• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To compare the way three news publications, The Times, The Mirror and Newsweek, an American weekly magazine, reported the same incident, “A Disaster in the Alps”

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

To compare the way three news publications, The Times, The Mirror and Newsweek, an American weekly magazine, reported the same incident, "A Disaster in the Alps" For this essay, I have been asked to compare three different news reports of the same incident - 'Disaster in the Alps'. On the 3rd of February 1998, a US fighter plane severed the cable of a ski lift in the Italian Alps. A cable car with 20 occupants inside fell to the ground and all were killed. The incident was widely reported in the British and American press, but the three publications I am looking at are; The Mirror, The Times and Newsweek. The Mirror is a tabloid paper. It uses pacy, dramatic language, bold type and pull quotes to report on the incident. The Times is a broadsheet paper. It is known as the establishment newspaper, has a reputation for investigative journalism and uses calm language to report the incident. Newsweek is an American weekly publication. It is in high competition with another American weekly, 'Time', for the highest sales. It downplays the incident as a form of 'anti-Americanism'. Each publication therefore describes the incident in a different way. The Mirror provides facts on the number of people killed and how far they fell. It includes opinions on the height that the plane was flying and interviews people from every angle of the incident - holidaymakers, police, fire and US officials. ...read more.

Middle

Words and phrases like 'sliced' and 'ripped apart' also help to do this. The Times reports on the incident in a more controlled manner, but it still shows the horror of the incident. The article provides all the facts without going over the top and does not try to put the blame squarely on the Americans. The article includes all the information that the reader needs for an accurate picture of the incident and the writing is structured so that the reader can fully understand the situation. As The Times is a broadsheet paper the language is also more complex and includes longer sentences. Newsweek's report is very different. The language does not show the horror of the incident, but tries to say that the outcry against low-flying planes is some kind of anti-Americanism. Even the sub-headline says that 'Europe questions America's character'. This all starts to confuse the reader and so does not give an accurate picture of the incident. The words used also try to disagree with the facts of the incident. Words like 'griped' and 'claimed' both suggest that there was nothing wrong and everyone was 'ganging up' against America. The people interviewed in The Mirror's article each give a different perspective on the incident. There are British holidaymakers, who narrowly missed being on the cable car. ...read more.

Conclusion

The Times does not have any American comment, other than the statement by the Pentagon. This means that although the Times' article is largely impartial, it does not give the American view of things. Newsweek's article is weak because it is totally dependent on confusing the reader. If it fails to do this, the reader can see through the article as just a show to try and turn the incident against Europe. It is also weak because it is clouding the truth and not facing up to the facts. The article diverges away from the incident and further and further away into things that have nothing to do with the incident. From looking at these three very different articles on the same incident, I have found that The Mirror is very good at making the reader feel personally involved, a common tactic used in Britsh tabloids, by giving the incident a British feel. From this comparison, I have found that The Times is very good at keeping the incident international and writing about it in a calm manner. I think that The Times sticks to the facts and portrays the incident as it is and does not over complicate it. I think that on the basis of this, Newsweek does not give the reader all of the information that they require for an exact picture of the incident. It changes the focus of the article and does not let the reader get into the incident in detail. It is, in reality, cheating the readers. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Newspapers & Magazines section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Newspapers & Magazines essays

  1. My two articles I have chosen to compare are from the 'The Sun' and ...

    Due to this need for emotions most tabloids will be biased particularly 'The Sun'. In the article being analysed 'The Sun' is biased because it displays hate for the kidnapper: "THE Sun today offers a 50,000 reward to catch the beast who snatched Sarah Payne."

  2. Analyze 3 different newspaper articles - the articles are taken from 'The Mirror,' 'The ...

    Words like 'griped' and 'claimed' both suggest that there was nothing wrong and everyone was 'ganging up' against America. In The Times, the witness interviewed is not British, so the Times keeps the story international. An unreasonable complaint is made in the first line, which may show their guilt: "Cavalese

  1. To compare the way three news publications, The Times, The Mirror and Newsweek, an ...

    The whole report is presented in as factual a way as possible, trying to avoid blaming any particular party. The Mirror report contains much of the same factual information, but it relies more on first hand accounts from eyewitnesses to describe the accident, and particularly the scene afterwards.

  2. Media report on magazine

    Preparation and Planning Our first ideas were producing a magazine about football as stated before. This was because our knowledge of football was much more than any other sport but as we researched over the internet, we learnt that there were already many football magazines to compete with.

  1. Production Report - Magazine

    The main reason for doing this was to make the construction quick and easy as possible. I had to decide what was going to be good stories to design and compose that would allow me to show off as many media skills I can.

  2. My coursework is going to be based on a newspaper report called 'disaster in ...

    In both reports the language is very dramatic as both reporters are trying to give the readers a realistic feeling of the incident itself. The language used in the 'The Times' to describe the incident and the plane is very formal as it goes deep into text and pulls out the striking information.

  1. 'Smash Hits' sells itself as a 'popular music magazine';

    Whatever messages that 'Smash Hits' offer can be taken on, disregarded or adapted by the audience depending on their individual beliefs. The audience, of course, are not one solid entity or crowd, but rather are fragmented and separated by both location and time.

  2. Magazine Comparison Nuts and Zoo. Discussion of Men's Weekly Magazines

    Or more cynically as Rick Poynor, writing for eyemagazine, put it "If these products then sell, is it because this really is what men want? Or because the evolving conventions of the global market place have engineered public taste to respond to this rubbish?"

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work