• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Two media pieces - 1) The Factsheet from the NCDL 2) The article from the Sunday Mirror by Pippa Sibley.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Study the two media pieces. 1) The Factsheet from the NCDL 2) The article from the Sunday Mirror by Pippa Sibley Write a response to these pieces in which you consider the aims and the purposes of each piece; the methods used by the writers to persuade the readers of their point of view: any similarities in approach and which you find the most convincing. This piece of media coursework asks me to study closely a newspaper article published by 'The Sunday Mirror' and a factsheet produced by the National Canine Defence League. I think the purpose of the article from the "The Sunday Mirror" and the "Factsheet" is to inform people who are not involved with puppy farming, what goes on behind the doors of the farms. They have been written to persuade the reader to feel anger towards the farmers, who run puppy farms and to make the reader feel sympathy towards the puppies and their mothers. Pippa Sibley's article, gives us information about how badly the puppies and bitches are treated throughout their lives in the farms and considers the type of breeders who are involved in this business. It also tells the reader how the mothers are dealt with when they become infertile. The Factsheet also informs people about what kind of puppy they might be buying in pet shops: puppies that have had a cruel life and may now be a danger to their new owners because they may have diseases or strange behaviours because of intense breeding. ...read more.

Middle

The presentational devices used on the factsheet are similar in some ways but very effective. The first thing you see are the words, 'FREE-range FIDO', in the left hand corner, which is the name of the campaign against puppy farming. This is a campaign that has been set up to try and help puppies and bitches to be freed. The sub heading, 'How much is that puppy?' is very interesting. This is because it might remind people of the song, 'How much is that doggy in the window?' which makes the reader think that the text will be a light-hearted look at breeding and selling puppies. Once he/she starts reading it, they realise that it is not light-hearted at all and that it is more like the heading of the article. It is quite hard hitting as we read about cruel farmers and the suffering of dogs and puppies. The effect on the reader is very strong and makes us realise how bad this business is. Towards the bottom of the fact sheet, there is a sub-heading that reads, 'What you can do'. This is very positive and it gives the impression that you can actually help these poor puppies and their mothers by bringing this business to an end. The text below it gives you all the things you have to do to try and help 'FIDO'. We are asked to write to our local MP and if we do this we will change things. ...read more.

Conclusion

'Bitches are suffering'. By using the word 'are', she is presenting the idea that this is the truth when really it is just her opinion. This kind of technique is used throughout the article. In the factsheet, there is still emotive language despite us thinking that we are reading 'facts' and a neutral, balanced piece published by the National Canine Defence League. For example the writer describes the conditions of the puppy farms as being 'dark', 'cramped' and 'cold'. This information could be a fact or the writer could be biased in trying to make the reader believe it. This could be the case for most of the text. There are some similarities between the two pieces of writing. One of the similarities is that they are both trying to get you to help in any way to try and get this type of farming stopped and give these, and other unfortunate puppies and bitches, a better life. Another similarity is that, they both include text about the 'NCDL', 'National Canine Defence League' trying to stop the farming but it needs the readers help to succeed even further. Both use emotive language and disguise opinion as facts. Both use recognised presentational devices but the factsheet does not use a photograph. I think that the Factsheet appears the most convincing. This is because the information given is more accurate and reasoned. It is an official piece published by the 'NCDL'. The article seemed to be sensationalised but in dealing with the puppy farming issue in this way I was left wondering how truthful the piece really was. Adam Taylor 4g ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Newspapers & Magazines section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Newspapers & Magazines essays

  1. Comaparing two types of media

    It is easily recognizable that 'The Sun' is meant for readers that may or may not be highly educated, hence, it is called 'The People's Paper'. Therefore, the language used has to be simple: "Police also boosted the hunt yesterday by issuing an e-fit (above)

  2. Free essay

    magazines task 1 n 2

    There are different types of consumers specilist magazines for example, computer games, fishing, music and fashion. most of these magazines are available in the whole of the country, often through localised editions so that, for example

  1. How to approach 2 holiday brochures

    This helps attract children it also connects with the blue wave image, showing the reader how important water is in the holiday. The writer seems to be playing on the idea that water is fun for children. The type of language used by the 'Club 18-30' is a very compelling brochure.

  2. Year 10 English Coursework - Media

    Underneath this picture the subheading is "Offensive..Harry in fancy dress gear" Here the Sun is telling you what you already know and by using the word offensive makes him sound a lot worse than he is. There is only one picture in The Times article and it only takes up one sixth of the article.

  1. Compare the article in the Independent with the article in the Daily Mail, addressing ...

    Generally the Independent is truthful, detailed and covers politics. Generally The Daily Mail is trivial, not completely factual and not very informative but is still just as, if not more popular. This is due to fact it publishes celebrity gossip, sports results and punchy headings to unbalance the readers emotions.

  2. Analyse item 1 a newspaper article from ' The Guardian' and item 2 part ...

    After that incident an officer visited him. With a helping hand and a shoulder to cry on Jim was taken to a hostel where he "enjoyed a hot bath, a shave" and most of all "friendship." From then, Jim had been living in the local 'Salvation Army' hostel.

  1. Compare The Sunday Times and The Sunday Express.

    The Express uses a bold, thick border around the article, making it stand out further. In The Times, there is a border, yet it is less effective as it is very thin and not very bold. There is just one column of text in the Express article.

  2. 'The Children's Society' - Media study.

    They both use the similar technique of correlation with the image: " 'Now that Richard's 16 they let him stay out at night' " On the surface, the first and third headlines are very positive, but when read in conjunction with the image in each, they become profoundly ironic.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work