• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A Comparative Analytical Commentary of Debussys Syrinx and Prlude l'Aprs-midi d'un Faune

Extracts from this document...


A Comparative Analytical Commentary of Debussy's "Syrinx" and "Pr�lude � l'Apr�s-midi d'un Faune" Composed at the turn of the 19th century, the works "Syrinx" and "Pr�lude � l'Apr�s-midi d'un Faune" by Claude Debussy are examples of French Romantic music where the flute is featured prominently. The works were revolutionary at the time they were written, both displaying the Romanticism of their era and also the innovatively modern harmony which would become widespread in the 20th century. This Commentary will attempt to analyse the key features of "Syrinx", the shorter of the two pieces, and comment on how it creates an effective impact on the audience. The Commentary will then compare it with the longer, orchestral, "Pr�lude � l'Apr�s-midi d'un Faune" and identify the similarities and contrasts present. The way which Debussy used a common subject and program to create two very distinct and different works of music will also be examined. "Syrinx", intended originally to be titled "La Fl�te de Pan", was written in 1913 as a piece of incidental music during a play for solo flute. The aim of the piece was to accompany a scene comprising the Greek God Pan, often depicted in the image of a faun or satyr in mythology. The piece begins by stating the main theme: Although the piece is in B-flat minor, it is evident that chromatic notes and semitone intervals are liberally used. ...read more.


which ends this phrase completes the diminished broken chord from before, albeit with much delay and notes filling in between. The fact that A is spelt as the enharmonically equivalent B(( suggests that the music will modulate, which is exactly what Debussy proceeds to do next after a brief repetition of this quavers phrase. The music continues by quickly changing to a major key: At bar 19 the triplet-quaver rhythm ceases suddenly and is followed by a flowing passage with a wider range of movement than before. Although not evident in the score, when heard bars 20 and 21 is distinctively major. The presence of an F(, C( and all other notes flattened would suggest the key is G(-major. This is interesting as this is a modulation to the submediant which is usually used to change to the relative minor key from a piece with major tonality. However in this case it is the reverse, with a modulation to a major key from a minor tonality. The function of this phrase could be explained better if the context which it appears is known. Here the music is preparing to enter the final section restating the opening theme of the piece after a further modulation at bar 22. This brief major section "prepares" this modulation by providing contrast between the previous and following minor sections. ...read more.


"Syrinx", being a depiction of a scene of a solitary faun playing the panflutes, is well suited to a free, performer-centred and almost impromptu form. "Pr�lude", being set to a whole story, is better served by having a more defined structure. Both "Syrinx" and "Pr�lude � l'Apr�s-midi d'un Faune" are examples of the works of a Romantic composer at the zenith of his productivity. By using chromaticism, whole tones, complex harmonies and unusual and distant modulations they are strong examples of the departure from the orthodox melodic and harmonic features found in the earlier Baroque and Classical eras. The link between them is uncommonly strong for two different works by the same composer due to their common program. This, and the fact that at the time they are at the cusp of a transformation of the prevailing music style from Late Romantic to Modernism, ensures these pieces will continue to have both artistic and historical value and will be enjoyed long into the future. Analytical Commentary Plan Debussy: Pr�lude � l'apr�s-midi d'un faune * Orchestration * "Modern" harmony * Tone "qualities" and voicing * Motifs * Imagery imagined by the audience * Evaluation and personal response * Comparison and similarities with Syrinx * Depiction of a faun * Representation by the flute * Harmonic similarities * Orchestral vs. unaccompanied * Free form * Romanticism * Departure from strict structures in earlier eras * Brief comparison with earlier music * Why does it work? ?? ?? ?? ?? 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Music section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Music essays

  1. Compare and contrast ‘Ghost Dances’ and ‘Rooster’ by Christopher Bruce.

    Although in his two dances Bruce conveys very different themes ,there is a similarity of pattern and movement interpreted and demonstrated by the dancers to create the mood he intended.

  2. Write a critical commentary on Mendelssohn's Quartet in Eb Major, Op. 12

    In fact, Mendelssohn now modulates F minor, introducing a haunting melody first played by the second violin. This melody becomes part of a sequential phrase, modulated to G minor, and then to A minor. Where the piece modulates to A minor shows contrapuntal texture, with the violin melody passing to the viola, and then to the cello.

  1. Nicolai Rimsky-Korsakov's Concerto for Trombone, composed in 1878. The work is one that I ...

    Due to it not being is questionably incorrect. The phrasing comparison is shown clearly overleaf. The next obvious difference in approach from the two performers is seen in F. From the third bar of F onwards to the conclusion of the movement, Lindberg slows the tempo down; by contrast Law drives the phrase forward.

  2. An Evaluation of the Marketing Strategy of Nestl Yorkie Chocolate Bars.

    Motorway Service Stations are likely to charge close to 50p for a single, Original Yorkie bar whereas a newsagent will charge close to the RRP (38p). On the shelves Yorkies don't really have a special place unless they have a special offer.

  1. What is the nature of employment in the music industry?

    So if someone does a particular job they would advertise there services. Contractual issues regarding sessional work is that if you are no longer needed to do the particular job you was originally hired for you would be laid off.

  2. Free essay

    Price List and Evaluation of Equipment

    powering both of them. This will also mean I can separately level the bass and lo mid speakers separately to the hi to hi mids which could be helpful when trying to find the best mix of the two

  1. Music therapy and my personal response

    The Benefits by Music Therapy People get benefits mentally and physically from Music Therapy such as practice problem solving, emotional problems to open up the feelings, make optimistic changes in mood and resolve conflict. Music Therapy makes these benefits available because music affects our physics such as brain, body and mind.

  2. How the Flute has developed throughout time up to the point of Boehm and ...

    The Early Baroque Flute did not change that much from the standard Renaissance flute, although an extra hole and silver key was added. One finds that during this period, most of the music written was written with a particular model or maker in mind.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work