• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is motivation more important than ability in a successful competitive performance?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Is motivation more important than ability in a successful competitive performance? In this essay I will investigate whether motivation is more important than ability in team games, racket sports and individual activities. By looking at sources on the Internet, in text books and sports papers; as well as adding graphic examples, I should hopefully be able to answer this question. Before I begin however, I must build up a series of definitions in order to help explain the question. The Edexcel Advanced PE book describes motivation as the 'Drive to Strive', while Kent describes it as 'the internal state which tends to direct a person's behaviour towards a goal'. The English Dictionary describes ability as 'A natural or acquired skill or talent' or 'someone's natural aptitude or acquired proficiency.' Therefore this question asks if, under competitive pressure, a side or person with a lower level of skill or talent than their opponent can win if their mental drive is higher. There are many examples that argue this case. Firstly there are the team games. ...read more.

Middle

However the number of cases in which motivation overcomes ability in individual sports such as track events, swimming and boxing, are few and far between. In Athens last year the Americans ruled once more with athletes like Justin Gatlin and Shaw Crawford winning on the track, and Michael Phelps winning 6 golds, while just a few months ago no amount of motivation from Danny Williams could beat the sheer ability of Vitali Klitchko (see appendix). However, this being sport, it does happen. The Briton, Danny Williams, knocked Mike Tyson, former heavyweight champion of the world and a fighter of huge ability, to the canvas. With the bookies' odds stacked against him, he had the motivation to beat Tyson. Meanwhile in the 110m Hurdles final in last year's Olympic games, the young and unknown Liu Xang won gold. Not only did he win gold, he equalled Colin Jackson's world record at the same time. Despite being a junior champion Xang had never won on a world stage before. In the appendix the inverted U theory shows how motivation helped Williams and Xang to victory against their opponents despite lower levels of ability. ...read more.

Conclusion

Having the right level of motivation is too hit and miss. Say an athlete does have the perfect level of motivation, their opponent still has to have either a really low level or too much motivation for them to win, and that's if they even have the perfect level of motivation. The physiological 'fight or flight' hypothesis means that people with lower abilities than their opponents can become nervous and therefore lead to 'flight' meaning low levels of motivation, and even if 'fight' occurs, they could arouse themselves too much and still have a low performance. It is much easier for the team or person with a higher ability to win as they have to be in a real physical or mental state to lose. Obviously it can happen as some of the examples in the appendix show, but overall ability conquers motivation. If I were going into a sporting competition tomorrow, I'd much rather have the confidence of supreme ability than the worry for the need of motivation. Appendix Miss M. Sharapova bt. Miss S. William - 6-1, 6-4 Vitali Klitchko bt. Danny Williams 1st Xiang Liu ---------------- 12.91 2nd Terrence Trammel ---- 13. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Acquiring, Developing & Performance Skill section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Acquiring, Developing & Performance Skill essays

  1. Identify the important components/skills/techniques needed for a successful performance in the shot put.

    This is to be expected, as we do not have much experience in the event of shot putt. Firstly, he does the movement too quickly, and looks rushed. What Grant would need to do is take time over executing the shot, make sure that his chin, knee, and toe is all vertically aligned to each other, prior to the throw.

  2. Technique Sheet Activity - Swimming Front Crawl

    25 fist, 25m full, 25 alternate 1-arm, 25 full, 25 catch-up, 25 full (375m) Main: 125 full, 100 full, 50 full at 1,500m pace with 10 seconds rest intervals (225m) Warm-down: easy swim to complete the session Week 6 - 950m Warm-up: Set C (300m)

  1. A2 pe coursework

    She will be creating an unforced error for the other team. * Jenny tends to so obstruction when she is marking a shot, making the umpire pull her up for obstruction. This unnecessary free shot given to the shooter puts her team at more of a disadvantage, and it allows the other team to have more free shots.

  2. Free essay

    A2 PE Factors Affecting Performance - Anxiety / Arousal

    So in shot putt I asked the athlete what they thought about anxiety levels and later compared the results to their extrovert / introvert test. (Refer to results page) This relates to Hanin (1980) who realized that personality is a factor when considering anxiety. When considering Wiggins and Brustad (1996)

  1. Gaelic football

    Although the development scheme described above is prodomidently for beginners a competent player who wishes to improve his high catching could benefit from it as it breaks the skill down into the different components. Information on the GAA National headquarters GAA Croke Park Jones Road Dublin 3 Website www.gaa.ie Phone

  2. analysis of 2 sports : Badminton and Gaelic Football

    A minimum amount of Fat. Ectomorph * A high forehead * Receding chin * Narrow shoulders and hips * A narrow chest and abdomen * Thin arms and legs Ectomorphs have high metabolic rates This makes it very difficult for them to gain both muscle and strength.

  1. Critically Evaluate The Relationship Between Team Cohesion and Performance in Competitive Sport.

    1990), whereas leadership characteristics such as trust (Dirks, 2000) have been examined. Situational factors relate to the forces that are holding the group together (Carron and Dennis, 1998). Weinberg and Gould (1999) suggested that group size is one of the situational characteristics that has to be considered.

  2. Is motivation more important than ability in a successful Competitive performance?

    This would give the player huge satisfaction and happiness. The main examples for intrinsic motivation are fun, enjoyment, achievement and satisfaction. These are some of the factors for intrinsic motivation. Like Biddell said people who have lots of intrinsic motivation would last longer in a sport because the extrinsic motivation

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work