• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

When We Study History We Are Not Studying The Past But What Historians Have Constructed About The Past

Extracts from this document...


'When we study history we are not studying the past but what historians have constructed about the past' (Keith Jenkins). Discuss. History is supposedly the process of reporting the past in the most accurate way possible, however, this inevitably is not always the case. Our study of history is rarely, if ever, based on first hand experiences but rather the accounts of such experiences by other historians. In this way the basic and obvious facet of the question is answered as indeed in the act of studying it is necessary to have material to study which inevitably is written by a historian, as Jenkins comments "all history is historiography".1 Pg11 This though does not mean that opinions become uniform and although the same set of key facts are largely used they can be interpreted in endless different ways in pursuit of a 'past' closer to the truth. The clearest counter argument to Jenkins statement is the use of primary sources which could be said to be unbiased as they are predominantly objective such as facts and figures. They are the first report of fact which has not been lost in the translation of interpretation by various different historians. However, even these are vulnerable to inaccuracy, whether it is incomplete archives "perished by accident or design", being "Tainted by the less than pure intentions of their author"2, human errors or inaccuracies, or simply ambiguity such as that represented by a photograph. ...read more.


History in its nature is always a retrospective account of by an individual, rather than the first hand experience of it, and thus leaves it to become subject to the bias or discrepancy of that author. It is argued by post modernists that it is impossible to completely separate ones self from the argument and so facts become subject to spin and interpretation therefore becoming a tool in a subjective argument. "The belief in a hard core of historical facts existing objectively and independently of the interpretation of the historian is a preposterous fallacy."4 Pg 12 Carr expresses the view that there cannot be a completely unbiased argument and that during the process of writing history even the facts, in being used in a way that supports an argument, become part of a subjective argument. It could be considered that everything from the selection process to the structure of the essay becomes biased as the mere justification of using one group of sources over another and to pick only the most important facts over others to sustain your argument means that it becomes partial to the preference of the author and the structure of the essay can be used to present a fact in a more significant was so as to inflate its importance to the argument or its significance to the topic. ...read more.


accepted it is crucial to answering the question as it means that the process of historiography, that being the writing of history, has a purpose to entertain and so loses credibility as a source that is even attempting to be completely factual. This then has the implication that the history which is studied is not only constructed but manipulated. Although the study of history is largely based around the work of previous historical authors this does not necessarily imply any negativity unlike what is suggested in Jenkins statement. The process of writing history is not simply the acceptance and then reconstruction of information that you are given. It is also the evaluation of a source's integrity based on the conditions of its production and the extraction of any worthy information that may be with in even though it is undeniable that over time the selection and ensuing discard of information in history that it becomes impossible to recover a full account. So in some ways historians are undeniably bound by the choices of their predecessors but it cannot be considered that the historians as a race are to naive too have already accepted this argument at and sought to not simply take sources of history at face value but to analyse them and use them, albeit, just to restructure an argument in a way for the next person to similarly decode. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Miscellaneous section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Miscellaneous essays

  1. Planning, Design and Production Phases of the Construction Industry

    filled in followed by a number of site meetings arranged by them for the architect and the Council. *Information sourced from Havering Council's website. - The design Team The design team should be involved from the beginning of the project but if the architect chooses he can employ a team at this stage of planning.

  2. factors influencing conformity and obedience

    Within the public services there are penalties which may involve you being demoted or even being discharged. There is a phobia of punishment, this is known as poinephobia. There are many theories about that say that people should learn about discipline through being rewarded not made to obey orders through

  1. "Why has there been a substantial increase in the adopted population of children born ...

    issues, medical issues, occupational and physical therapy issues, parenting issues, pre-adoption issues and school based issues such as learning difficulties and problems associated with making friends.4 There are many medical conditions that are associated with children adopted from overseas such as: Latent Tuberculosis Infection (common in children adopted from China and Russia)

  2. Customer experience management in UK higher education

    (Narasimhan 2007 121) Characteristics of Higher Education In any society, higher education is accessible in a cultural minority and the university is a privilege for few. The university acts as a big agency, not only forming as selector leaders for the society.

  1. Contemporary Construction - Economics and Finance

    (skilled, semi-skilled workers), such as bricklayers, carpenters, and equipment operators, but also those who supply the service like architects, engineers and other professionals and technicians. 3. Capital Capital in an economic sense is different from "capital" in accounting aspects. Capital is the goods used to produce further goods and/or services.

  2. Forensic Photography: Selection of Equipment'

    D1 In forensic science a good camera is vital for taking photographs. This is because in many cases photos can help to tell the crime. The two cameras I have researched to compare are the Panoscan MK-3 and the Fujifilm IS Pro SLR Digital Camera.

  1. Investigating The Use of Pectinase

    I believe that these are appropriate volumes of pectinase and buffer and also that it is important not to use too much liquid material so as not to distort my results. * The mass of apple pulp needs to be kept at a constant at all temperatures.

  2. Children are active in constructing their own learning.

    who had witnessed the adult being rewarded behaved more aggressively towards the doll than those who had seen the adult getting punished. He concluded that the children had learned their behaviour through observation alone but does go on to suggest that children are more likely to copy behaviours of children of similar ages and gender.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work