• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

When comparing two websites, Green Landscaping with Native Plants and The South Carolina Wildlife Foundation, it is important to "evaluate

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Website Evaluation ENG-101-W01 Instructor: Julia Towles July 18, 2005 Geoffrey Stephens When comparing two websites, Green Landscaping with Native Plants and The South Carolina Wildlife Foundation, it is important to "evaluate each website before you consider using the information found on it"(Learning Resource Centers). The categories to evaluate are: Accuracy, Authority, Objectivity, Currency, and Coverage. These five guidelines are the basis for evaluation and the cornerstones to creating a good website. Of these two sites listed, I find that the Green Landscaping with Native Plants site falls more in line with these criteria and is therefore the better site. The first criterion to be discussed is that of Accuracy. This criterion could very well be one of, if not the most important one. It is essential for a web site to maintain not only accurate information, but also up to date information as well. The Great Lakes National Program office of the Environmental Protection Agency maintains the Green Landscaping with Native Plants site. This is a very reliable source for this sort of information. The site includes a pamphlet that lists all sources used. This fact helps to solidify the validity of the claims. The site also informs it readers that it is not the final know all authority on the topic by saying "we make no implied or expressed guarantee"(Green Landscaping with Natural Plants). ...read more.

Middle

It also includes any bias or conversion tactics. To be objective about a topic simply means to present all the facts, even if they do not support your viewpoint. On the topic on landscape and habitats, it is a little more complicated to determine if something is being objective. This fact is easily determined in the case of the Green Landscape with Native Plants site because they are simply giving people advice on what plants will grow best and how to establish the plants so that they will flourish in times to come. This is not hard to determine because, there really is nothing to sway a person to or from. It is simply putting out the information to the people so that they may have better success with their planting projects. They go even further by stating their objectivity in their disclaimer where they say "does not necessarily constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by the US Government"(Green Landscaping with Native Plants). It is hard for The South Carolina Wildlife Federation to compete with that level of objectivity that comes with being a government agency. However, they do a pretty good job of it. The purpose of their site is to raise people awareness of how easy it is to help with the habitats of wildlife in this rapidly expanding and growing state that suffers from habitat erosion due to construction rate in the state. ...read more.

Conclusion

not go into enough detail or is not presented in a easy to read and navigate through manner, either the information will not meet the needs of the reader or they will not try to locate it. Both web sites evaluated presented their information in a well formatted, easy to navigate manner. One thing that could very well turn away potential readers from The South Carolina Wildlife Federation website goes back to the fact that they rely on public donations. On the home page of their website is the listings of current fundraising events that are upcoming as well as an advertisement for a ball cap that can be purchased. These two things could very well dissuade some people from continuing to search their site for the desired information. This fact is especially true in today's era of pop-ups and spy ware plaguing many individual's computers. For that sole reason, Green landscape with Native Plants site is the better site in this category. So as you can see by using the five evaluation categories, it makes the difficult task of deciding which websites are good and which are not into a seemingly simple process. Even when faced with two overall outstanding sites such as The South Carolina Wildlife Federation and the Green Landscape with Native Plants websites, it was quite apparent that the later better satisfied the evaluation criteria for a good website, making it the superior choice for obtaining the desired information. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Internet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Internet essays

  1. In assessing the competitive position of a large online trader, we would use the ...

    Because after they became Amazon's customers, all of their website operation will be locked up with Amazon and they will hardly change to other competitors. However, Amazon has to keep on introducing new service by adding more value to their services and trying to keep those customers with Amazon.

  2. Critically analyse and evaluate current developments in consumer behaviour in relation to one transport ...

    the population who have not taken a cruise, reasons identified by Dickinson and Vladimir (1997) cited in Cartwright and Baird (1999) revealed five main reasons why people do not cruise which consist it being too expensive, the exclusivity, family commitments, claustrophobia and sea sickness.

  1. Evaluation of Two Commercial Multimedia products. oth products are professional animations which have ...

    Techniques used: This animation has used a number of techniques to make it professional and attractive which eventually makes it successful. The animation has used buttons to navigate from scene to other by clicking the "story bear" or "next". Users can start the story again if by clicking "back to the start".

  2. CRITICAL EVALUATION OF A2 MEDIA PRODUCTION COURSEWORK (website)

    but I feel it could have been improved if I had been able to use a dedicated camcorder with better quality. When the quality of the audioclips is compared to other amateur band websites such as those for The Lightyears or Odyssey of Fran, it is clear that I could

  1. Evaluation of five sites

    Which I feel is quite relevant to the movie. There is plenty of hyperlinks, which gives many clips form, the actual movie, which for those who haven't seen it would be encourage doing so. I think that the graphics here are particularly good, again with an ancient feeling.

  2. Whom Willa Cather is and where I should begin searching for my topic. ...

    There were many obstacles that I faced when I set out to do this presentation. The most obvious obstacle was time. The time slot that I signed up for was the first spot to present and the last spot available on the sign up sheet.

  1. Setting up a good video shop.

    The one that we are going to concentrate on is questionnaires. Primary data is the most reliable and is more likely to give us first hand experience of the local market where I plan to sell my product or service.

  2. Design and create a website for a company of my choice. I have decided ...

    Is your computer connected to a printer? Yes No 15. Do you have a colour printer? Yes No 16. Would you like to receive emails informing you of the latest offers? Yes No Please select what other features you would like to see on the site Details on the products and items sold Yes No Pictures of

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work