• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Assess the extent to which Members of the Northern Ireland Legislative Assembly have been successful in carrying out their functions.

Extracts from this document...


Transfer-Encoding: chunked ´╗┐Assess the extent to which Members of the Legislative Assembly have been successful in carrying out their functions. [26] MLAs have three main duties: scrutiny, legislating and representing. MLAs have come under sustained attack for what many perceive to be their failure to carry out the functions assigned to them by the Good Friday and St Andrews Agreements. Careerism, party loyalty, ignorance and incompetence have all been given as reasons for this failure. In examining whether or not this is a justified belief, a good place to start is looking at how MLAs have been unsuccessful in their scrutiny role. Many feel that they have not been effective in scrutinising the Executive, for a variety of reasons, such as their self-interest. For example, MLAs may fear that if they scrutinise the Executive too much, especially if it is a minister from their own party, then they might lose their position in the party or miss out on the opportunity for promotion. It has been argued that MLAs are too self-interested to properly hold the Executive to account, and the recent expenses scandal would be evidence for this. The dominance of the Assembly by the two leading parties has also been cited as a cause of poor scrutiny. This is especially so with the abuse of the Petition of Concern. ...read more.


A DUP or SF committee member therefore is highly unlikely to challenge a Minister from their own party. Committees are often engineered to give the Minister 'protection', meaning heavy hitters in the party are brought in to support their Minister. This does not lead to good scrutiny. The alternative view is that this is far too harsh a judgement of MLAs, many of whom have become increasingly active in scrutiny and in participating in the legislative process. A key way that MLA scrutinise the executive is through debates. Moreover, debates are another way that MLAs have been successful in holding the executive to account. Debates take place during plenary meetings in the Assembly Chamber on Mondays and Tuesdays. MLAs debate Bills, particularly Executive bills, at several stages during the law-making process. At the Second Stage they debate the general principles of the Bill and decide if it is a law that the Assembly thinks it should pass. There are no time limits on legislative debates ? all MLAs who wish to speak must be given the opportunity to do so. There are also opportunities to hold the Executive to account through adjournment debates. An Adjournment debate is possible at the end of each plenary sitting and can last for up to one hour. The purpose of an Adjournment debate is to promote debate on a matter without requiring the Assembly to come to a decision. ...read more.


MLAs can represent their constituents by asking questions related to their needs. There are four types of question: Questions for Oral Answer; Questions for Urgent Oral Answer (to Ministers in the Chamber); Written Questions; and Priority Written Questions. Ministers must reply to Questions for Oral Answer during a plenary meeting of the Assembly in the Assembly Chamber. This meeting is known as Question Time. It is a very public way for Ministers to explain what they and their Department are doing. Question Time takes place in the Assembly Chamber between 2.00pm and 3.30pm on Mondays and Tuesdays. For example, in 2015 Jo-Anne Dobson who is the UUP MLA for Upper Bann asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety for his assessment of the impact the Minister of Education's decision to withdraw the funding for the Early Years Fund will have on the health and well-being of the children in her constituency. However, some would argue that this is only because they are looking for re-election rather than genuinely caring about their constituents. To conclude, MLAs have generally been successful in carrying out their roles as representatives, legislators and scrutinisers. However, there are still aspects that could be improved, such as the petition of concern. The decision of the UUP and SDLP to go into opposition after the most recent election will change how MLAs are able to carry out these functions and hopefully it will lead to better scrutiny, but only time will tell how effective this will be. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level United Kingdom section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level United Kingdom essays

  1. Evaluate the above statement and consider the extent to which you think it is ...

    that of the body of the party, is concerned: disquiet and outright discord may be seen during Cabinet meetings, and political bartering may take place there, but by custom and practice, Cabinet Ministers will not attempt to thwart the Prime Minister's plans for the state's future11 - if for no

  2. Can parliament bind it's successors with the provision in the Northern Ireland Act 1998, ...

    way in which the Act may be repealed, through a majority poll by the people of Northern Ireland. A good example of a Parliament possibly binding its successors as to 'manner and form' can be found in Hilaire Barnett's Constitutional and Administrative Law.

  1. Political Awareness

    He is also a Church Commissioner; an Honorary Fellow of the Society for Advanced Legal Studies; a Trustee of the Hunterian Collection; Chairman of the Glasgow University 2001 Committee; and a Vice-Patron of the World Federation of Mental Health. Lord Irvine's title comes from the village of Lairg in the District of Sutherland in the North East of Scotland.

  2. Assess the view that since 2007 the Northern Ireland Assembly has been a legislative ...

    become more experienced in assessing the merits of Executive legislative proposals and in putting forward viable alternatives. A further example of the Assembly passing effective legislation is the plastic bag levy by Environment Minister Mark Durkan SDLP. This piece of legislation borrowed on legislation in Wales and the Republic of Ireland.

  1. Is the House of Commons effective at carrying out its various functions?

    This is the 1911 Act of Parliament. The final stage in the Royal Ascent is the process by which the queen signs the bill. The Act of Parliament has now gone into the statute book and must now be obeyed by all citizens of the UK.

  2. Explain the parliamentary stages through which government bills must pass before becoming law, making ...

    Minister would then make a statement that even though he is not able to make the statement of compatibility, he still wishes the House Of Commons proceeds with the bill. However some bills may proceed without s19 like the Dangerous Dogs Bills and the Child Support Bill.

  1. What was Thatcherism and was it Successful?

    Thatcher managed to reduce income tax in every annual budget from 1979 to 1990. However Thatcher created a 'poverty trap' i.e. wages were sometimes so low, and taxation so high for low income earners that it was not worth getting off unemployment benefits.

  2. Assess the reasons why the Alliance Party has always struggled in Northern Ireland politics. ...

    and it was also decided that the Executive will be handed the power to set its own rate of corporation tax with the aim of reducing it to the 12.5% rate of the Republic. Plans for a commission to examine the thorny issues of flags, identity, culture and tradition will proceed.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work