“Marx’s political philosophy is a mixture of German Philosophy, French Politics and British economics.” Do you agree?

Authors Avatar

“Marx’s political philosophy is a mixture of German Philosophy, French Politics and British economics.” Do you agree?

Marxism has certainly been influenced by German philosophers like Hegel and French politics like the example of the French revolution, French politics like the example of the French revolution and he has studied the capitalism of British economics. A synthesis of all these elements produces contradictions and uncertainties in the very large and complicated ideology of Marxism.

Marx’s dialectical philosophy was derived from George Hegel’s version of the dialectic. Hegel was an idealist, his believed that the metaphysical progress of man’s collective consciousness to understand itself was reflected in the sequential reality of history. This model begins with an existing element, or thesis, with contradictions inherent to its structure. These contradictions unwittingly create the thesis' direct opposite, or antithesis, bringing about a period of conflict between the two. The new element, or synthesis, that emerges from this conflict then discovers its own internal contradictions, and starts the process anew. This is considered progressive because each stage in human development would be more advanced than the previous, similar to a human progressing from infancy to adulthood. These stages would continue until the conclusion of history is met, when man could attain self-consciousness and liberty. The freedom that was accomplished, according to Hegel, could only be true when all human beings were adequately conversant that they realise the morality of law which everyone would follow without doubt. Hegel’s dialectic represents a necessary process of human development as a series of stages or civilisations. He believed that the human mind progressed in a dialectical way and thus affecting history, but this dialectical law was not supposed to apply to reality.

Join now!

        Unlike Hegel, Marx believed that he was in the penultimate stage of history and that the highest and final stage of history was still to come, because he was unhappy with Hegel’s view that he was already in the final stage. However, Marx did share Hegel’s theory that history was a single dialectical process proceeding through a series of necessary stages to a predetermined end, culminating in a final stage. Marx created his own theory called Historical Materialism, the belief that material circumstances shape who a person is, and these material circumstances alter over time and therefore so do the ...

This is a preview of the whole essay