• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Elizabeth Loftus

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Mark Suffolk Group A For many years eye witness testimony has been a key element of courtroom trials. Whether a person is given a guilty verdict or not can revolve around who the jury believe, and eye witness testimony plays a major part. However many studies have been conducted over the years which suggest a number of ways in which eye witness testimony can be unreliable. Leading researcher Elizabeth Loftus has suggested factors such as, violent crime, leading questions during interviews, and the presence of a weapon during a crime, can all have a marked effect on the reliability of eye witness testimony. Loftus and Palmer (1974) conducted an experiment in an attempt to show how leading questions can affect an eye witness's version of events. The experiment took place in a laboratory with 45 American students used as the sample. The participants were asked to view footage of a car crash. They were later asked to recall events as if they were an eye witness. The students were then asked to fill in a questionnaire, which had the wording of one question changed. Split onto five groups of nine, one group were asked the question "About how fast were the cars going when they hit?", for the other groups the word "hit" was changed to "smashed", "collided" , "contacted", or "bumped". The findings were that the average speed suggested when the word "smashed "was used was 9 mph more than the average estimate of speed than when the word "contacted" was used. ...read more.

Middle

who suggested we make more errors when the suspect is a different race to the witness. They concluded that we are better at being able to recognise our own race. Another explanation for the inaccuracy of recall is that if our memory of an event is sketchy we have a tendency to use our schemas and stereotypes to fill in the gaps. This is known as reconstructive memory, we reconstruct events by combining parts of the event that is real with our schemas which are stored in long term memory. One of the first to investigate the accuracy of memory was psychologist Frederic Bartlett (1932). He asked a subject to read a story entitled 'War of the ghosts' an old legend about an Indian hunter. The person then had to tell the story to another subject who had not heard it before, the second person then told it to another person, this carried on until ten people had heard it. Bartlett found that by the end, whilst a few basic elements of the story remained, many new 'bits' were added as each person along the way in order to make the story more complete added new parts. This additional information came from each person's knowledge from how they see the world. The findings from the all the research shows how problematic dealing with eyewitness testimony can be, for both the police who interview witnesses and for the courtroom where the testimonies of witnesses have a big impact. ...read more.

Conclusion

If it is the victim asked to identify a suspect, they could be in high state of emotional arousal. They could have the stress of coming close to a person who perhaps assaulted them, also there could be anger involved, and they may pick anybody on the basis they want someone prosecuted for what happened to them. Identity parades could be perhaps made more reliable by introducing new methods. One such method could be to introduce the line up sequentially, this may ease some of the pressure involved. Also the officer conducting the parade shouldn't be aware if the main suspect is present, this could stop anybody perhaps being led to one member of the line up. It could also be mentioned to the person who is trying to identify the perpetrator that the suspect may not be in the line up, this would stop the person feeling like they have to pick someone. It is clear from all the research there is a big margin for error in eyewitness testimony. Whilst jurors are still highly influenced by a confident eyewitness, more cases are able to be solved with more scientific methods such as DNA. However all parts of the justice system should be trying to eliminate potential problems with the testimony of an eyewitness. Perhaps cases should not go to court when the main evidence provided is eyewitness testimony. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Miscellaneous section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Miscellaneous essays

  1. travel and tourism event management

    This is the way the feedback came back from us to be able to choose what destination or types of meal we where going to have: 1. Would you be interested if we were to organise a meal for 6th year and staff?

  2. Principles of the Building Control System

    the works that holds primary responsibility for complying with the regulations and achieving the set standards. Researched through http://www.communities.gov.uk/planningandbuilding/planning/ and http://www.bromley.gov.uk/environment/buildingcontrol/the_regulations.htm P1c) Describe the application of primary legislation The Approved Documents give practical guidance on how to fully comply with the requirements of the regulations.

  1. Referencing. This essay is going to look at four different methods of research used ...

    4. Neville C (2007) 5. Neville C (2007) In any institution, be that educational or research, there are certain rules that govern the use of information. These are called copyright or intellectual property law. Everyone should know these rules to avoid plagiarism. The rules do not allow anyone to use images, sounds, written words unless permission is given by the creator.

  2. Gender Identity

    There are different stages, firstly we observe our parents behaviour and imitate the traditional roles in the household, for example children may observe their father going to work to be the bread winner and the mother cleaning and washing up.

  1. Theoretical Perspectives

    level of pay, this eradicates the threat of an employee raising questions over their pay due to the threat of dismissal - with a reserve army of similarly skilled workers ready to fill in any jobs that may become available, this almost forces a worker to accept his or her

  2. Investigating The Use of Pectinase

    * Lastly, I will be precise with the time intervals whilst performing the experiment. Risk Assessment * I should not keep the buffer solution or any other solution near electrical devices or connection points, such as that of the electrical balance, to prevent any electrical shocks or short circuits.

  1. Ownership of the T & T industry

    are just stamps by the authorities of that country that then confirms you may enter and when you must leave otherwise the visa is not valid anymore. It is normally long haul countries like Australia, USA, and China where you would need a visa.

  2. Outline the main changes and developments in American Stage Music from “Showboat” to “West ...

    This was certainly not the case with coloured folk in the USA at the time. This was slightly unfair criticism to be levelled at such a man, who having grown up in the Jewish community, had experienced a great deal of discrimination first-hand.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work