• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Analyse the claim that nowadays "the president's cabinet performs no useful functions

Extracts from this document...


Analyse the claim that nowadays "the president's cabinet performs no useful functions." Tom McKeown. At first sight, it might appear that the cabinet offers a means by which the entire executive branch can be directed and drawn together. The cabinet membership is made up of those who head the 15 executive departments, such as the secretary of state (Condaleeza Rice) and the secretary of defence (Donald Rumsfeld) and other figures such as the US UN ambassador (currently John Bolton), the chief of staff, and the head of the Office of Management and Budget. The cabinet is made up of professionals from a variety of different areas. One of its main sources of recruitment are former members of congress, e.g. Bush appointed 4 including John Ashcroft as Attorney General. State governors are also often recruited, e.g. Bush appointed Tommy Thompson of Wisconsin as Secretary of Health. City mayors are also sometimes recruited as cabinet members, e.g. Clinton appointed Federico Pena ex mayor of Denver as Secretary of Transportation. Recruitments are also sometimes made from outside the political spectrum, Bush appointed Rod Paige as Secretary of Education an ex professor at Cincinnati University. When making recruitments to his cabinet the president considers a number of different factors. ...read more.


Bush Snr prior to Malta summit with Gorbachev on foreign policy. They also provide an opportunity to check on the progress of legislation (Bush used 24 September 2002 to press for congressional action on military action in Iraq, the passage of the Homeland Security Bill and the budget. Lastly cabinet meetings provide an opportunity to solve inter-departmental disputes. Cabinet meetings also serve several functions for cabinet officers. They can resolve inter-departmental disputes, meet with other cabinet officers before/after meetings, also meetings give them an increased standing back at their departments, reporting back from the President (may be able to give team fresh impetus etc). Along with cabinet meetings there are also cabinet councils, smaller groups of relevant cabinet members to discus particular issues i.e. sub committees. Groups such as, the Economic and Domestic Policy Councils have been used extensively by Reagan, Bush Snr and Bush Jnr and reduce the need for cabinet meetings. The cabinet officer's role is to run their department, not to act as the Presidents principal advisors (the role of the EXOP) and they do not have a great impact in determining policy, especially since the emergence of the EXOP. They must take account of a number of things; Congress, who controls their funds, their own departmental bureaucracy, interest groups with strong departmental links and perhaps most importantly the President himself. ...read more.


A further reason why it might be argued that the cabinet performs no useful functions in modern times is that cabinet members are not always selected on their capability to do the job, they may be picked for other reasons, for example, when Clinton selected his cabinet so that it would 'look like America'. However it can be argued that even in modern times Cabinet is important for a number of reasons. Firstly as individually they have large departments to run. Also, as Cabinet departments have massive amounts of money to spend. It should also be pointed out that some Cabinet departments/ Heads of cabinet are more important than others e.g. Donald Rumsfeld, Defence, Condoleezza Rice, Home Secretary. I believe that whilst it is not accurate to state that today cabinet "performs no useful functions" as it evidently is still important for a number of reasons (massive budget to spend etc) it may be accurate to say that the influence or even importance of the cabinet is dwindling, with in recent times, the increased use of the EXOP in terms of things like policy. However the cabinet's role is dependent on the President who ultimately has the say over how influential and important his cabinet will be in his administration. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level European Union section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level European Union essays

  1. EU functions

    This has strong links to the European Union as both institutions contribute to this role. There are 3 main procedures that are used during the legislation process, consultation, assent and co-decision. The consultation procedure involves ideas being initially proposed to the parliament.

  2. The EU's CFSP and the Iraq Crisis: A Catalyst for Change?

    play a role in decision making.9 This makes the process inevitably long and inefficient. From a tactical standpoint, members often duplicate important segments of a security policy such as military capabilities and intelligence networks. It further complicates matters that the EU member states are members in other security organizations, such as the UN, NATO and the OSCE.

  1. The Importance of the Cyprus Issue in terms of the Accomplishment of the ESDP

    was more visible as NATO was representing the spirit of the western international community during the Cold War more than the EU.6 As long as Turkey felt the support of NATO, for whom Turkey's commitment to the Western camp was vital, it did not feel sidelined or entered into a

  2. Cultural Factors Relating to Fraternities

    One problem with psychological abuse is that it is often perceived to be harmless. This form of abuse is viewed as an initiation ceremony designed to determine one's worthiness as a prospective "brother" (Curry 95). Most existing fraternity members and the new members feel that the hazing process creates a bond between the two.

  1. C1 Analyse the factor, which contribute towards an effective team.

    It gives them experience about other departments, which they never experience. The disadvantages of group dynamics is that if employees swap their job roles and are not motivated in doing the work they can let them down. They may also not like the roles and finding it difficult.

  2. Issues pertaining to the professional conduct of IT professionals

    Having a global membership has meant that ACM has a great deal of GLOBAL influence, therefore at world summits etc, ACM is a force to be reckoned with, however in terms of national influence in a particular country, ACM has SLIGHTLY lost out as SOME governments don't care much for

  1. Boston University - A Presidential Search Gone Wrong

    What had happened at Boston University, the site reported, was a role reversal where the board served the president and not the other way around. When the important decision of who would run the university was being made, it was Silber and not the board who was in charge and

  2. What problems confront a President in controlling and coordinating the executive branch and how ...

    This is because the Cabinet members are loyal to two sides. Firstly, they are loyal to the President for choosing them and giving them a prestigious job, and secondly they are a representative of an area of society, and therefore thousands of people depend on them to get their voices heard.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work