ICT Solutions for individuals and society

Authors Avatar
ICT Solutions for Individuals and Society

For this unit I am going to try and find the answer to the enquiry titled "Has increased TV coverage affected the attendance of live sports events" As I have more of a interest in this than I do in the other possible questions. To do this I am going to use a variety of online and local sources.

Task A

In this task I have to search through search engine for information, which will help me, answer the above query. I will use three different search engines to help me do this, which are as follows: www.google.com, www.ask.com & www.lycos.com. I am using three different ones to broaden my range of answers so I can have more information when I come to sum up all the data at the end. I will also use three different types of searches which are: simple, phrase and logical operators. To do this I am going to have to find information on attendances for different sports, as well as the viewing figures over the past few years for the same sports. A lot of the hits which are produced will not be relevant as most of the searches will produce thousands if not millions of responses, and only ten of them might be relevant. After I have looked at all three search engines I will decide which one produced the bets hits, which I will then use for the rest of the unit.

Simple Search - Google

The first hit that I got was the one linking me to the wikipedia, which turned out to be a very useful site. As the first was so good it, made me think that the rest of the results would have the same amount of relevance. The wikipedia page is shown as below. There are too many hits to search through them all, so I just searched through a select few from the first page.

All this website shows is the average attendance for the top 23 teams in Europe, this is not as useful as I first hoped as I have not got anything to compare it to. I can still possibly use this to compare the average attendance of other sports teams.

This is another website I have found from the Google search, this one however bears no relevance to my search, and is also the data is out of date by quite a while. I can tell how old this data is by the fact that Wimbledon changed their name to MK Dons back in 2002 so this just shows how old and unreliable some of my results can be.

Simple Search - Yahoo

I now need something to compare the results to so I will conduct the same search with Yahoo.

Again the same website from wikipedia has appeared on Yahoo also as well as Google, so I will not show that page seeing as I have already showed it on the previous page. Again there is way too many results to search them all so I looked at the more relevant ones from the first few pages, but to no avail seeing as I could only find the one site that was relevant being the wikipedia one. Although there are less results than Google a lot of the sites have appeared on both.

Simple Search - Lycos

Again to get the most information possible I am now going to search another website using the same criteria as the previous two searches.

As you can see I encountered many results using the Lycos website, which is too many to go through, also the Google search came up with about ten times that amount which is just too many so I am guessing many of them will be irrelevant.

Yahoo found the least results and none of first ten results were relevant as well, which is surprising considering it looked through the most pages. The same result came up on each search engine, which is helpful, but there were also many irrelevant pages about the NFL etc. Overall I have not found many results as the criteria I searched for was too general and most of the hits will not help with the enquiry, this could be changed by using a phrase search.

Phrase Search

As there were too many hits in the simple search, I have decided to whittle it down by using a phrase search. A phrase search narrows down the results by quite a bit as it basically searches for that specific phrase. This should give me more relevant results... but might not give me all the information needed for this enquiry.

Google - Phrase Search

Yahoo - Phrase Search

Lycos - Phrase Search

The phrase search has narrowed down my results by quite a bit as you can see, so it should of left me with more relevant hits than the simple search. This time Google has given me the best results and the most hits, and as usual dog pile is coming up with random results that do not mean anything to me. So the chances are that I will not be using this site when it comes to finding out more information. To try and get even more relevant information I am going to perform an advanced search.

Advanced Search

The advanced search will hopefully give me information, which is perfect for what I am looking for. Advanced searches use words like and, or & not, and searches for the web for the two or more words on the same page, or searches for either of the words and not searches for websites which do not contain that word. For this, I will use the same search engines as before. To do this I am going to have to use the link saying advanced settings. From this I am looking for exactly the information that I need.

Google - Advanced Search

This will produce all articles with the words viewing or figures, the phrase sport attendances and without the word American. From this I should get very precise results.

Results

There were very few relevant results given which shows I will have to tweak it to find the information I need, it has also unsurprisingly produced many results, as it is very specific and perhaps too specific.

Yahoo - Advanced Search

Results

I have just realised that Lycos does not contain a advanced search feature, but I can still perform a logical operator search using my previous knowledge by using AND, OR and - - round a word to not include that word in the search

Results

Good website to use later on in my analysis.

Turns out the website is not as good as I had first anticipated.

These advanced searches gave me less results than the previous simple and phrase searches, however a lot of relevant results have came up which are handy to use later on in this unit.

This is because I have taken words out of the search which is good because I no longer get results containing American football results, as the websites I've used being American. Yahoo gave the best results but along with that gave me too many hits so I will not be able to go through them all. Google came up with a few decent hits as well as having a low amount of hits, so I can scan through them all. Lycos has disappointed me when I thought it would be the best, but again there is not too many relevant results.

Logical Operators

Logical operators refine the search to the most it can, as they pinpoint the exact data that I need, hopefully. I am looking for websites, which contain both TV viewing figures and attendances. By doing this I am hoping to find more relevant results and I will be doing this by using NOT & AND.

Google - NOT Search

This has given me a lot of good results from this search, but I am still going to go ahead and search through other sites so I can get a broad variety of information.

Google -AND Search

Even though the search did not work properly due to the and already being including it has still cam up with a few results, which I needed.

Yahoo - NOT

Even though I have used the same search criteria as the Google search I have came up with different results many of which being irrelevant or unusable.

Yahoo - AND

Like Google Yahoo already adds in AND between each of the search criteria, so this is not needed for this search, there are not many relevant results to go with that either.

Search Engine

Searching Criteria

Number of Hits Produced

www.google.co.uk

Sport Attendances

6,280,000

www.yahoo.com

Sport Attendances

39,000

www.lycos.com

Sport Attendances

5,750,000

www.google.co.uk

"TV Viewing Figures"

0,200

www.yahoo.com

"TV Viewing Figures"

2,470

www.lycos.com

"TV Viewing Figures"

,880

www.google.co.uk

Viewing OR Figures "Sports Attendances"

-American

6
Join now!

www.yahoo.com

Sport Attendance Average "Viewing Figures"

71

www.lycos.com

Sport Attendances -American- "TV Viewing Figures"

45

www.google.co.uk

Sport Viewing Figures -Attendance

2,380,000

www.google.co.uk

Sport Attendance AND TV Viewing Figures

427,000

www.yahoo.com

Sport Viewing Figures -Attendance

2,290,000

www.yahoo.com

Sport Attendance AND TV Viewing Figures

203,000

www.lycos.com

Sport Viewing Figures and not Attendance

72

As the table above shows Google gave me the most hits from the criteria I searched. In the phrase and advanced search Yahoo and Lycos did not ...

This is a preview of the whole essay