• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Assess The Success Of Attempts To Develop Comparative Theories Of Revolutions.

Extracts from this document...


Assess The Success Of Attempts To Develop Comparative Theories Of Revolutions The social revolutions that have occurred spasmodically throughout history are an important area of study, forming a distinct and drastic pattern of sociological change.. Unique to social revolutions is that basic changes in social structure and political structure occur together in a mutually reinforcing pattern, and it can be asserted with a fair degree of accuracy that changes occur through socio-political conflicts in which class struggles do play a role. In studying revolutions, the use of theory has been employed in an attempt to provide an explanation (within a context) that enables us to predict for the future which consequences should follow which events. Theories over the causes, course and consequences of revolution have developed significantly; early theories becoming limited in their aims and objectives. Instead, today comparative historical methods are a major influence on theoretical interpretation of revolution that gives breadth from the use of examples. The main difficulty encountered by historians in attempting to generalise revolutions using the theoretical approach has been the failure to test and modify explanations in light of subsequent historical cases. ...read more.


Wolfenstein's theory, which sought to explain revolution in terms of personality have also failed as it is not possible to apply clinical methods to past political leaders and it appears only valuable to look at the role of leader in a wider social context. Having said this, Gurr's ideas of relative deprivation do help in understanding a major aspect of revolution in giving a greater insight into what gives rise to discontent. Systems/Value Consensus theories explain revolutions as violent responses of ideological movements to severe disequilibrium in social systems. Chalmers Johnson's Revolutionary Change theory sees revolution as 'the purposive implementation of a strategy of violence in order to effect a change in social structure' that will change core-value orientations, which have become out of balance between the state and its institutions and the people. A successful revolution will accomplish the resynchronisation of a social system's values and environment that the old regime was unable to accomplish. The other most significant approach to revolutions comes in political conflict theories the most important of these being Charles Tilly's From mobilization to Revolution. This theory puts the conflict between government and opposing groups at the centre of it explanation of collective violence and revolution. ...read more.


The old regimes also had a number of broad similarities, in that all three revolutions occurred in wealthy and politically ambitious agrarian states. In revolution, all three cases saw the conjuncture of the incapacitation of the established central, widespread rebellion by the lower classes (particularly the peasantry), and attempts by mass-mobilising political leaderships to consolidate a revolutionary state. This again highlights the possibility for there to be consistent factors across revolutions - a large presumption that theories of revolution make. In light of this, and whilst paying significant attention to the key differences that also occur, it can be seen that, 'the similar socio-political features of the French, Russian and Chinese revolutions can be highlighted and explained in ways that would purposefully be missed by analysts determined to keep them in separate type categories'1. It is therefore clear that whilst general theoretical explanations of revolution can adapt to the many and varied forms necessary, they lack the applicability of grounded, specific case studies. It is a catch-22, in that neither can effectively be achieved without neglecting the other, but these theories have played a large part in sociological history, and this certainly, should not be ignored. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Political Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Political Philosophy essays

  1. Utilitarianism: Explanation And Study of Criticisms

    There are three types of Utilitarianism, Act, Rule, and Preference. Act Utilitarianism is where you look at the consequences of each individual action and assess which brings the most good. Act Utilitarians like Bentham do not see the need for rules when deciding morality, each situation is different.

  2. Discuss the conflicts between Employee and Employer by Marxist

    Usually, employers will ask to negotiate with the Trade Union again, and they will raise the wages or agree with what their employees asked for. However, in some cases that capitalists had won by waiting out the strikers - after all, working people need to eat and usually can not last long without income.

  1. A Study of Carl Rogers' Theory of Personality

    Some research has also tended to support the idea of changes in self-concept occurring as a result of therapy (Butler & Haigh, 1954; cited in Rogers, 1954). However, Maddi (1996) raises and interesting point regarding such studies. While it has been found that self-descriptions move toward ideals after counseling and

  2. Extent of key political ideas in directly influencing change and development .

    Clearly, the intellectual climate had some bearing on the growth of democracy, indeed women's suffrage was achieved not only as a result of fervent campaigning for equality but as a result of the valid contribution they made to the war effort. In France, however, the growth of democracy, developed differently.

  1. Critically assess the value of the models of Frank, Rostow and Clark-Fisher in our ...

    Frank's views have been described significantly as 'strident' and have therefore attracted criticisms of his dependency theory. These generally state that many of the developing worlds were impoverished before the arrival of European colonists. However, it is hard to concisely decipher the precise meaning for impoverishes and to the extent that it is relevant.

  2. How revolutionary were Lutheran and Calvinist theories of authority?

    This was a major movement of Christians in "Protest" of Church abuses (thus they were called Protestants). Luther's fundamental argument was that salvation was based on grace alone, not from the selling of indulgences. However the 95 Thesis were not written with the intent of starting a revolution of reaction against authority but for discussion amongst academics.

  1. Socialist uses of workers' inquiry

    Production is started not by what consumers are prepared to pay for to satisfy their needs but by what the capitalists calculate can be sold at a profit. Those goods may satisfy human needs but those needs will not be met if people do not have sufficient money.

  2. An analysis of the Marxist perspective on religion

    Marx does not believe that God actually exists outside of our own thoughts; all of our gods are our own creations, made to suit the need of a particular society. 'Man makes religion, religion does not make man' Marx would say that even within the Bible, the figure of God or Jesus changes according to the need of the writers.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work