• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Are pressure groups good for democracy?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Are pressure groups good for democracy? There are many differing views on the role of the pressure group within the modern liberal democracy. Some political commentators claim that pressure groups led to an imbalance of democracy or a democratic deficit, because people who are members of pressure groups receive more of a political voice than those ordinary members of society whose access to democracy is their vote during elections. The opposite f this is the opinion which claims that pressure groups are not a form of democratic deficit but merely a way of the public getting its opinions herd and a form of communication between public and government. I am now going to analyse the pluralist model, and begin by answering the question what is a pluralist? Pluralists uphold the principle that political power in a liberal democracy is widely distributed, that continual competition between groups and that new groups constantly emerge. The pluralist would claim that the pressure group system is good for democracy as it allows people access to politics all the time as opposed to once every 4 years when an election is held. ...read more.

Middle

It is more likely that a pressure group will be ignored by government than listened to. Secondly pressure groups are not representative of the public, and often their members, this is because many groups do not have procedures for consulting their members. Thirdly because of the wide range of pressure groups different groups exert different amounts of pressure on decision makers therefore it is impractical and wrong to generalise. Fourthly pressure groups disguise the true nature of power. By claiming that decision makers merely arbitrate between the views presented by competing groups, supporters of pluralism give the impression makers are neutral when their primary concern is the maintenance of the capitalist system. Marxists like pluralists agree that organised groups are important. However, the Marxist view holds that the state is far from neutral and the imbalance in terms of political power between the groups. Thus not only will the state in liberal democracies favour business interests against those of organised labour, but their is also a huge difference between the resources available to the two, this is described by Miliband as 'imperfect competition'. ...read more.

Conclusion

This is often out of proportion of their true importance in society. Therefore they can be seen as a threat to parliamentary democracy. Pressure groups themselves may not be internally democratic. Therefore it is wrong to assume they will be outwardly democratic and it will lead to leaders and spokesmen expressing opinions which are not reflective of the democratic system. This means they become reflections of elitism rather than pluralism. Trade unions were suspected of this practice before reforms of the 1980's. The same could be argued today of the Automobile Association, the British Medical Association, or the Football Association none of which have a process for consulting their members. In conclusion, on the whole pressure groups make a significant contribution to the democratic system. They allow the views of the minority to be heard and they promote mass participation in the political system. However they can led to an uneven spread of democracy and certain people benefit more from the system than others. In my opinion on the whole pressure groups enhance the political system. So in turn they are an important part of modern liberal democracies. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Pressure Groups section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Pressure Groups essays

  1. Are pressure groups good or bad for democracy?

    However, is it good for democratic system if a small group of ordinary people can undermine the government? The politicians, who sit in the Parliament, have to be aware of numerous issues not only of national but also of those world-wide importance and look at them from different angles.

  2. Assess the contribution of interest groups to democratic government

    The Pluralist view is the main defence of interest groups in government. It is the idea that groups play a hugely valuable role in society as they disperse power so that no groups can dominate the political process. Under this, a powerful group such as the American Farm Bureau Association (Republican)

  1. The wealthier and the closer the pressure group is to the government, the more ...

    This suggests that the UK is still democratically active, as despite Greenpeace's overwhelming level of wealth, they have been unable to influence the government effectively. This may well have severe repercussion for democracy within the UK. The implication here is that the wealthiest pressure groups are more likely to have

  2. Are pressure groups good or bad for democracy? Harmful or Helpful?

    they provide representation on single issues which parties do not do. They provide an additional secondary tier of democracy behind elected politicians. They help to formulate policy. c) They provide info/specialist knowledge for decision makers (e.g., at Congressional hearings).

  1. Access the view that pressure groups strengthen democracy.

    With the use of protests of this small pressure group, Outrage! managed to equalise the age of consent for all sexual acts to 16 in the Sexual Offences Act in to 2000 by petitioning the Danish Embassy. It can be seen that creating links with pressure groups and the government

  2. The existence of pressure group makes government more democratic; the activities of pressure groups ...

    They are populist groups concerned with a single issue. Snowdrop is a cause group set up after the 1996 massacre at Dunblane, 16 children and a teacher were killed. This brought the fact that guns were readily available into the forefront.

  1. A Cabinet Minister once described Pressure Groups as Creatures which strangle efficient government. Discuss ...

    These include FOREST or ?Freedom Organisation for the Right to Enjoy Smoking Tobacco? who defend the rights of smokers who say that they have been heavily victimised by the public and the media since the smoking ban in Britain. Another group would be the Stonewall group who represent gays in

  2. Pressure groups revison notes

    Similarly, the co-operation of the farming community is vital to policies related to food supply/pricing and the preservation of the countryside 3. If the government relies on you eg: farmers you are more likely to be listened to 1. Public opinion: 1.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work