• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Assess the Criticisms of the Various Electoral Systems Used In the UK

Extracts from this document...


Assess the Criticisms of the Various Electoral Systems Used In the UK There are a number of criticisms that can be placed against the various electoral systems that are used in the UK. The criticisms themselves vary with the electoral system against which they are alleged. One of the systems in question is first past the post. Ftpt is used in general elections. Specific criticisms of this system are that the election results do not necessarily reflect the views of the electorate as a whole. This is because the number of seats does not reflect the number of votes cast for them. There have been instances where the winning party has fewer national votes than that of the opposition. One example of this having occurred is in February 1974 in which Labour won with fewer votes overall but more than their opponents. No recent Government has had 50% or more of the votes cast. Those who criticise ftpt claim that the effect of the system is to over represent the winning party. This was shown in 1983 when the conservatives, with 42.4% of the votes, had 61% of the MPs elected in parliament. ...read more.


This can make it more difficult for the party in question to rule and legislate. Critics also say that the link between representative and their constituents is significantly weakened. The link between constituents and popular known candidates can be damaged or broken. This is because constituents vote for the party as opposed to the candidate themselves. This can lead to the constituents feeling alienated from their representatives. The system also places more power in the hands of the parties. This is because they compile the lists and determine where on the lists candidates will be placed. However, despite these complaints against it, the cpl system is the most proportional system in use in the UK and is therefore the fairest system to all political parties in the running. It also means therefore that votes are not wasted as the electorate vote for their first choice instead of voting tactically for candidates. It also helps minorities to be represented such as women and candidates from ethnic minorities. Another system in use is AMS which is used for the Scottish Parliament and the Welsh and London Assemblies. It is a hybrid system which combines fptp and the closed party list system. ...read more.


However, STV provides a good connection between votes given and seats allocated. It is also fairer to small parties and minorities as there are in Northern Ireland where it is used. It also gives the voter greater choice as they can choose between candidates from the same party. The Supplementary Vote system is used in London Mayoral elections and allows voters to express a second choice when placing their vote. It has been criticised because it is not proportional. The victor always seems to be the compromise vote with the first preferences not providing a victory. This means that it would provide a "fair" result to a party like the Liberal Democrats which would not be mathematically justified. It would also reward parties that have concentrated support rather than that same support spread across the country like the fptp system. However, the system is more likely to lead to stable majority governments which are favourable in both the eyes of the electorate and politicians. It also maintains the link between constituents and politicians because they are able to vote for a candidate as opposed to a party in general. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level United Kingdom section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

3 star(s)

3 stars - In terms of the question asked the essay addresses a thorough range of voting systems, and is logical in describing the relative strengths and weaknesses of each system. Relevant examples are largely applied effectively, though not always consistently, throughout the essay.
Where this piece could be improved would be through greater explanation of the workings of each system, and why the function as they do - this would demonstrate a deeper understanding of the topic. Secondly the essay would benefit from increased analysis and evaluation - the strengths and weaknesses were listed as points rather than being compared and weighed up - there was little direct comparison of the different systems and there was no final conclusion that addressed the overall question directly.

Marked by teacher Dan Carter 10/09/2013

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level United Kingdom essays

  1. Government & Politics Revision Notes

    Disadvantages of a Representative Democracy > Big gap between people and government -Representative democracy always means that there is a gulf between government and the people. > Unreliable Representatives -Representative Democracy places too much faith in politicians, who are always liable to distort public opinion by imposing their views and preferences on it.

  2. To what extent is Parliament representative?

    Furthermore Blair declared war on Iraq because he judged it best for the national interest, though there was nationwide protest. This is the major issue with this type of representation - Burke first makes the assumption that the representative's judgment is more valid than the electorate; secondly, he essentially claims

  1. To what extent have constitutional reforms since 1997 reduced the powers of the UK ...

    age and changing the voting system but never got round to putting them into place, maybe down to the fact that he did not have long in government and had other bigger issues like the credit crunch of 2008. However one reform that Brown did complete was the introduction of the Supreme Court.

  2. Some differences and similarities between the Australian and United States federal legislatures

    There are 15 secretaries of departments as well as heads of many other executive branch and independent agencies and commissions. The Prime Minister is replaced or loses the position if members of the governing party vote for a replacement or if that party loses its majority in the House.

  1. What are the main features of representative democracy? In what ways has political participation ...

    million, however in 1989, this had dropped by 600,000, to 1.1 million. In 2006, it had dropped to a low of 0.6 million, showing the ever declining decrease in political participation and has stayed at this level ever since. Just over 1% of the UK population are affiliated with any

  2. There is no such thing as a perfect electoral system Discuss.

    There are two main parties with strong nationwide support, giving them a good chance of winning a parliamentary majority; this is in part due to the disproportionality. The lack of voter choice can be seen in the election results since 1945, as for the last 65 years there has only been a Labour or Conservative, single-party government.

  1. Should the Westminster Electoral System be Reformed?

    The arguments in favour of the retaining FPTP are much more prominent and convincing. Firstly, FPTP is very simple to understand in comparison to other electoral systems. In FPTP voters only have to select one candidate whereas in other voting systems, for example AV, voters have to select many preferences, which over complicates the process of voting.

  2. Apart from referendums, explain three ways in which democracy in the UK could be ...

    began which attract the younger generation, meaning that there is not a crisis at all. 2) a) Using examples, distinguish between promotional and sectional pressure groups. Promotional pressure groups endeavour to promote a particular cause, and for this reason are sometimes called ?cause? groups.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work