• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Analyse the main strengths and weaknesses of Marx's sociological thought.

Extracts from this document...


Analyse the main strengths and weaknesses of Marx's sociological thought. "The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles" Marx and Engels (1967, p.67) Born in 1818, Karl Marx, using his philosophical and socialist ideas, attempted to show how conflict and struggle in social development were important in the development of a society. The works of Marx were influenced by three distinct intellectual traditions: German idealist philosophy, French socialism and British political economy. German idealist philosophy is an approach based on the thesis that only the mind and its content really exist. This philosophy maintains that it is through the advance of human reason that human beings progress. French socialism is a political doctrine that emerged during the French Revolution and emphasised social progress led by a new industrial class. British political economy was brought about by the social analysis of early capitalism by writers such as Adam Smith and David Ricardo. (Bilton, Bonnett, Jones, 2002, p.476) Using these concepts as a base to his theories, Marx further argued against the capitalist regime and was a firm believer of the revolution of the workers which would one day bring about the destruction of capitalism. Marx was also influenced by the philosophical ideas of Georg W.F. Hegel. However, unlike Hegel who was an idealist Marx was a materialist as he believed that the processes of reality as real, concrete existences in the social world. ...read more.


Exploitation also is able to provide those exploited to take individual or collective action against the system. This is the notion that Marx argues. Under capitalism the working class or proletariat (as known by Marx) produce goods for the benefit for the dominant owners of capital - the bourgeoisie. This class exploits the labour of the proletariat by paying them wages that are lower than the market value of the goods they produce. Capital was seen as nothing more than hidden human labour following as a 'dead' result of the workers 'live' labour as said by Gregor McLennan (The Story of Sociology). Marx went on to state: "Through alienated labour, therefore, man not only produces his relation to the object, and to the process of production, as alien and hostile men; he also produces the relation of other men to his production and his product, and the relation between himself and other men." 4 EPM (1844) MEGA I /3, p.91 Leading on from exploitation, Marx further argues the concept of alienation. Marx asserted that what singled out human beings from other species was our power to use our creative activity in order to influence our lives. Work could therefore be seen as a result of human intellect provided it was not alienating. For Marx, the alienation of labour reached its worst during industrial capitalism because workers were set to work on machines which performed meaningless tasks that were part of a larger process. ...read more.


Marx would argue that the causes of social occurrences lie at a level in which they cannot be seen by looking at individual events i.e. Marx was a realist. Although Marx makes it clear the material conditions that enable change, one could demand how the working class are able to take advantage of its historical opportunity. We could question whether the revolutionary consciousness happens on its own or whether it is necessary to have the leadership of a political party to help guide the process. (Bilton, Bonnett, Jones etc, 2002, p481). It could be easy to dismiss Marx's analysis on capitalism as we are able to see that it has not only survived, but has developed into a global system. One could also argue that as a system begins to develop crises, rather than destruct, it could have adapted itself in order to survive. The state also has an influence because it is the state that provides help for example, introducing welfare provision therefore reducing social conflict. However, despite these criticisms, Marxism is still relevant in the world of today and can still provide us with some questions we ought to consider. We could question whether capitalism is the defining feature of modern societies? Or question whether class membership is an important factor in our lives? This shows that although we may not fully support his views, Marx's ways of thinking at looking and analysing our society still has reference to the important questions we need to answer even today. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Political Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

3 star(s)

3 Stars - A thorough and articulate essay that demonstrates a strong understanding of the conceptual aspects of Marxism, and good explanatory powers.
Where this essay could be improved is with a greater focus on the question, and with a balanced structure designed to evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of Marxist thought more explicitly - the first part of the essay is more explanatory narrative than argument in favour of Marxism, whereas insufficient time is spent on the counter argument.

Marked by teacher Dan Carter 15/10/2013

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Political Philosophy essays

  1. 'Socialists have disagreed on both the means and ends of socialism' - Discuss

    They were very disciplined and relied on a strong leader. When power was gained this did not change, but was implemented on a nationwide scale. Finally, as opposition was completely removed with the overthrow of the old order, it was easy for this to lead to a totalitarian dictatorship.

  2. Conservatsim favours pragmatism over principle, discuss.

    The rolling back of the state therefore meant rolling back of welfare, which was criticized for creating a 'culture of dependency'. This gives the idea that the 'undeserving poor' do not deserve anything from society as they owe nothing to society.

  1. An essay on David Ricardo's Major Contribution to Economics

    I will now look at some of these theories in more detail. In 1810 as I mentioned earlier, Ricardo released his first major work titled 'The High Price of Bullion, A Proof of the Depreciation of Bank Notes'. In this paper he set out what is today known as the Classical Theory of Money.

  2. To what extent has socialism been defined by its opposition to capitalism?

    However other socialists don't place such value on the removal of the capitalist state, they believe that reform and restrictions on the market would result in balance where the impracticalities of revolution are removed but its aims are largely achieved.

  1. This essay is aimed to discuss the meaning of ideology and it different uses ...

    Its other central beliefs are human imperfection, Organic society, Authority and Property. (A. Heywood, 1992 pp27+69). Socialism is a political and economic theory or system of social organisation, based on collective or state ownership of the means of production, distribution and exchange similar to capitalism, it takes many diverse forms, and it is a continually developing concept.

  2. Distinguish between negative and positive freedom and explain the implications of each for the ...

    Furthermore, since Liberals believe the key function of government is to protect individual's natural rights, namely the right to 'life, liberty and property", it should not interfere in men's private matters. This emphasises the separation of "public" and "private" matters, which Liberals see as vital.

  1. What are the main advantages and limitations of the trait and type approaches to ...

    be underpinned by at least three independent source traits meaning that links between the two can be made when trying to determine personality. Other one is that it's established as the main test used with mangers due to its higher level of accuracy when compared with other tests.

  2. Do you agree with Churchill's statement that "democracy is the worst form of government ...

    Canada is under Parliamentary Democracy and follows a tradition known as responsible government. Reforming laws or passing laws goes through branch of government. Unlike Canada, United States follows a republican system of government. It also has three branches of government; legislative, executive, and judicial.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work