• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Watch Jack Neo's Homerun and an episode of MediaCorp's "Police and Thief" television programme. Compare and contrast then in terms of both narrative and genre and/or mode.

Extracts from this document...


Watch Jack Neo's Homerun and an episode of MediaCorp's "Police and Thief" television programme. Compare and contrast then in terms of both narrative and genre and/or mode. Organisation of Essay: 1. Short summary of my understanding of the question and my thesis statement 2. State some obvious similarities and differences between the 2 case studies. 3. Dissect each case study with the following categories in mind: a. Narratives b. Genres c. Representation d. Ideology e. Scenes 4. Conclusion 5. Some other things to think about: a. Give concrete examples. b. Aspects of styles. These two shows are very Singaporean. By this I mean that they contain many elements which are unique to my country, elements which only within the paradigm of our society will resonate with local viewers. Homerun, an Asian remake of the internationally acclaimed Iranian movie Children of Heaven is a movie directed by Jack Neo, who is a local celebrity best known for his comedic prowess and the many comedy shows under his name. Police and Thief is a relatively new weekly half-hour sitcom shown on Channel 5 which has yet to set a foothold in the heart of local audiences. ...read more.


Kiat Kun has no idea how the shoes had mysteriously disappeared and hence his sister Seow Fang too. In this scene alone, a beautiful play on camera angle suffices to keep us in suspense till much later in the show. This seemingly passing top down close up scene of the gnarled hands removing the shoes helps to tug hard at our heart strings when we later realize the rag-and-bone man is blind. The above is a good example of how both restricted and unrestricted narration can be developed from one scene. We know who had taken away the shoes (unrestricted narration) but like the characters in the show we have no idea he was blind (restricted narration). These two shows belong to the 2 commonest genres in Singapore. Police and Thief can be classified as belonging to the "HDB" genre. In fact this plot of this particular sitcom revolves around the conflict faced by two men who live in close proximity. It has an appeal particular to local viewers who are able to appreciate the familiar settings. One example which we can relate to is the scene of Lily, Tok Kong's wife who repeats a punch line in a scene where her face is framed in the center of our common older HDB window panes. ...read more.


This is perhaps the director's ideology portraying the way Malaysia hordes over us in the water issue. The premise of Homerun revolved around three things: shoes, intelligence and power being associated with wealth. Jack Neo parodies the socio-political situation between Singapore and Malaysia using the three elements with shoes being the water, Singapore being the more intelligent country and power that Malaysia holds over us due to their superior water resource. The two shows end differently too. The end of the sitcom is close without answered questions while the cryptic ending of Homerun leaves us pondering what the director would have us think as we leave the cinema. There is no element of suspense left in Police and Thief to entice the audience to look out for the next episode, unlike a soap opera. Even as both shows make use of our experience to enhance our appreciation and understanding of the shows, they obviously use several different techniques and some similar ones to bring forth the essence of each individual story. These different methods highlight certain elements essential to the plot of the stories and ultimately help us to enjoy the shows as Singaporeans. Word Count: 1512 ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Television section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Television essays

  1. Delia Smith and Jamie Oliver are both extremely influential television chefs, however their methods ...

    The main colour scheme in her kitchen is white. It is perhaps ironic as I associate white with 'pure'. This coincides perfectly with my idea of which I believe Delia represents - "the pure essential English woman" who everyone respects. I doubt this effect was purposely created. On the other hand, Jamie's kitchen is overflowing with cooking utensils.

  2. Crime Genre Report for Media.

    Secondly is the soap-opera influenced crime "how they're getting on?" less attention is paid to the crime itself and focus is on characters, rules and procedures get in the way of solving the crime. The private life of cops is included.

  1. What does mise-en-scene contribute to our understanding of character and plot in the chosen ...

    This is the type of mise-en-scene that you would expect to see in this particular genre. The branch represents not just Ron but also all that he stands for, given his outspoken love of nature and anything to do with plants.

  2. What is the significance of 'flow' for an understanding of television?.

    can aid the viewer in making sense of programme units individually, as well as in relation to other programme units. For example, if the news on a given evening contains main headline about cars and the pollution they bring, then this may well be followed by a programme with car background; for example Top Gear.

  1. Comparison media essay

    The opening credits begin with a flash of bright light, and then a spaceship zooms across the sky revealing the word, "Futurama". This is similar to "The Simpsons and Family guy" as it also revealed the name of the show at the very beginning.

  2. How Do You Account For The Popularity Of The Crime/Cop Genre With Television Audience's?

    that an audience would expect to see in an episode and associate it with crime/cop shows. Examples include; Guns/Baton, Police Badge, Hats, Walkie-Talkies etc. The narrative of crime/cop shows often run in a linear narrative (events in chronological order) as to not confuse the audience, and if a viewer has missed many episodes they can quickly catch up.

  1. Discuss the reasons for the success/appeal of the reality television genre and the moral ...

    I think this because you get to see what happens to the people in the house, like if they can cope or if they crack from being trapped in an artificial environment. It gives us a good programme because it has; humour, suspense, romance, sudden dramatic changes and it makes you feel you're in their shoes.

  2. How does "Life on Mars" (2006) use visual codes, technical, audio and narrative codes ...

    Throughout the episode, Sam hears hospital noises and doctor voices and at one point sees a person on late night TV talking like a doctor describing Sam being in a coma.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work