to decode text and they must be given the knowledge to do so. (http://www.coreknoledge.org/ckproto2/about/nwsltr/phonicsNwsltr.htm [4.11.99]) Clear drawbacks in the perspective of the top-down proponents are being exposed, the comparison between learning to speak and learning to read in my opinion is unconvincing.

  2. The two articles we have looked at for analysis have a common theme - ...

    This point is reflected earlier on in Doctor Bishop's interview. The readers are more likely to believe something if it has been repeated by two different persons. Industries are often deemed to be moneymaking businesses out to exploit the hard-earned money of the populace.

  1. Comparison of two texts on the Shetland oil disaster.

    The residents reported throat and eye irritations, headaches and nausea. This adds to the urgency of the situation. Concerns were so serious that evacuating the area was even considered as an option. This tells us just how bad the disaster was.

  2. Comparing news reports - 'Disaster in the Alps'

    All three of these interviews were supplied using direct speech. In contrast, the interview in Newsweek was given using reported speech- Italy's Air Force chief, Mario Arpino, said that the Prowler was "four miles off course" and was also flying "3,300 feet below the altitude designated in the flight plan."

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work