• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In this excerpt from Marie Winn's 1977 book The Plug In

Extracts from this document...


In this excerpt from Marie Winn's 1977 book The Plug In Drug, Winn draws several parallels between drug or alcohol addiction and "the television habit." Do you find Winn's arguments to be persuasive? Why or why not? Television addiction is no laughing matter. According to author Marie Winn in her 1987 book Unplugging the Plug In Drug , television addiction should be viewed no differently than other serious addictions, such as drug addiction. When people become engaged in both activities their motivation is similar: pleasure and escapism. So why should a resultant addiction to both activities be any different? Although Winn makes several convincing arguments, television and drug use are ultimately not comparable due to their distinct effects on human lives. People indulge in drug use and television for similar reasons. Both activities offer an escape from daily life and a different experience of reality. Moreover, immersion in television and drugs can "blot out the real world" and allow for a pleasurable or indifferent state. Drugs provide a biological reinforcement of the activity and produces a pleasurable chemical response. ...read more.


Her point is still a valid one. Whenever a person dedicates themself to one particular purpose they are limiting their interests and experiences. There is no impetus for them to develop or diversify, as long as they find a superior pleasure in one pursuit. Sometimes the experience is not pleasure, but a passive state in which there is no motivation and no progress. The feeling that a person "ought" to do other things outside the benumbed practice of television viewing, but does not, indicates that peoples' lives have been narrowed by their so-called addiction. Winn fails to be convincing when she goes on to further define addiction. She defines addiction not only as the desire to repeat an activity, but as the inability to be satiated by the activity upon repetition. Her argument is problematic because with drugs there is an initial guarantee of satisfaction and with television there is not. When you take a drug, there is a biological pleasure induced. It may require more each time to provide the same effect, but there is still a pleasurable experience. ...read more.


Winn overlooks that unlike drugs, a person can rouse themselves from the state of television viewing. Someone under the influence of drugs or alcohol cannot. Their impairment is physical. In addition to this, there are also physical side effects when a person curtails use of drugs. The addict becomes physically ill and unable to function normally. If a person who watches a lot of television ceases to do so, there are no such consequences. This is a crucial point, because Winn describes addiction as the inability to function normally without the activity to which one has become addicted. It would be interesting to learn in greater detail what Winn views as the negative or adverse effects of television addiction. She does not detail the impact the actual content television could have, in her chapter entitled "Television Addiction." Certainly, one could see that television's content could have an adverse impact on impressionable addicts, such as children. The act of viewing itself, not the content, is the focus of her analysis of the influence of television addiction. While some of the conditions of television addiction resemble those of drug addiction, it does not fully meet Winn's criteria for addiction. She cannot give any concrete examples of television's harms; she can only insist that it must be harmful. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Television section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Television essays

  1. Essay responding to "Television Addiction" by Marie Winn.

    Therefore, scientific information has become accessible to more people all over the world. Secondly, television can be a powerful tool for learning a language and, as a result, it can improve our communication abilities. Thus, Marie Winn falls into card stacking by saying that "It weakens relationships by reducing and sometimes eliminating normal opportunities for talking, for communicating."(15).

  2. To compare the television viewing habits of 50 people

    Tally Total 0 - 1 IIIII 5 1 - 2 IIIII IIIII I 11 2 - 3 IIIII IIIII IIIII I 16 3 - 4 IIII 4 4 - 5 IIIII I 6 5+ IIIII III 8 5.* Tally Total News IIIII IIIII IIIII IIIII I 21 Drama IIIII IIIII

  1. Television industry is experiencing significant growth in the UK.

    Developing their own content means a new source of profit for cable operators. Moreover they can use the time allocated to them by most program suppliers (aprox. 2 minutes per hour). - A merger between Granada and Carlton presents more possibilities for cooperation between the UK content providers and Cable

  2. Television and its Effects

    There is no debate as to whether children are impressionable, and this makes violence on television even more of an important topic. The 90's series 'The Mighty Morphin Power Rangers' are a prime example of children imitating the things they see on television.

  1. Television Violence and the Effects on Children

    (CRTC Chronology). In 1997 it was required that on screen ratings accompanied television shows such as children's programming, dramas, reality shows, and feature films. There have been further studies and reviews of the shows on Canadian television, the commission has also continued to lobby the American networks with Canadian concerns.

  2. To what extent do ‘Eastenders’ and ‘Neighbours’ represent reality?

    removed after two years because her policy of dealing with social issues such as drugs resulted in a large drop of viewing figures. Bill Podmore, a later producer of the soap is very critical of Eastenders. 'Eastenders took up the cudgels for just about every controversial issue, from homosexuality and AIDS to drug addiction.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work