• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critically assess the value of the models of Frank, Rostow and Clark-Fisher in our understanding of development issues.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Critically assess the value of the models of Frank, Rostow and Clark-Fisher in our understanding of development issues. There are a great number of differences between the models of Frank, Rostow and Clark-Fisher. For example, the Clark-Fisher sector model and W.W. Rostow's modernisation theory are merely temporally based models of development. However, Frank's dependency theory contains elements of both temporal and spatial factors. There is also the highly significant division to consider between dependency theories and modernisation theories. Dependency theories are the theories which build upon the idea that the rate of development of a country is largely a consequence of its relationships with other countries. On the other hand, modernisation theories are theories that build upon the idea that the rate of development of a country is largely to do with internal structures, government and culture of that country. According to Frank's dependency theory, countries can become more frequently dependent on powerful colonial powers. He believed that as the more powerful country exploits the resources of the weaker colony, the colony becomes more dependent. Frank in 1971 described the effect of capitalist development on many countries as "the development of underdevelopment". ...read more.

Middle

W.W. Rostow's modernisation theory incorporated five stages through which he believed that all developing societies must pass. His model was put together through his work on the growth of industrialisation in the UK and USA. The five stages of the model are: traditional subsistence economy, preconditions for take-off, take-off to maturity, the drive to maturity and the age of high-mass consumption. These stages can be characterised by limited technology and a static and hierarchical social structure. Despite the fact that Rostow's model was proposed in terms of the national economic unit, he concluded that the development gap was explained due to different countries being at different stages of the model. Rostow was able to present a highly descriptive model of development in which much was left unsaid about how one stage leads to another. Rostow, like Frank, did commit himself to a number of hypotheses. His theory is evolutionist, as it sees social and economic change as unfolding through a fixed set of stages. It is also un-linear because all countries must pass by the same route and in the same order. There can be no leaps, shortcuts, choices or alternative routes to development. ...read more.

Conclusion

This increases the diversity of industry within a country or region. The UK has a good example in the cotton industry as it encourages textile machinery, and service industries. Also, the ability of the Clark-Fisher sector model to interact with other models such as Rostow's modernisation theory, the Demographic Transition Model and Myrdal's cumulative causation can only work in its favour. The problems with the Clark-Fisher sector model are far more easily understood than either of the previous two discussed models. The sector model is highly descriptive and offers only a crude level of analysis. It does not however say how or why a country has developed, and it also does not show the internal variations which can exist within a country. All three of these development models contribute significantly to the understanding and different interpretations of development, in one form or another. However, because of the flaws in each of the three models which have been identified when the models were produced, none of them can claim to be the leading authority on development, and maybe if these models were used in conjunction with further models of development from Wallerstein, Sutcliffe or Friedmann, then they would become more apparently clear. ?? ?? ?? ?? William Cooper ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Political Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Political Philosophy essays

  1. Utilitarianism: Explanation And Study of Criticisms

    But, a viable moral theory should not have such problematic and inconsistent prescriptions. The hard problem comes in the following form. It could be the case that utilitarianism demands an action, which is incompatible with fair play or fairness. In the early 1800s slave labour produced the most amount of good for the most amount of people.

  2. How and why does Locke explain the creation, value and protection of property?

    Locke believes that we can, but there is no one to regulate or make sure that we don't put our property unto an external object at the expense and disadvantage of someone else. History clearly shows that human nature is not such as Locke believed it but rather that we are capable of evil and aggression towards each other.

  1. The development of fascist doctrine.

    Our restricted concern is with the systematization itself, the emergent social and political philosophy which attained maturity with the fully explicit synthesis of Gentilean idealism and Fascist political doctrine that took place in 1932. Here the focus of attention will be directed to a summary outline of Fascism's mature social and political doctrine.

  2. Nigeria Country Study

    Ten years ago, if you asked an expert in the global business community to associate a country with these statements, "India" was the expected reply. Today, a similar opportunity exists in Africa, mainly Nigeria, which in particular, is poised to make massive strides in the global business world.

  1. Iran Country Study

    - Beginning of Islamic Revolution; protests begin to mount tension between rioters and police forces. * 1980 - Shah completely deposed; constitution adopted by the people. * 1980-1988 - Iran-Iraq War * Religious and Cultural Background * Ethnic composition (% of total population as of 2003)

  2. Is Increasing Dependency an Inevitable Result of the Development Process?

    Modernisation theory had been criticised for stressing obstacles to development that were internal to countries and ignoring international relations. Dependency theory stressed the latter and has been criticised itself for neglecting the former. This is only one of the criticisms of dependency theory which have led to it falling out of favour in recent times.

  1. Assess critically Marx's distinction between ideology and science

    "Once upon a time", he points out with a degree of sarcasm, "a valiant fellow had the idea that men were drowned in water only because they were possessed with the idea of gravity."[11] Some of the German ideologues were like this valiant fellow: they became so captivated with their own ideas as to neglect the persistence of reality.

  2. Analyse one model of abnormality I am going to analyse the biological model

    These studies however do not show whether it is a cause or an effect. Finally, neuroanatomy. This suggests that it is the brains structure that determines whether someone becomes mentally ill. According to recent studies schizophrenics tend to have different shaped brains compared to 'normal' people.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work