• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing the Works of Luhrmann and Zeffirelli.

Extracts from this document...


Comparing the Works of Luhrmann and Zeffirelli These two films, both interpreting the same play, but portrayed very differently. When comparing the two we have to take into consideration that the time these films were made. Zeffirreli's version was made in 1968, and supposedly set in the 16th century. This version is based mostly on the script and is set in the time Shakespeare would have pictured as he wrote the play. The more recent one, directed by Baz Luhrmann is set in the world of today. In this version Luhrmann relies more on the visual impact on the viewer and the special effects. He is able to achieve this because of the huge budget that films have nowadays. In my opinion he was able to make a film, based on the works of Shakespeare and make it appeal to a wider audience than Zeffirelli. The older version seems more theatrical, meaning that it focuses on only a few main themes. For example, the scene where a Capulet trips up an old Montague man. It uses very basic visual effects for this, but by doing this it is made into a very melodramatic scene. It also keeps in most of the script and is based around it. ...read more.


and then it introduces the characters. It uses the same font throughout the opening scene, which is very effective considering it is in very bold, white letters. When I realised this, it meant that they used the same font for both families suggesting that they are both the same, both wanting the same things. It also focuses a lot on the two names. This occurs when the camera zooms in on the crests of both families' guns, the number plates on each car and the names in huge neon lights on the two highest buildings in 'Verona'. What struck me the most when comparing the two films is how the music affects the opening scene. The music in the Luhrmann version is a huge, thunderous orchestral soundtrack. This is a perfect background to many huge, quick, sweeping camera shots, as it draws our attention to the vastness of the city. I would say it was a 'gothic' soundtrack, because the music has a great texture and it emphasizes the 'colours' of the city. We see a lot of greys, blues and blacks of the city. I also thought that the music enforces intense emotion, which sets the viewer up for the rest of the film. I found that it set a sense of suspense. ...read more.


both are in smart, expensive, very different clothes and the both stand out in the crowd. They both walk and talk in the same sly, powerful, confident manner. Out of all the Capulet boys, Tybalt would definitely be the first to catch your eye. If you compared the Montague boys to the Capulet boys, in both films, the Montague's are a lot scruffier, relaxed in their clothing, they look and act quite weedy, in a way. Both openings have their own positive strengths and weakness, in different ways. The traditional opening is more accurate as it portrays how the author would have seen the story unfolding in 1595, and the language used is accurate for that period. The downside of this is that it is likely to only appeal to scholars of Shakespeare and purists. The modern version however, appeals to a wider audience. Although not based accurately upon the script and entered into a modern context, which the author could not have imagined at the time and in no way intended, it is likely to appeal to a far greater audience who perhaps were not readers of Shakespeare and wouldn't have understood the older version. Helped by stars such as Leonardo Di Caprio the film opens up a whole new appeal to what was considered an old fashioned and to some, uninteresting story. Laura Bentley ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Music section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Music essays

  1. analyse of title credit sequence of Fresh Prince of Bel-Air

    Also, teenagers nowadays use secret language so they like it. Camera Angles Now, I will talk about the camera angles and how do the camera angles develop the images meaning. There are five types of camera angles they are Point of view Shot, Tracking Shot, Zoom, Long shot and Mid/Half Shot.

  2. The subject of this dissertation is how feminist beliefs have been expressed in alternative ...

    3.2.2 Effect of Feminism in Alt Music Upon The Identity of the Female Consumer In looking at how alternative music has helped women define their own identity one thing was stressed by many participants - that the groups they listen to had helped to define their identity but that this identity was as an individual not as a female.

  1. Reading about a sequence of scenes from 'Signs'

    is used on the non digetic volume of the music as it get quieter focusing on the diegetic sounds of the aliens trying to get in. Morgan then scouts the basement with the torch and we can see lots of family possessions that symbolise the family, including the mother like

  2. Music In Context

    Roni sizes track does not involve lyrics. The key that all three tunes are played in are almost the same they are highly pitched with the drums being heard clearly this is because the drums were probably "micd" up the same to give the same sort of feel the tunes.

  1. Alfred Hitchcock has been called 'the Master of Suspense', considering 'psycho' state how effectively ...

    a state of tension or anticipation, building up to the point were the murder is commited and then giving the audience a kind of release. The music plays a big part in creating suspense. The music used in Psycho is very sinister, high pitched and high tempo.

  2. Identify and compare the main codes and conventions of two television documentaries and explain what ...

    Our first impressions of him are not good. He is wearing black clothes and is covered in piercings and tattoos and his hairstyle is completely out of the ordinary. The music used to introduce him is heavy metal this immediately gives us the impression he is a ruffian and time waster.

  1. Compare And Contrast The Opening Scene In 'Raiders Of The Lost Ark' And 'Tomorrow ...

    Then the picture disappears into the corner of the screen and reappears at the terrorist bazaar. The director uses wide screen. There is a point of view shot from a high-tech camera zooming in on the terrorists and then that shot appears at M.I.6 on a huge screen.

  2. Analysing and comparing 2pac- 'letter to my unborn child' and Nas featuring R.Kelly -'Did ...

    hits, Did you ever think that you would be the don, Have a crib with a fifty acre lawn'. This is the second stanza and all the words rhyme with the beat. This song is representing someone because the singer is referring to a person when he says 'Did you

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work