• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The two articles under discussion are chosen from a well-known tabloid newspaper called, 'The Daily Mail' and the well-established broadsheet newspaper, 'The Independent.'

Extracts from this document...


Media Analysis Claire Rapley 4a The two articles under discussion are chosen from a well-known tabloid newspaper called, 'The Daily Mail' and the well-established broadsheet newspaper, 'The Independent.' Both articles were printed fourteen years ago, however the broadsheet was printed on the 9th March, a few days after the tabloid printed their view on the 6th March. The articles cover the same story, about a summer camp for children aimed at making school subjects fun. The camp, held at Butlins received mainly criticism from the tabloid, and a mixture of good and bad publicity from the broadsheet. The presentations of the articles differ tremendously, and the general layouts reflect different types of newspapers. 'The Mail's' article takes up a whole page of the newspaper. It carries a large two line banner headline, which is significantly larger than the main body of text. Roughly half the page is taken up by a large photograph. Underneath this are nine short paragraphs divided up with one larger subheading breaking the text up. The article in 'The Telegraph' is presented in a very different way. The headline goes all the way across the text of the article, however this cannot be called a banner headline, as the headline would not have gone across a whole page. ...read more.


There purpose is to draw the reader into the story and make them want to read the following article. The tabloid achieves this aim, by means such as word order. In the lead paragraph of 'The Mail', three key phrases are mentioned. When stating the motto, it is prefixed with "familiar and factious". Having read the whole article this implies that the journalist is being slightly sarcastic, and again making fun of the camp. The Lead paragraph states that the holiday camp is in Brighten. This is in fact a factual error, and should not have been included. This tells us that the newspaper article was poorly reserched. The journalist also mentions why the students are there. When doing this, he states GCSE in full. (General Certificate of Secondary Education) The articles were printed in 1987, which was the first year that GCSE's took place. The fact that he states this in full suggests that his does not expect his readers to be aware of this major education issue. The overall effect of this paragraph, created by the choice of vocabulary etc is emotive, and dramatic. The Broadsheet's lead paragraph is much longer. It is written much more factually. ...read more.


In the final paragraph, the journalist makes a remark which attacks the teacher, parents and local authorities involved with the project. By using the phrase, "No marks" it shows that he not impressed with the people involved with the scheme. Both of the articles mention "Hi-di-hi", The tabloid uses it in its headline, and the broadsheet in its final paragraph, however I do not feel that they are after the same effect. When it is read in context in the tabloid article, it is one of the first emotive words used. Word order is a common technique used in tabloid writing, and by placing it first, emphasis is placed on it. The Broadsheet places this as a joke at the end, and I feel that this has no meaning or depth, but is just simply a joke added in as a small light hearted piece of humour. The newspapers are not written to rival each other. They are both targeted at different audiences. I think it is important to realise that the tabloid article was published several days before the broadsheet one, and therefore the broadsheet article journalist would have had more time to put his story together. I feel that the tabloid has written his article in the way he has and included the facts he has because he knows that he will sell more newspapers - the British public loves a scandal--! 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Newspapers & Magazines section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Newspapers & Magazines essays

  1. Comparing Two Newspaper Articles

    The Times (article one) is a larger article compared to The Mirror (article two) in size. It is factual and an international paper with loads of numbers and figures used. The article contains two photographs of John Walker (an American Taleban fighter).

  2. Comparing two Newspaper Articles

    Figures are used ' twenty people fell three hundred feet', 'about one hundred meters', '40 people', '6000ft mountain', etc. The figures used within the text introduce a certain eloquence to the article, and reinforce the severity of the situation. The tone is very monotonous and detached and hyperbole is used

  1. Comparing two articles based on the same story, from different newspapers ie. Tabloid and ...

    In the article from 'The Daily Telegraph' the first sentence as well as involving the subject and main clause, is a complex syntax.

  2. Coverage of the same story in 'The Sun' (a tabloid newspaper) and the Independent ...

    In opposition broadsheet papers use informative headlines. The Independent says 'English woman shot on round world trip'. This emphasises the issue at hand rather than the 'hero' that The Sun puts the emphasis on. This keeps more to the point rather than dramatising the situation.

  1. A comparative analysis of 'The Sun' a tabloid newspaper and 'The Guardian' a broadsheet ...

    text: 'impassionate, strategically, specifically, steepled and persona' are examples of this type of language which is used in the article. It crates a more accurate coverage and reporting of this particular news story, which is apparently how the readers of 'The Guardian' prefer their newspaper to report, more focus on the facts than entertainment.

  2. Compare tabloid and broadsheet newspaper styles, focusing particularly on layout, the language and the ...

    This way it stands out, is attractive and catches the eye of the reader who then buys the newspaper. The logo of "The Sun" is slanted forward slightly, forward in terms of progression maybe, and is bold and large. The font is basic and so appeals to younger people.

  1. Compare and contrast the three newspaper articles, explaining carefully what you like and dislike ...

    The Daily Mail article has a very hopeful mood. It goes on about how Bruno may have lost the fight but he grew in status and has earned everyone's respect. The fans have not turned against him and sang 'Frankie, we love you'.

  2. Commentary on a Newspaper Article by Russel Brand.

    nerves to face reality, which must make the reality show a fake, aka the government is a fake they won?t face reality. Brand claims they are ignoring society?s real big problems by sweeping them under a carpet ? that is why Big Brother isn?t watching you ? as the title of the article claims.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work