• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In this essay I am going to compare and contrast the treatment of the James Bulger story in two different newspapers. The newspapers are, one being a broadsheet (the guardian) and the other being a tabloid (the sun).

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare and contrast the treatment of the James Bulger story in a tabloid and a broadsheet In this essay I am going to compare and contrast the treatment of the James Bulger story in two different newspapers. The newspapers are, one being a broadsheet (the guardian) and the other being a tabloid (the sun). Before I look at the articles I already think that the guardian would be written in more depth and have more facts in it, compared to the sun article, which may have a lot of opinions mixed in with facts and just mainly get you to agree with what they are saying. The reason I think this is because, from newspapers I have read in the past. The first thing that one notices about any news story is the use of headlines and sub-headings. The headlines in the two articles I am looking at are: In the broadsheet: Justice on trial: vigilante fears overshadow parole hearings for killers of James Bulger. In the tabloid: Final Insult. In the tabloid the headline is really big and eye catching. Its language is quite informal and really makes you want to know exactly what has been such an insult. ...read more.

Middle

But then having the cheerful picture of James, could make you think he was so young, and make you feel angry. Whereas, in the tabloid, the picture's bring out a totally different feeling. The pictures of Thompson and Venables, show them happy, and I think this could make readers feel angry; as if you picture them with a smile on their face it could make you feel like they don't care about what they have done, and are happy about it. Whereas the James picture is located in-between theirs, so it shows they had power over him and because the picture he does not have a smile shows he was vulnerable and shows him being young. These pictures are there to bring out one feeling, that Thompson and Venables should pay, for their crime. In the broadsheet the picture doesn't take up that much space, but in the tabloid it's like it is the main feature. The captions in the tabloid bring out even more feelings to the picture because of the bold words 'KILLER' 'VICTIM' 'KILLER'. Using the word killer shows that the murder was vicious and could have never been done by accident. The captions in the broadsheet just basically tell you what the picture is of, and doesn't really make you focus on the pictures. ...read more.

Conclusion

the point, whereas the broadsheet is aim at readers of a more higher class and people who want to know the in-depth truth of the story. Both newspapers also make use of different fonts and typographical device. The bold font size of a tabloid attracts the reader to the paper. The tabloid has less writing and a reading age from 8 yrs. The tabloid paper makes the article look more interesting. The quotes are in italics with bold speech marks. The tabloid captions are short, quick and simple. The broadsheet has a much smaller font and more writing. The broadsheet has fewer captions. The text in the broadsheet is surrounding the photos. It has more columns and long sentences. The tabloid is easy to read on a quick journey whereas the broadsheet would take a lot more time to read and has a lot more detail to take in. The fundamental difference between the way the different newspapers treat the story is that in the tabloid I think they are appealing to the right wing and the broadsheet to the left wing. I think the tabloid appeals to more people as there are emotive words which effect the readers feelings and reaction1,2,3s to the article. 1 Simone Etienne 2 Simone Etienne Simone Etienne GCSE Coursework Assignment-Media Unit ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Newspapers & Magazines section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Newspapers & Magazines essays

  1. Looking at and comparing how two different newspapers report the same story.

    It is quite important for this technique to be used in the headline and lead paragraph as they're the first places the reader looks and decides whether the article is worth reading or not. There are also other examples of sensational language in the main text of the article such

  2. Comparing two articles based on the same story, from different newspapers ie. Tabloid and ...

    'The Daily Mirror' article is on page 17 of the newspaper, presenting to us that the newspaper obviously do not perceive this story as being of great significance to its target group, where as 'The Daily Telegraph' article is on the front page of the newspaper, illustrating to us that

  1. In Depth Structured Textual Analysis Questions - Tabloid newspapers.

    Its simplistic enough to reach a wider audience, with short simple facts about its main stories. The main points of story on Michael Jackson, is that a 12 year old boy has accused Michael Jackson of sexually abusing him, straight away we can see a bias in the article as

  2. A comparative analysis of broadsheet and tabloid newspapers

    Everything is very spaced out and I can see the red masthead at the top of the paper. This is why newspapers such as The Sun are known as redtops. I think that the layout is very eye catching and is much more appealing than the broadsheet.

  1. Comparing tabloid and broadsheet newspapers

    These Fill stories are generally humorous and interesting and I think this is why a tabloid newspaper is aimed at a much younger audience possible teenager upwards, whereas I would say that broadsheets are suitable for middle aged to older people.

  2. My two articles I have chosen to compare are from the The Sun and ...

    conclude that a broadsheet is a better source of information than a tabloid. With relation to language comes the tone of an article. The article from 'The Sun' is of an informative, angry and sad tone. The informing tone is simply created by displaying the e-fit picture, but the emotional

  1. Successful reading may be achieved by balancing approaches: bottom-up and top-down.

    She indicates that phonics on the other hand, builds upon a reader's pronunciation and word recognition skills. (http://www.superkids.com/aweb/pages/features/reading/phonics.shtml [23.10.01]) John Holdren, director of research and communication of the Core Knowledge foundation gives an example of the phonics based bottom-up approach to reading from a Merrill basal reading series as follows: Is a cat on a mat?

  2. Celebrity and the tabloid press.

    than The Daily Star with an unexpected emphasis on current affairs and politics. The front cover holds a story about Spain's election in which a socialist party won following the bombings in Madrid. The main story on the front cover is a story about the Leicester City rape allegations -

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work