• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Assess the Changing Relationship between the Federal Government and the States

Extracts from this document...


Assess the Changing Relationship between the Federal Government and the States One of the biggest issues that divided the framers of the constitution was the role of Federal government in relation to the states. Eventually federal and state government were given separate powers, and the responsibility of checking on each other. The doctrine of nullification saw power to the states with a limited federal government. Since then different powers have swayed between state and federal governments, on balance the federal government has come out on top. A case example in 1816 where Martin v. Hunter's Lessee, saw that the judges of the Supreme Court of Virginia asserted that they had the power to decide whether a federal law was valid. This case involved the interpretation of a federal treaty; the judges felt that the federal Supreme Court was no more authoritative than they were in interpreting federal law. The Marshall court rejected that argument and established that when a federal law is ambiguous the US Supreme court (rather that any other state court) ...read more.


US (1935) and the Agriculture Adjustment Act of 1933 in US v. Butler (1936) FDR threatened the court with his Court Packing Plan, which helped him secure further policies such as the National Labour Relations Board v. Jones & Laughlin (1937) this became considered a turning point in the federal state relations, for the first time the Federal government was allowed to intervene in state affairs. This period became known as Co-operative Federalism. Later in the 1960's the federal government took on new responsibilities, such as social and welfare issues, known as Presidents Johnson's Great Society, involving increased welfare provision through Medicaid and Medicare, his vision was an America, free of socials ills, such as poverty, squalor, ignorance, fear or hatred and where the quality of life opened the door for all Americans; "For the first time in world history, we have the abundance and ability to free every man from hopeless want" L Johnson 1964. Again this cause another large rise in the federal budget, and bureaucracy, where planning and funding came from central government and implementation was carried out locally. ...read more.


This slashed his Federal spending bill and impacted schemes such as Medicaid - This was conceptually a return to Duel Federalism. Consequences are being noticed, now that States have lost Federal revenue, and most States have an unconstitutional budget-deficit. Causing States to raise its own income by raising taxes, and cutting spending. Showing that states had become subordinate to the needs of national government. Today State power is an significant force, with the power to control elections and law enforcement, they are responsible for public education and transport, and they set their own tax rates, as shown in the 6th Amendment. To conclude the influence of Federal Government has been strengthened throughout, through its increase in budget, personnel and military; becoming vitally important to the well being of the people. The Supreme court being the arbiter of disputes between State/Federal, has often permitted a considerable increase in the size of national intervention, by emphasising the broad and permissive character of the clauses in the constitution, however the Federal relationship has always avoided becoming unitary, so allowing acceptable degrees of state independency. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level United States section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level United States essays

  1. Examine the Causes and Consequences of the changing balance of power between the federal ...

    Since 1980 the US has seen its economic position strengthen along with its position as a world superpower and as a result, the federal government has seen its role reduced. This in-turn has seen the power of the federal government reduce and this is clear from the number of supreme

  2. Federalism: a form of world government.

    In existing federal states, there are essentially two specified levels of government: (a) the federal state and (b) the member states. However over recent years a very strong demand has developed, particularly in western Europe, to organise also the member states on the basis of federal institutions.

  1. Using Suetonius and Res Gestae, assess how effective Octavian was in enlisting Senatorial Support ...

    as the senators and: "exchanged social calls with many noblemen" (Suetonius 53) He therefore wanted the upper class to feel loyalty to the principle of the constitution, and willingly participate in the government. The Senate was comprised of many different men with many different agendas and so cannot be perceived

  2. How is Britain's constitution changing in the 21st century?

    Scotland has been appeased in devolution, as has the capital with the foundation of the Greater London Assembly. This has caused significant interest in certain English regions to challenge Westminster for its grip on power, and the government has served to satisfy them by establishing Regional Development Agencies.

  1. 'Examine the reasons for change in the balance of power between the federal and ...

    This period was regarded as 'New Federalism' Introduced in the 1960s as a reaction against the continuing expansion of the federal government's activity and expenditure, President Nixon was committed to a system of 'new federalism' to resolve the proper balance of power, regaining some of the states former authority.

  2. Is the EU a federal state?

    On the other hand we have Spinelli's constitutionalism. He believed in preparing a constitution and ratifying it. This second possibility proved to be impossible in the post-war period. Most of the West European states had just regained their status as sovereign nation states after World War II, were unwilling to loose such a significant account of their sovereignity in favour of a federal Europe.

  1. The History of the Original Ku Klux Klan

    the Union, that the Union and the States were indestructible, and that there was no way by which any of them could get out/ this had been announced in various resolutions of Congress and proclamations of Mr. Lincoln, and was in fact the only theory on which the position of

  2. Assess the view that the US Constitution often ensures limited government

    Originally, the framers of the constitution thought a bill of rights was unnecessary. This was because they felt that specific guarantees of fundamental rights were unnecessary because the Constitution already included certain prohibitions[25]. They also believed that there was a danger in enumerating specific civil liberties, in that future governments

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work