• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Differing Notions of Citizenship

Extracts from this document...


In Chapter 5 of Pierson, the notion of 'citizenship as membership' suggests that citizens are granted a prestigious position as members of the state upon birth. There is a strong link with territory and citizenship and an importance placed on the concept of nationality (Pierson 128). To be lucky enough to receive this 'membership' in the 'country club' of the state gives one special status and privileges while it precludes others from the same luxuries. This rather simple analogy is effective in outlining the benefits of being born a member of a prosperous state. It also emphasizes the inclusive/exclusive aspects of citizenship as membership. As Pierson notes, "...it is overwhelmingly at [the nation-state] level that the privileging of citizenship and the practice of social closure against outsiders has been observed" (Pierson 130). 'Citizenship as status' is parallel with 'citizenship as membership' since it too reinforces the notion of nationalism. However, status diverges from membership since it makes a claim to a less normative quality - the 'imagined community.' ...read more.


A feature that Parekh conceptualizes in the cultural framework includes, "...institutionally embedded multicultural practices rather than assimilation or mere tolerance" (Stevenson 72). It is evident that there is a fine line between granting too much to multicultural enhancement and risking national traditions, and reinforcing nationalism to the point where multicultural views are not given enough attention. As Stevenson puts it: "...we should be careful to avoid a false universalism that simply gestures towards the equality of the globe's cultures and avoid a form of cosmopolitan optimism that assumes that national cultures do not remain important centers of power and identity" (Stevenson 73). Overall, the concept of cultural citizenship seeks to embody nationalism (as in the membership and status conceptions) while advocating pluralism in a global society that unites so many unique cultural qualities. In relation to The Swedish Government's EU Policy Goals for 2002, three primary relationships can be conceived. The first resemblance is in the overall nature of both cultural citizenship and the EU Policy Document. ...read more.


express a similar sentiment to the pluralistic attributes of cultural citizenship. Furthermore, the pluralistic conception of the EU Policy Document is conveyed in the section on 'The future direction of the EU must be subject to open and broad debate.' Here, the document expresses the need for intergovernmental conferences to, "...be composed of representatives of Member State governments, national parliaments, the European Parliament and the Commission" (Swedish Government 11). The range of groups that the document prescribes to be involved in intergovernmental talks is in line with the pluralistic conception of cultural citizenship and the need for deliberation to find common, unified interests. The final relationship is most clearly defined as a mutual goal of retaining national interests. As it has been made clear, cultural citizenship, although focused on pluralism, reserves the importance of nationalism. Likewise, the Swedish EU Policy Document, although centered on integration with European goals, also realizes the importance of retaining national interests, and safeguarding against the compromising of these interests. This is evident through the advocating of a need, "...for national reflection" (Swedish Government 11) before policies are put into motion through intergovernmental action. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level European Union section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level European Union essays

  1. A clear explanation of key underpinning economic theories relevant to the EU.

    Firms are now having to pay all workers at the age of 18 or above a fixed rate which is been introduced by the Social policy. Firms must pay this as this is mandatory which is increasing costs for a business.

  2. "What is the importance of the concept of citizenship in the development of EC ...

    For all these directives there is one common factor, which is that the individual who is seeking to enforce a right under them is not economically dependant upon the benefits system of the host Member State. A new Part to the EC Treaty on 'Citizenship of the Union' was created by the TEU and confirmed by the Treaty of Amsterdam.

  1. Is it possible to talk of civil society beyond the nation-state? Although a clich, ...

    Enlightenment when the religious basis for morality was fast disappearing and philosophers were seeking an alternative.4 The Scottish Enlightenment thinkers found an alternative in what they called civil society, "a realm of solidarity held together by the force of moral sentiments and natural affections."5 They thought that the "natural sympathy"

  2. What does citizenship mean in the European context?

    'third country nationals' A survey of five ethnic minority groups in five EU member states shows that most respondents [some having the nationality of the host country, some dual nationals and some long-term residents] believe that they have access to a satisfactory range of legal, political and social rights (Smith and Wistrech, 1998).

  1. EU actorness in relation to Environment policy and Development policy: An evaluation.

    Commonwealth countries in Africa , the Caribbean and the Pacific the possibility of negotiating with the EEC with regards their future trade relations. This led to the First Lom´┐Ż Convention (1975-1980) followed by three other ones: 1981-1985, 1986-1990 and 1990-2000.

  2. Issues pertaining to the professional conduct of IT professionals

    BCS first made its key impact in the legislative system in 1990 'The Computer Misuse Act2' where the act was co sponsored by BCS. Since than, BCS has gained respect across the board as a place of 'specialised knowledge'. BCS organises numerous events aimed at increasing awareness and knowledge in

  1. Discuss the suggestion that ''Britishness' is a story whose final chapter has been written.'

    Hinduism, Muslim, Gospel etc. are merely new 'mixtures' of Britsihness following in the tradition of the 'Saxon and Dane.' The formula is as it always has been, just the answer has changed. For Scotland 'the economic risk has always been cited as the principle argument against separation' the union allowed free trade throughout the empire.

  2. The Management of Global Crisis.

    terrorist groups has certain political objectives: its ultimate objective is to influence political decission /behaviour. Even though it does manifest as a criminal activity. Similar to most of the anarchic theories, terrorism is seeking to gain political control by means of psychological terror, implying indiscriminate terror.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work